Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Breaking- Truck kills dozens in Nice, France Breaking- Truck kills dozens in Nice, France

07-14-2016 , 08:02 PM
Reminds me of shortly after the tsunami in south east Asia, when there were pics floating around the Internet of fat Europeans lazing on the beaches in their Speedos while dead people were being put in body bags a few feet away.
07-14-2016 , 08:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by revots33
Excellent post.
He didn't offer any solutions. Whining about Muslims isn't an "excellent post."

You know what makes people less religious? More money and more education. How about we start moving in that direction instead of bombing them to the stone age every time they kill another 1000 people?
07-14-2016 , 08:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
1/4 of French Muslims support an ideology as evil as Nazism and a group as evil as the Third Reich. Do you think cultural relativism and "softly softly, let's not upset the people with the vile ideology" is working?

How about:

- We stop claiming it's a "tiny minority". That's a straight out lie.

- We stop pretending Islam is a "peaceful religion" - it's the most violent, religiously fascist, xenophobic, misogynist, bigoted religion on the planet by a huge margin. Its worst elements are believed by a large proportion of global Muslims. Yes most Muslims are peaceful. So were most Nazis. Apologizing for Islam is like apologizing for Nazism. Just because there is moderate Nazism (and most Germans were moderate Nazis) doesn't mean Nazism should therefore be apologized for.

- We stop importing into our peaceful, open, female rights, gay rights, free speech countries, people who don't and can't respect those cultures due to their deeply ingrained ideologies.

Is that really so unreasonable?

Where I live, heavily armed soldiers have to patrol synagogues, Jewish schools and houses around the clock, because of a kind of violent antisemitism - widely taught in the mosques here - that hasn't existed since the Nazis, but that Islam brings with it. Jews are leaving France in record numbers because of it.

There's a problem here - let's say it. Let's talk about it. Let's admit it.

This is what happens when you're not even able to say "Radical Islamic Terror" and care more about vanity than actual people - including the Muslims brutalized by ISIS. It's what happens when your view of the world is informed by left-wing cultural relativism rather than reality.

Ideas matter. The conversations we have and how honest we are about this stuff matters. ISIS would not be anything like it is today and this attack tonight would not have happened if a person with a more sane understanding of the world was in the White House.
I agree that slowing Muslim immigration into places where there is a lot of homegrown terrorism, like France, is a legitimate discussion.

But other than that - do you have any solutions other than talking tougher, and what do you think that will accomplish?

I sympathize with you but I can't think of any way to put the genie back in the bottle that doesn't involve mass human suffering, can you?
07-14-2016 , 08:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by master3004
Nobody is going to ban you for that, but you aren't offering solutions. Ok, Islam is violent. Great, what now? Ban people from practicing it? Kill the Muslims?
Offer a compelling solution. Talk out against it. What are young Muslims to think when ISIS is telling them the TRUTH, and Western intellectuals, leaders and journalists are dithering and apologizing and saying Islam is just fine and that the West is to blame? People without direction look for strength and self belief, and the Western/the Left offers the exact opposite of strength and self belief.

In the mosques, they're told that gays and Jews are terrible and should be killed, etc, and we offer no compelling alternative. We don't even denounce it as "hate speech" and censure the Imams. Instead, they're invited to meet Obama and other Western leaders, while right wingers who are FAR less bigoted and dangerous and violent are (rightly) shunned. We bend over backwards to apologize for Islam.

Speaking out works. Marginalizing the bigots and misogynists (which is most of Islam if you look at global surverys) works. Look at how the far right has been successfully marginalized by constant hate speech against it (totally deserved). You could marginalize Islam too.

Quote:
How do you stop people from practicing a religion that you believe to be inherently violent?
You simply don't bring them into your country. The end.
07-14-2016 , 08:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by domer2
It needs to be excised from the planet like the deadly cancer it is. Easiest way to do that is probably Muslims themselves excising the worst elements, something that many have heretofore shown little interest in doing.
I guess we don't count all the Muslims fighting ISIS right now? But OK, I guess your proposed way to do convince moderate Muslims to "excise" their worst elements is to not so subtly imply that all Muslims are enemies of the West?
07-14-2016 , 08:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DVaut1
I don't understand this mentality. What does the precise thread matter? You think like the family's of the victims are logging into 2p2 to review our thoughts on this and might be offended by the political banter, but like, okay, if it's excised to some other thread, we'll spare them some pain?

Is this thread just for like -- nothing? Just facts and stuff? Isn't that what all the other news-sites on the internet and twitter are for?

I'm really perplexed where this ethic comes from. I am confident you are not alone but in feeling it but I just do not understand it.
The horribad gun-control stuff should be confined to a confinement thread. It doesn't need to spill over to everything within 5 posts.

