Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
2017 "Tax Reform": They'll Screw This Up Too, Right? 2017 "Tax Reform": They'll Screw This Up Too, Right?

12-22-2017 , 10:51 AM
The propaganda has already started, even on MSNBC I'm seeing ads telling me how great this thing will be for me. One would think those would have aired before the votes but nothing matters anyway.
12-22-2017 , 10:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheHip41
Let’s take a family with two kids
Why are we taking a random example...I don't have any kids. Just me and the wife.

Taxes be going DOWN. This bill is gonna save us thousands of dollars next year.
12-22-2017 , 11:07 AM
But your taxes won’t go down for 9 years

You will see nominal tax decrease for a few years and then a nominal tax increase for a few years after that.

In he meantime, these rich ****s get to have a top tax rate of 25% on all passive flow through income.
12-22-2017 , 11:11 AM
Same posters still continue to post, same posters seem to still be way out of touch with reality. MAGA, cant wait in 3 years to watch this forum cry again on election night when Trump wins in a landslide.
12-22-2017 , 11:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheHip41
But your taxes won’t go down for 9 years

You will see nominal tax decrease for a few years and then a nominal tax increase for a few years after that.

In he meantime, these rich ****s get to have a top tax rate of 25% on all passive flow through income.
How do you figure it's a nominal decrease???
12-22-2017 , 11:13 AM
As a pass through owner I'm not too mad.

this is lol tho:



12-22-2017 , 11:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by General Tsao
Uhh like what? I'm all ears here guys.
JFC, you are so grossly uninformed. Its literally called a "personal exemption" that currently allows you to deduct $4050 for each member of your household.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Person...(United_States)
12-22-2017 , 11:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BreakYaNeck
Same posters still continue to post, same posters seem to still be way out of touch with reality. MAGA, cant wait in 3 years to watch this forum cry again on election night when Trump wins in a landslide.
It took George W. Bush and his Republican cronies eight years to destroy the country's economy, but they managed to do it.

Just because you fail to see the train coming down the tracks doesn't mean it's not coming down the tracks.
12-22-2017 , 11:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bobman0330
So I have kind of a personal axe to grind with all the pundits who have circulated the idea that you can save money under the new bill by "forming an LLC." Normally people have all kinds of zany theories about the tax law and you can mostly just ignore them, but I'm already starting to see people who want to insert their LLC (or worse, their S corporation) into random transactions because they have heard that doing things through an LLC is going to save them money on taxes. And you can't just tell them that their personal LLC is literally disregarded for income tax purposes and is treated as if it did not exist, and therefore does nothing, because they've heard it on the teevee that you can save money by forming an LLC now.
So hypothetically if Charles Koch owned 100% of Koch Industries LLC he gets taxed at a higher rate than if he owned it 50/50 with his brother David Koch?
12-22-2017 , 11:37 AM
Also, I don't even see a 4 point drop in any bracket. wtf is taso talking about?
12-22-2017 , 11:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jsb235
It took George W. Bush and his Republican cronies eight years to destroy the country's economy, but they managed to do it.

Just because you fail to see the train coming down the tracks doesn't mean it's not coming down the tracks.
Its not... keep telling yourself that. Its seriously amazing at this place. Just a bunch of whiny liberals that do not have any idea what people want. Literally 0 clue. Literally cry about everything Trump does
12-22-2017 , 11:43 AM
you're probably forgetting that taso just has no ****ing clue what he's talking about. would love to have him actually do a breakdown of 2017 vs 2018 with his actual income numbers so we could all have a laugh at his errors.
12-22-2017 , 11:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pwn_Master
So hypothetically if Charles Koch owned 100% of Koch Industries LLC he gets taxed at a higher rate than if he owned it 50/50 with his brother David Koch?
No, it's the other way around. He would get taxed at the same rate owning 50% of Koch vs. owning 100% vs conducting the activities that Koch conducts in his personal capacity with no entity around at all. (Also Koch Industries is famously an S corporation, so it's not disregarded even if it's wholly owned by somebody.)
12-22-2017 , 11:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by prana
Also, I don't even see a 4 point drop in any bracket. wtf is taso talking about?
I'm too lazy to upload a screen shot for you

http://money.cnn.com/interactive/new...ets/index.html
12-22-2017 , 11:44 AM
He's almost certainly getting in awal $20 a week, max. He's a "libertarian" who magically goes to bat for all of Daddy's nonsense.
12-22-2017 , 11:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BreakYaNeck
Its not... keep telling yourself that. Its seriously amazing at this place. Just a bunch of whiny liberals that do not have any idea what people want. Literally 0 clue. Literally cry about everything Trump does
yea, it's not like there's not polling that has this tax bill at like a 29% favorability rating.

i'm guessing all these liberals are forgetting how trump campaigned on making the rich richer and they voted for him because of that. that's really what people want, man. totally spot on.
12-22-2017 , 11:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by hacksaw JD
yea, it's not like there's not polling that has this tax bill at like a 29% favorability rating.

