Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Israel Palestine Israel Palestine

07-15-2018 , 05:09 PM
WTF is Hamas doing? Why don't they just make nice with Egypt, get the crossing open and then try to build up the economy and actually do some governing? Or make nice with the PA in the West Bank and get all those people's salaries back? Or *gasp* make nice with Israel? Instead they try to build up their armies, shoot rockets at Israel and incite riots on the border. They actually had a shot at a viable proto-state at one point in Gaza.

I was in an Israel-Palestine thread in another forum and I tried to get people's opinions on what practical steps that Hamas, as the governing entity of Gaza, could take to help alleviate their situation. They've been dealt a ****ty hand but you still gotta play your hand to the best of your ability. I suggested they make nice with Egypt so that they could open the border and end the blockade. After all, if they can move goods and people freely through Egypt then it doesn't matter at all what Israel does. I mostly got ignored but the responses I did get were "Don't try to shift the blame to Arab states" and "It's the occupier's responsibility to fix the situation not the occupied."

Last edited by synth_floyd; 07-15-2018 at 05:19 PM.
07-16-2018 , 05:02 AM
^ you just can't play 27o no matter your ability. Israel has borders on lock down and is in total control of the economy, water, electricity etc.
07-16-2018 , 06:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 57 On Red
They don't. Even though the rockets, crude home-made devices, inflict virtually no casualties, the Israelis will occasionally kill a few thousand people in response, by deliberately bombing and shelling schools and hospitals and of course firing tank shells at people working in their own fields.

You mean the hospitals and schools the terrorists fire their rockets from?

Israel does not accidentally hit civilians. They do it on purpose. They even put out sofas on the hillside overlooking Gaza, creating an 'open-air cinema' as they call it, and drink beer and cheer while they watch the murder being done.

I'm pretty sure Israel give like 30 minutes warning before bombing civilian property that is close to terrorist targets.

Remember when the Palestinians were literally having parties in the streets on 9/11?

What you actually mean is:-- 'Israelis are mostly Europeans and therefore white people and Palestinians are brown people, and white people have a holy duty to kill brown people and brown people have no right to live, so yay racism.'
Yeah, we all know how racists love defending Jews.

EDIT: Don't know how to separate my replies from that trolls post
07-20-2018 , 11:30 AM


embarrassing for everyone involved
07-20-2018 , 11:42 AM
In one story I read Netanyahu said both these things (paraphrasing)

How dare you question the only democracy in the region

And

We have to balance democracy and Israel's Jewishness
07-20-2018 , 12:34 PM
Also removed Arabic as an official language.

It's a ****ing ultra right wing state and no home to the Arabs.

Did someone say apartheid? How long before practicing their religion is outlawed?
07-20-2018 , 01:26 PM
The Nation State Bill is... not good.

https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/...onal-1.6291906

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/i...-world-n893036

The Zionist project only worked at all, given its essentially 19th-century, ethno-nationalist nature, if sufficient allowance was made for the Arabs whose land it actually, historically is. The Declaration of Independence made no discrimination -- or, by sleight-of-hand, appeared not to, even though it did really. The 1967 war of expansion, touted as a triumph, was in fact a disaster. And Israel is now drifting from secularism, pluralism and democracy to racism, apartheid and theocracy. It's bloody depressing.

Last edited by 57 On Red; 07-20-2018 at 01:32 PM.
07-20-2018 , 03:23 PM
There was a pretty bad incident today in Gaza that is still not publicized (although rumors circulating for the past few hours). IDF is attacking ever since. You know, the usual summer routine.
07-20-2018 , 03:32 PM
'Wide scale attack launched after Hamas shoot at soldiers'

Headline I seen.

So IDF get to try crush the Gazan's because someone just shot at soldiers?
07-20-2018 , 03:36 PM
They didn't ask my permission
07-20-2018 , 03:41 PM
What was the pretty bad incident you mentioned?

The rumour will do.
07-20-2018 , 03:50 PM
I imagine it's a dead IDF soldier or more from sniper fire on the Gazan border. Probably the first since the 2014 Tzuk Eitan operation. This is usually how new ones "operations" start.
07-20-2018 , 05:43 PM
Yeah it sounds like an IDF soldier has been killed by a sniper on the Gaza border.
07-20-2018 , 05:46 PM
Ugh not good
07-20-2018 , 08:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by martymc1
'Wide scale attack launched after Hamas shoot at soldiers'

Headline I seen.

