Against tight ranges, high rundowns run into card removal and possible domination, especially if any of the Broadway pairs or of course A+3 Bway are out. It's not just about straights; a lot of hot and cold equity comes from two big pair.
T987 same suits probably performs better because:
- Big cards in opp hands don't block or dup as many straights, esp nut straights.
- Two pair and trips are more likely to come up and less likely to be dominated. Ideally if there were multiple tight(ish) players they'd be consuming each other's Bway cards.
Obviously I don't mean to say that 30% or wider is tight. But even having that one 10% range eliminates many cards you want in the stub.