Containment threads ftw
07-14-2016 , 08:05 PM
You simply don't bring them into your country. The end.[/QUOTE]

They are in your country.

They are in my country

They are in every country.

Now what?
07-14-2016 , 08:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
1/4 of French Muslims support an ideology as evil as Nazism and a group as evil as the Third Reich. Do you think cultural relativism and "softly softly, let's not upset the people with the vile ideology" is working?

How about:

- We stop claiming it's a "tiny minority". That's a straight out lie.

- We stop pretending Islam is a "peaceful religion" - it's the most violent, religiously fascist, xenophobic, misogynist, bigoted religion on the planet by a huge margin. Its worst elements are believed by a large proportion of global Muslims. Yes most Muslims are peaceful. So were most Nazis. Apologizing for Islam is like apologizing for Nazism. Just because there is moderate Nazism (and most Germans were moderate Nazis) doesn't mean Nazism should therefore be apologized for.

- We stop importing into our peaceful, open, female rights, gay rights, free speech countries, people who don't and can't respect those cultures due to their deeply ingrained ideologies.

Is that really so unreasonable?

Where I live, heavily armed soldiers have to patrol synagogues, Jewish schools and houses around the clock, because of a kind of violent antisemitism - widely taught in the mosques here - that hasn't existed since the Nazis, but that Islam brings with it. Jews are leaving France in record numbers because of it.

There's a problem here - let's say it. Let's talk about it. Let's admit it.

This is what happens when you're not even able to say "Radical Islamic Terror" and care more about vanity than actual people - including the Muslims brutalized by ISIS. It's what happens when your view of the world is informed by left-wing cultural relativism rather than reality.

Ideas matter. The conversations we have and how honest we are about this stuff matters. ISIS would not be anything like it is today and this attack tonight would not have happened if a person with a more sane understanding of the world was in the White House.
No.
07-14-2016 , 08:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by smrk2
As the people you're asking don't have the courage to answer, I'll answer and it's actually very simple. They don't want a "solution" per se. They want Western governments to carry out swift and disproportionate reprisals, like bombing the **** out of tens of thousands of Sunni Arabs where ever. If it works, cool, if not, hey, at least we got tough. They basically want a war war against "those savages", like a WW2 style effort, but they just don't want to fight or pay for it themselves.

Informed as they are, they surely know that Assad has already done a lot of that work for them, having killed 300,000 Sunnis in the last 3 years.. oh wait they don't know that.
This post is completely demented, and you don't speak for anyone. Get some help.
07-14-2016 , 08:07 PM
Yo Toothsayer:

Quote:
Ideas matter. The conversations we have and how honest we are about this stuff matters. ISIS would not be anything like it is today and this attack tonight would not have happened if a person with a more sane understanding of the world was in the White House.
I disagree totally.

Did this conversation just stop, or what? Can we keep going or will that be left-wing cultural relativism silencing you or something?

Just want to make sure we reach some consensus here that this conversation is actually happening, in fact it happens ALL THE TIME, all over the internet, all over TV, all of Fox News, all over Facebook newsfeeds: there's Team Muslims are barbarians, and then Team lolno. This conversation is happening, I promise, even if you don't like the fact people don't share your point of view, the conversation hasn't floated into the ether and you haven't been silenced.
07-14-2016 , 08:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
It's like people haven't read the Koran.

ISIS are just following the life and acts of Muhammed, who all Muslims consider blameless and an example of a good life.
And what about the billion or so Muslims who don't slaughter people in the same way Christians don't smite their neighbor working on the Sabbath?

All religions are ****ing stupid imo. One religion currently is being taken more literally, and might be more violent at it's core to begin with. That is a bad situation. But I'm only interested in solutions that don't end in the genocide or conversion of every Muslim on earth - which seems to be the end game of constantly harping on Islam and the Koran as the core of the problem.
07-14-2016 , 08:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by domer2
This post is completely demented, and you don't speak for anyone. Get some help.
Okay friend, I guess I must have hallucinated all that talk from Trump and Cruz rallies about bombing the **** out of ISIS, carpet bombing and making the sand glow, about murdering the families of terrorists, all of which got raucous cheers? I accept your retraction, no hard feelings.
07-14-2016 , 08:10 PM
Some of my friends were there; it's a carnage. I usually either watch 14th of july fireworks in Paris or Nice; this year was Paris...

on another dark/bitter note; chief of DGSE (french intelligence) predicted in an very recent interview that this would be the new modus operandi for attacks. Sickening
07-14-2016 , 08:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
I and thousands of panicked people ran for my life tonight, afraid of an ISLAMIC gunman (what we though it was before we found out it was a truck) and I'm not going to shut up about it.
The most emotional guy in the room right now is convinced that this is the time we all need to listen to his completely rational opinions about banning all Muslim immigration. Wheeee this thread's gonna set a new bar for AIDS.
07-14-2016 , 08:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by suzzer99
And what about the billion or so Muslims who don't slaughter people in the same way Christians don't smite their neighbor working on the Sabbath?

