Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed?
View Poll Results: Should pitbulls be allowed to breed
Yes
391 46.94%
No
289 34.69%
Yes but only if you have to have a special license to own one
153 18.37%

09-18-2015 , 01:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by younguns87
Right, I'm not saying he was incorrect in being nervous, I'm just saying to tell the story in a way of a pitbull tried to kill my friends dog this one time is not remotely true
It doesnt have to be true and he is definility right to assume the worst, that s beeing cautious unlike the guy who joke about beeing a bad parent because he let his kid play with his friends pit.

In the first case nothing bad happend and he did his best to prevent the worst , in the 2nd case good luck living with yourself when your kid died because he has been killed or need some skin transplent because of your friend dog "who wouldnt hurt a fly"
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 01:39 AM
I work in the hood a fair amount and once in a while a stray pit will just saunter by. I'm calm on the outside, but I'm as ready as I can be to jump on top of my truck or whatever is nearby.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 01:44 AM
nah every pit are loving and protecting and you should feel safer that he is watching for your security
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 06:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mackeleven
My argument is that pitbulls are harmlful when they are trained to be harmful until I see a list of cases of pitbulls attacking who were trained
by decent people.
Not only are pitbulls harmful when they are trained to harmful but also when they are neglected and not trained at all in obedience because, again, these dogs have the most destructive jaws out of any dog breeds and when you combine that with a dog's natural tendencies to attack other people and dogs it is not any surprise that you get an awful amount of carnage.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 06:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bundy5
Not only are pitbulls harmful when they are trained to harmful but also when they are neglected and not trained at all in obedience because, again, these dogs have the most destructive jaws out of any dog breeds and when you combine that with a dog's natural tendencies to attack other people and dogs it is not any surprise that you get an awful amount of carnage.
And what constitutes most destructive?
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 07:15 AM
I love how all the posts and statistics that can't be refuted get ignored completely. Like the one pointing out that the statistics have photographs of the dogs.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 07:24 AM
Its interesting how the poll results are different from the posting ITT. I wonder if the 52%actually read this thread if they'd change their mind. The idiocy on display by pit fans here has definitely made me more strongly opposed to pit bulls, because most of them seem to irresponsible to take care of a pet rock.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 09:56 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by problemeliminator
Its interesting how the poll results are different from the posting ITT. I wonder if the 52%actually read this thread if they'd change their mind. The idiocy on display by pit fans here has definitely made me more strongly opposed to pit bulls, because most of them seem to irresponsible to take care of a pet rock.
Yeah. I've certainly never supported banning pits. I never really thought about forcing sterilization, but this thread has me thinking about it.

I think identifying breeds though is probably too big a problem.

At this point I think I'm just hoping for social pressure to sterilize and holding owners responsible for what their dogs do, even if the dogs weren't trained to fight or anything like that.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 10:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wooders0n
Why does that matter?
Because I don't want to live in a nanny state where thugs training a breed of dog to be vicious spoils it for other dog lovers.

I have seen first hand how a labrador can be trained to fight like how a pit-bull does by idiots. If thugs who trained their dogs to be vicious all instead owned labradors, labs would get a bad name by you people while people like myself would be arguing that labradors aren't the problem, it is their owners.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 11:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by problemeliminator
Why?

What is your opinion on the dogo argentino?
Like any other dog.

Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 11:12 AM
Are you guys offended when someone says a nova scottia duck tolling retriever is good at duck retrieving?

If no,

Why are you guys offended when someone says a pit bull is good at attacking and maiming other living beings?
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 11:15 AM
youtube videos: the source of choice for nutjobs of all stripes.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 11:22 AM
I didn't source youtube to prove anything. I could have left the video out. It's my opinion.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 11:23 AM
mack,

Yes you could have.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 11:43 AM
There are links to trustworthy sources in this including to the ASPCA. Read it before you state things like "pitbulls are unpredictable" or "they have an especially strong bite".
http://www.alternet.org/civil-libert...ia-turned-them

