Quote:
Originally Posted by VincentVega
Getting my masters in psychology to be a therapist. Doesn't make me an expert tho. I know a few of each and he is right. A lot of psychiatrist have only had a couple classes related to psychotherapy and are not that qualified to "talk therapy". I'm not saying they are only good for prescribing meds, but if you are looking for someone to guide you through life troubles, is start with a somebody who is a psychologist, not psychiatrist.
I am assuming that when you say "talk therapy", you're talking about psychotherapy, the vast majority of which is verbal. I suppose there are some non verbal forms of psychotherapy, but that's generally not what people mean when they say "psychotherapy". Unless your meaning of "talk therapy" is something incredibly specific, you're wrong.
1. First of all, as you say, they "have only had a couple of classes", then you're clearly wrong, as a couple of classes, is clearly some formal training. The post I replied to asserted that they had none.
2. You're probably wrong about about the "couple of classes" thing anyway. They, if we're excluding medical school, essentially have zero classes. That's not how a residency training program works. It's essentially an apprenticeship that takes years. There is a board that certifies these training programs and they require training in psychotherapy to take place.
They also don't have "classes" on anything else. They don't have "classes" on how to prescribe psych meds, but it seems everyone would agree that they receive formal training on that.
3. It is entirely possible that psychiatrists are not very good at psychotherapy, in general, and inferior to psychologists. That's not the issue I'm talking about.
4. It is also possible that psychiatrists receive less training in psychotherapy than psychologists. Once again, that's not the issue. The issue is the moronic assertion that psychiatrists often have no formal training in psychotherapy.