All religions are ****ing stupid imo. One religion currently is being taken more literally, and might be more violent at it's core to begin with. That is a bad situation. But I'm only interested in solutions that don't end in the genocide or conversion of every Muslim on earth - which seems to be the end game of constantly harping on Islam and the Koran as the core of the problem.
Right. The end game that helps is progress. Improving poverty worldwide. Improving technology worldwide. Vertical farming to prevent hunger worldwide.

These are the things that defeat violent religions. Not bombs, drones and bans on who can practice what.

I dislike religion more than anyone here, but fighting their hate with our vengeance does nothing for anybody. We need to invest hard in technology and be willing to share it with the world. Cure diseases, cure hunger, cure dirty ****ty water.
07-14-2016 , 08:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by domer2
What do you think the number is?

There's no other group killing innocent people by the tens of thousands, not even if you combine all other groups and individual attacks does it even get close.

Part of this "well maybe you're right it's a problem" shtick is a purposeful and convenient denial of reality.



It needs to be excised from the planet like the deadly cancer it is. Easiest way to do that is probably Muslims themselves excising the worst elements, something that many have heretofore shown little interest in doing.
So, no idea, that's what I thought.
07-14-2016 , 08:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jar Jar Bakes
Some of my friends were there; it's a carnage. I usually either watch 14th of july fireworks in Paris or Nice; this year was Paris...

on another dark/bitter note; chief of DGSE (french intelligence) predicted in an very recent interview that this would be the new modus operandi for attacks. Sickening
Hope everyone you know got out ok jar jar
07-14-2016 , 08:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by master3004
Right. The end game that helps is progress. Improving poverty worldwide. Improving technology worldwide. Vertical farming to prevent hunger worldwide.

These are the things that defeat violent religions. Not bombs, drones and bans on who can practice what.

I dislike religion more than anyone here, but fighting their hate with our vengeance does nothing for anybody. We need to invest hard in technology and be willing to share it with the world. Cure diseases, cure hunger, cure dirty ****ty water.
Poverty or lack of it isn't predictive of terrorism though.
07-14-2016 , 08:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vixticator
So, no idea, that's what I thought.
If you're just posting to troll, why are you posting at all?

0 engagement on the issues, just low effort garbage.
07-14-2016 , 08:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JayTeeMe
The horribad gun-control stuff should be confined to a confinement thread. It doesn't need to spill over to everything within 5 posts.

Containment threads ftw
Why? If we weren't arguing about the causes, motivations, possible policy solutions, political culture, whatever, then what is this thread for? It seems entirely appropriate here. I'll reiterate twitter, the TV, the rest of the internet are all better for capturing the latest news.
07-14-2016 , 08:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by domer2
If you're just posting to troll, why are you posting at all?

0 engagement on the issues, just low effort garbage.
Come now:

Quote:
Originally Posted by domer2 View Post
This post is completely demented, and you don't speak for anyone. Get some help.
You're a pretty egregious violator of just that ITT. Vix saying you have no idea is at least to the argument. "Get some help" is a pretty patent violation of the forum rules and needless dbaggery. I couldn't care less in a sense but if this is a pissing match about posting quality, you lose, hands down.
07-14-2016 , 08:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Huehuecoyotl
Poverty or lack of it isn't predictive of terrorism though.
Of course not, but more prosperity = less religious. Ipso facto, making less people religious will bring down religious terrorism.
07-14-2016 , 08:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by master3004
Hope everyone you know got out ok jar jar
Thanks

Still stressed about some people not answering texts; but its 2am here so the likely reason is that there are sleeping.

such a horrible+symbolic attack
Pieces of ****
07-14-2016 , 08:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jar Jar Bakes
Some of my friends were there; it's a carnage. I usually either watch 14th of july fireworks in Paris or Nice; this year was Paris...


Just horrible events, unimaginable.
07-14-2016 , 08:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DVaut1
Why? If we weren't arguing about the causes, motivations, possible policy solutions, political culture, whatever, then what is this thread for? It seems entirely appropriate here. I'll reiterate twitter, the TV, the rest of the internet are all better for capturing the latest news.
This thread is for honoring victims and calling Muslims bad names.

      
m