Turn ($6.80): 4 T J 5 HERO Checks, CO Bets $2.35 (allin), BTN Raises To $9.97 (allin), HERO Folds
River ($19.12): 4 T J 5 Q
Spoiler:
CO shows: 3 4 4 2
BTN shows: J K J T
CO wins: $10.93
This situation has come up a few times, but I'll use this hand as an example. Action limps to me and I complete. Flop comes with two hearts, and I am holding the ace of hearts. Cutoff bets, button calls, and I reraise bluff holding the Ace of hearts. BB and UTG fold, but cutoff and button call. Reviewing this, I think I only want to reraise bluff like this with nobody calling the flop bet, and the bettor not having a high VPIP. Is this reasonable logic?
These types of plays, although they have merit, are for hu pots - you aren't going to bluff multiple players on this board. You might, but it will be costly and -ve over the long run.
The NFD bluff works best multi way when the flush actually gets there and villains have weaker ranges where they are vbing less than a flush, or weak flush combos. Also keep in mind at these stakes it's probably better just to tighten up and value bet as people probably call down way too wide. And yeh this a garbage hand out of the SB - probably folding pre is best