Quote:
Originally Posted by MarkD
This is so wrong.
Everyone memorized a set of starting hands at some point. I did it in holdem, Omaha, stud, and so did you. Learning to adjust these ranges based on the specific situation is obviously important but this doesn’t mean you shouldn’t start with a baseline range and GTO certainly provides a very solid base created from first principles.
In your example yes your ranges will be different but not drastically different. If your baseline open from button is 45% of hands you might be singing 43-48% or at most maybe up to like 50-55% if there are nits in the blinds.
Yea, you can argue that you are going to change the composition of your range based on a lag or some other player type and I agree with you but again, these adjustments are on the margins. Learning the gto range by rote teaches you where these margins are and now you can learn to make the adjustments.
You’ve got what 15-20 years experience? What about people with one month or two months? Arguing that learning something by rote is wrong is wrong. Learn something, anything, it’s a start. Build from that when you know enough to make adjustments.
I'm a little confused as to what part exactly of my post you think is wrong?
I never memorized any set of starting hands. PLO wasn't taught like that when I was coming up ~15 years ago. I vaguely learnt starting hand charts when I was trying to learn sngs and 6max nlhe cash.
My argument in general, whether it comes to flash cards, or learning GTO spots, is that learning things by rote stunts your development. That one learns faster and better when one is allowed to make mistakes, but then learn from those mistakes, leading to understanding the reasons behind why they're mistakes. If you try to learn the reasons behind a thing, you can generalize those reasons on the fly and work out what to do in different circumstances better.
There is certainly an argument that these days, with the standard so much higher than it was when I first started out, if you're starting from scratch, and you don't understand postflop playability or the value of position and so on, then you maybe go broke before you get a chance to learn the reasons behind what you do. So maybe there's a place for them. But ultimately, long term development is slowed down by this line of thinking.