Because a lot of people believe the lies that their taxes are going up.

When that proves false, I cannot wait to see Democrats campaigning on raising everyone's taxes, didn't think it'd be possible for them to **** it all up again and give us another four years of Trump, but they're gonna manage it.
12-22-2017 , 11:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by prana
Also, I don't even see a 4 point drop in any bracket. wtf is taso talking about?
Almost all of the old 28% bracket for MFJ is now in the 24% bracket, as is some of the 33% bracket.
12-22-2017 , 11:51 AM
I see that now.
12-22-2017 , 11:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bobman0330
Almost all of the old 28% bracket for MFJ is now in the 24% bracket, as is some of the 33% bracket.
oh, so taso thinks his entire income is now subject to 4% less in taxes, lol
12-22-2017 , 11:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by General Tsao
I cannot wait to see Democrats campaigning on raising everyone's taxes
Hey people making $1 million or more per year: Your taxes are going up. A lot.

Hey people not making $1 million or more per year: Your taxes are going down.

I think most would be okay with this message.
12-22-2017 , 11:52 AM
On Koch's oafish son

Quote:
It’s not just that Wyatt is precisely the sort of person who stands to benefit most from the new tax bill, although as it so happens his combination of wealth-without-wages, eventual massive inheritance windfall, and LLC company mean that he absolutely is. He absolutely is that person, but also and more importantly and most 2017 of all, he ****ing sucks at it. At this point in the current presidency, the idea that there is some inherent virtue to wealth or wealthy people just won’t play. Wealthy people do, on balance, tend to have larger homes and boats than less-wealthy people, but there is no way to look at the collection of fameball defectives and venal louts and thrice-divorced golf creatures that comprise Donald Trump’s extravagantly wealthy court and see any way to connect the valuable things they have with any of the values that they possess. The only exceptional thing about the rich people presently remaking the country in their own selfish image is their bulletproof self-regard.

If you start from the things they have and reverse-engineer your way backwards, you can kind of almost rig something together, and given that they’re willing to let a few thousand people starve to death in order to pay a little less in taxes I guess you can call them determined or focused or something. But again the evidence against their merit is towering and all around us.
https://deadspin.com/bless-this-oafi...rts-1821513843
12-22-2017 , 11:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BreakYaNeck
Its not... keep telling yourself that. Its seriously amazing at this place. Just a bunch of whiny liberals that do not have any idea what people want. Literally 0 clue. Literally cry about everything Trump does
This is why Trump is so unpopular and votes are swinging heavily towards Ds in every special election.

As your Daddy would say, no bubble, no bubble, you're the bubble.
12-22-2017 , 11:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by General Tsao
Because a lot of people believe the lies that their taxes are going up.

When that proves false, I cannot wait to see Democrats campaigning on raising everyone's taxes, didn't think it'd be possible for them to **** it all up again and give us another four years of Trump, but they're gonna manage it.
it's probably because people believe the truths that the rich are getting a major ****ing tax cut, financed with debt while the market is at an all-time high and the economy is growing a decent clip.

pretty sure everyone on this thread understands most people are getting a very modest tax cut for a few years and aren't arguing otherwise.
12-22-2017 , 11:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BreakYaNeck
MAGA, cant wait in 3 years to watch this forum cry again on election night when Trump wins in a landslide.
You want some action on this? With current approval ratings he's got no shot.

Quote:
Originally Posted by BreakYaNeck
Its not... keep telling yourself that. Its seriously amazing at this place. Just a bunch of whiny liberals that do not have any idea what people want. Literally 0 clue. Literally cry about everything Trump does
You're people. What do you want?

Quote:
Originally Posted by General Tsao
I'm too lazy to upload a screen shot for you

http://money.cnn.com/interactive/new...ets/index.html
Quote:
Originally Posted by General Tsao
Because a lot of people believe the lies that their taxes are going up.

When that proves false, I cannot wait to see Democrats campaigning on raising everyone's taxes, didn't think it'd be possible for them to **** it all up again and give us another four years of Trump, but they're gonna manage it.
The actual change in taxes probably isn't going to be noticeable for most people. Time will tell what actually happens, but for the most part people will not separate their general economic situation from their taxes. If their economic situation gets better, they will be happy about it and if it gets worse they will be sad. For example, if someone saves $50 a month in taxes on their paycheck but their healthcare deduction is $60 more, all they will see is $10 per paycheck.

I think you also overestimate the level to which reality will shape people's opinions. This tax bill is already unpopular and there is a lot of inertia that goes with that. Many people who have basically no idea what the effects of the Affordable Care Act are absolutely hate that thing, and it would take very significant and observable positive effects to change that. An extra ~$3.50 per paycheck is probably not going to accomplish that for someone who has already been convinced this thing is bad.

      
m