An open and collaborative society will always trump a protective one. Its not even close. But I understand how for the individual it might not look like it, especially in a society that embraces a culture in which individual gain is embraced. Very unfortunate state of affairs. (If you cant tell this is a general society critique, not only our poker subsociety.)
On to some poker:
So I tried to figure this spot out using ICMizer, but I couldnt figure out my limping EV.
Im in the shove camp and also dont think its close.
Unless we wanna talk about half stack raise -> shove most flops, which might be better or very close.
But I have never checked how profitable checking/various non-ai raises might be.