Quote:
Originally Posted by Namath12
I used to assume that SCOTUS nominee pulls have always come from the Ivy League (read: Yale or Harvard) but it's actually a fairly recent phenomenon. Now it's just a carryover of the prestige-whoring of the legal profession in general.
My favorite, and one of the most thoughtful, recent justices is John Paul Stevens, who went to Northwestern. Ginsberg went to Columbia.
Thing is, when you want to appoint a terrible half-wit conservative whose views are way outside the mainstream of the profession, you want to burnish him (not really any "hers") by having him come from a "top 3" school.
It's really damn hard to find smart, accomplished people who will decide cases like republicans want them to after being confirmed. Apparently the best bet these days is East Coast prep school scions, who still have something of an "affirmative action" path to Harvard, Yale, Princeton. If they are farily dilligent and kiss the right asses they can go to a "top 3" law school and then kiss the right conservative professor asses there (who they know of beforehand because of their network) and land a good "feeder" clerkship with the right judges. It's still not an easy path, and many would-bes wash out, but it mints a few "conservative legal luminaries" every year, which is sufficient.
Smart conservatives are so rare that even Ted Cruz got a Supreme Court clerkship (Rhenquist) even though he is the embodiment of smarminess. That's real affirmative action.
Last edited by simplicitus; 09-17-2018 at 04:09 PM.