Quote:
Originally Posted by Turn Prophet
Police unions have their fair share of scumbags to be sure, and if there is one form of union I might be in favor of abolishing, it would probably be police unions because their clout extends to the realm of life-or-death violence, which really does need to be kept on a tight leash by society at large.
But that said, it's absurd to suggest that unionized police forces are the sole or even primary reason that cop violence against civilians is going unpunished. Police violence exists in a terribly complicated matrix of:
- Politics, which would still exist even without the police unions
- Legions of cop defenders who excuse misconduct because cops have a "tough job," "split-second decisions," etc etc
- Racism, which feeds into the above two factors
And so on.
Well **** if you strawman someone hard enough you can dismiss what they say!
Of all the fixes proposed to attack this problem, the one that has a chance at quickly working is placing common sense limits on the gains that police unions have won. This means allowing bad cops to be fired much easier. This means removing various laws that allow police to become special citizens. It doesn't mean permanently abolishing them ffs.