Quote:
Originally Posted by Malachii
Do you guys really think Bobby Fists won? I was watching the PPV with friends and was ****faced so maybe I missed something, but I thought Romero clearly won Rds 3-5. Too bad because it would have been an amazingly good card for ne if I’d hit on him. Then again I got lucky with Till the other week so whatever, you win some you lose some.
He very clearly did not win round 4. You could argue he edged it if you value big shots over volume shots. He did land the 2 biggest punches of the round, but he also got lit up for 4 minutes and didn't drop Whittaker in that round.
Whittaker outlanded Romero 34-20 in significant strikes for the round and landed most of those strikes a lot cleaner, he just ate the two biggest shots of the round in the last minute. Depends how you score the round. If Whittaker had gone down i'd have scored the round for Romero but because he didn't I don't think those two punches are quite enough to overcome 4 mins of better effective striking - he was the aggressor, threw 50 extra strikes and landed 14 extra strikes overall. If you think Romero edged it fair enough but it certainly wasn't a clear Romero round.
Crowdsourced scores from mmadecisions (how the public scored it)
ROUND 1
10-9 Whittaker 96.4%
10-8 Whittaker 3.6%
ROUND 2
10-9 Whittaker 98.5%
10-10 Draw 0.8%
10-9 Romero 0.8%
ROUND 3
10-9 Romero 83.0%
10-8 Romero 14.0%
10-9 Whittaker 2.8%
ROUND 4
10-9 Whittaker 76.6%
10-9 Romero 17.8%
10-10 Draw 4.8%
ROUND 5
10-8 Romero 56.6%
10-9 Romero 41.9%
10-8 Whittaker 0.8%
Overall - 33% Whittaker, 28% Romero, 39% draw
So that's what MMA fans as a whole think, at least those who visit websites, although clearly a couple percent of people are ******ed with some of the scores above for certain rounds, obviously Adalaide Byrd's online scorecard was 10-8 Whittaker, 10-9 Romero, 10-9 Whittaker, 10-9 Romero, 10-8 Whittaker.
I personally think 47-47 is a 'fair' scorecard but I scored it 48-47 in real time and I think I stand by that. Scoring the fight as a whole a draw is pretty fair and under pride rules I guess Romero 'won' via 2 knockdowns, although Whittaker closed his eye up and landed more sig strikes over the fight as a whole.
R5 was super borderline and 50/50 10-9 or 10-8, it comes down to whether dropping someone alone constitutes a 10-8 in an otherwise close round - R3 Romero did a ton more damage and it would have been a 10-8, but Whittaker rocked him twice as well so it can't be because it wasn't a dominant round as both guys landed significant offense even if one fighter clearly did more damage.
At the end of the day a draw is probably the fair result, but I think the only ways to 'correctly' score the fight are 48-47 Whittaker and 47-47 depending on your definition of a 10-8.