So IDF get to try crush the Gazan's because someone just shot at soldiers?
How could that post possibly make you think that she was saying it was okay? Oh yeah it's you.
07-20-2018 , 09:07 PM
I didn't think Yuv was doing anything other than giving some news. But it's you and we're all anti semites.

Gfy.

Was rhetorical and a witty reply tbf.
07-20-2018 , 09:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by martymc1
I didn't think Yuv was doing anything other than giving some news. But it's you and we're all anti semites.

Gfy.

Was rhetorical and a witty reply tbf.
It's hardly everyone. Lately it's mostly just you. A lot of other posters here are quite clearly against the Israeli government. Certainly they are not all anti-Semitic.
07-21-2018 , 04:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by martymc1
'Wide scale attack launched after Hamas shoot at soldiers'

Headline I seen.

So IDF get to try crush the Gazan's because someone just shot at soldiers?
Killed a soldier. They've also burnt hundreds of acres of land in the last few months with their kites....and now apparently are using falcons to start their fires. As bad as the Israeli government can be, the Gaza goverment make them look like saints imo.

They've wanted Israel to attack Gaza for months knowing that when they do people like you will ignore these acts of terrorism, and will be "outraged" by Israel's retaliation on Hamas targets, while ignoring Hamas targeting Israeli civilians.
07-22-2018 , 02:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by martymc1
Also removed Arabic as an official language.

It's a ****ing ultra right wing state and no home to the Arabs.

Did someone say apartheid? How long before practicing their religion is outlawed?
every public street sign, every public anything, is written in hebrew, arabic, and english. just about everywhere. I just visited and traveled through almost the entire country anf the only area where i did not see arabic was up north in ultra orthodox tsfat.
07-22-2018 , 02:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by roddy
Killed a soldier. They've also burnt hundreds of acres of land in the last few months with their kites....and now apparently are using falcons to start their fires. As bad as the Israeli government can be, the Gaza goverment make them look like saints imo.

They've wanted Israel to attack Gaza for months knowing that when they do people like you will ignore these acts of terrorism, and will be "outraged" by Israel's retaliation on Hamas targets, while ignoring Hamas targeting Israeli civilians.
07-22-2018 , 02:52 PM
The nation state bill is just a bunch of right wingers wanking off and making themselves feel good. It doesn't change anything on the ground. Israel has a Jewish majority and as long as it does there is no need to state "this is the Jewish state." And if hypothetically Israel did lose its Jewish majority they would just repeal it anyway.

But the Palestinians love a good wank as well, with the kite throwing and the demonstrations in Gaza. They don't change anything but it makes them feel good.
07-22-2018 , 03:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by synth_floyd
The nation state bill is just a bunch of right wingers wanking off and making themselves feel good. It doesn't change anything on the ground. Israel has a Jewish majority and as long as it does there is no need to state "this is the Jewish state." And if hypothetically Israel did lose its Jewish majority they would just repeal it anyway.

But the Palestinians love a good wank as well, with the kite throwing and the demonstrations in Gaza. They don't change anything but it makes them feel good.
No, it's the government declaring its agenda.

https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/...bomb-1.6294021



It's not good.
07-23-2018 , 04:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by roddy
Killed a soldier. They've also burnt hundreds of acres of land in the last few months with their kites....and now apparently are using falcons to start their fires. As bad as the Israeli government can be, the Gaza goverment make them look like saints imo.

They've wanted Israel to attack Gaza for months knowing that when they do people like you will ignore these acts of terrorism, and will be "outraged" by Israel's retaliation on Hamas targets, while ignoring Hamas targeting Israeli civilians.
Need independent verification for anything coming out of Israel. Dead soldier story could easily be fake cover story for the apartheid laws that should see Israel removed from the UN in line with other apartheid states.

And in any case if the story is true the kill ratio is still about 100/1
07-23-2018 , 06:40 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DrRobotnit
Need independent verification for anything coming out of Israel. Dead soldier story could easily be fake cover story for the apartheid laws that should see Israel removed from the UN in line with other apartheid states.

And in any case if the story is true the kill ratio is still about 100/1
There were restrictions placed on South Africa, but the only country kicked out of the UN has been Taiwan and that was just because of China.
07-23-2018 , 08:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DrRobotnit
Need independent verification for anything coming out of Israel. Dead soldier story could easily be fake cover story for the apartheid laws that should see Israel removed from the UN in line with other apartheid states.

And in any case if the story is true the kill ratio is still about 100/1
LOL fake cover story

      
m