Quote:
Originally Posted by goofyballer
lol dude, if it was malicious I wouldn't have asked you for clarification. Calling him a nutjob doesn't preclude anyone from saying "at least he's not Lula/Dilma" if they think those people are worse, it's the Brazilian version of "at least Trump isn't Hillary".
It was completely dishonest, and typical of those who are unable to understand why the right is destroying the left because everytime someone tries to explain it to them they get accused of being a rightwinger. It's a tactic for shutting down discourse and communication that's typical of those who are ideologically blindered, and, unfortunately, very common on the right of the political spectrum.
It's very important to understand that what got Trump, Bolsonaro, Salvini, etc. into power is the same forces that got Macron and Podemos into power. It's massive disaffection with supposedly democratic political structures that fail completely to represent the interests of ordinary people against the overpowering interests of major commercial entities, such as banks and energy companies. Coupled with massive corruption in some particular leftist parties (e.g. Brazil), a lot of people just want change.
People are tired of being messaged, of things being framed for them, etc. They aren't as stupid as the elites (of both political stripes) suppose, some of them are even intelligent, and they are fed up with hearing one thing and seeing another. After ten years of one thing, they vote for the other, particularly if it appears not to censor itself. Oddly the racism, xenophobia, hatred, misogyny, etc. of the Bolsonaros and Trumps is sometimes appealing even to those it attacks, maybe not enough that they'll vote for these guys, but enough that they'll listen to them. It comes across as more honest than the pro-immigrant, anti-racist, pro-woman rhetoric of the left that appears not to be backed up by action, that appears directed at rich elites rather than at ordinary people.
Misogyny and homophobia are probably on the rise. It's a backlash to genuine changes in the situation of women and homosexuals in many societies. The same happened in the 1920s in Europe. People forget how much the vote for women threatened the church and similar entities, and how much of the fascism of that era was motivated by "decay of social conditions", and other similar phrases that can be understood as surrogates for keeping women in their place. The same is happening now to a certain extent.
Finally, the disdain the left shows for the Trumps and Bolsonaros only empowers them. People identify with the lack of respect they are shown, because people feel that the usual political infrastructure doesn't respect them either. An outsider, even if not really an outsider, really a rich bastard from within, earns sympathy that gets reinforced everytime he is attacked by the insiders, however meritorious the attack.
The solution are left wing candidates that aren't tools of the machine. The problem is that the left so far, in most countries, has failed to present any (Spain might be sort of a counterexample, but I'm afraid it will soon go the Italian way).