Last edited by mackeleven; 09-18-2015 at 12:11 PM.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 12:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mackeleven
There is links to trustworthy sources in this including to the ASPCA. Read it before you state things like "pitbulls are unpredictable" or "they have an especially strong bite".
http://www.alternet.org/civil-libert...ia-turned-them
ASPCA Guide to Handling Pit Bulls in the Shelter Environment directly says that pit bulls are unpredictable, don't give the traditional warning signs before attacking, are very destructive and have very powerful jaws. Keep in mind that this is a guide for ASPCA shelter workers. They have more incentive to be honest when writing something to keep their workers safe as opposed to press releases designed to solicit donations by telling pit-tards what they want to hear.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 12:13 PM
nah it s obviously written by a puddle on the payroll of the labrador mafia
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 12:22 PM
Some pit bulls were selected and bred for their fighting ability. That means that they may be more likely than other breeds to fight with dogs. It doesn’t mean that they can’t be around other dogs or that they’re unpredictably aggressive. These dogs have long been popular family pets, noted for their gentleness, affection and loyalty. And even those pit bulls bred to fight other animals were not prone to aggressiveness toward people.
https://www.aspca.org/about-us/aspca...ment-pit-bulls
The ASPCA contradicts itself there then.

But it's not important, read the article and you'll understand why pitbulls are involved in a disproportionate amount of attacks.
It's what I'm arguing; stupid people.

The pitbull has an above average temperament according to the ATTS.

Last edited by mackeleven; 09-18-2015 at 12:34 PM.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 01:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mackeleven
But it's not important, read the article and you'll understand why pitbulls are involved in a disproportionate amount of attacks.
It's what I'm arguing; stupid people.
But stupid people own all types of dogs.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 01:04 PM
Dear OOT:

Thank you to those who have posted and linked to good information. I'm a dog lover, dogless at the moment but I'll certainly get another some day. I also may eventually be heading to vet school. Further, I like big dogs — I once had an 85 pound german shepherd, which I considered a medium sized dog, and later a 130 pound great dane. The latter was a big girl, but from my perspective not too big.

I was dimly aware of the pit bull issues, and would probably never have gotten a pit (despite there being such a need for people willing to adopt them), partly for the danger to others and partly because I would hate for people to see me the way they see other pit owners. I don't want a dog for machismo, and I don't want anyone, even a casual on the street, thinking I do.

But what I didn't know is two important things:

1. Just how bad even sweet, gentle pits can get in a flash. The pits I've known — a few — have always been adorable. And I have trusted my ability to read dogs. What I know now, and didn't know before, is that I probably don't know how to read a pit, at least not reliably enough to rely on in a potentially horrible situation, as when a child is around. Now I will be more cautious.

2. How much the problem extends to other molossus-derived breeds. Reading the stats on dog attack deaths in the US I was most surprised at how many rottweilers were on the list. Every rott I've known has been sweet as anything, too, and I could have seen myself getting one, hoping for the much of the good stuff I got from my GSD without the goddamn shedding issue (which is absurd — GSDs, as well as huskies, are borderline intolerable in that regard, and I say that as someone whose baby was a GSD). Now I'll know better.

(Cane corso, dogo brasileiro, and that ilk may be even more dangerous, but it's really difficult to tease that out of the stats because of the low numbers and likelihood of confusion about what in the US are exotic breeds.)

I don't know what the laws on this, if any, should be. Mandatory neutering at the very least, probably, but frankly that should apply to all breeds for a variety of reasons. And mandatory liability insurance for all pets seems a no-brainer; as noted upthread, insurance companies, which are in the business of assessing risk and so very likely to do it far better than anyone here, might fix the problem by pricing pits out of existence, or alternatively they might work out that the breed really isn't so bad, I suppose. But regardless the laws that pass or don't, at least now I know to be more careful, I know that the drive for anti-pit laws has a sound factual basis, and I know that a well-written law would include not just pits but other related dogs.

Again, thank you to the thoughtful contributors.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 01:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by heater
But stupid people own all types of dogs.
Pitbulls are the most abused dog
http://www.peta.org/blog/abused-dogs-earth/
, the biggest attraction for sociopaths who want a 'tough' dog, want to fight dogs etc.
I mean those people.

Last edited by mackeleven; 09-18-2015 at 01:21 PM.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 01:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mackeleven
Pitbulls are the most abused dog
That's what the title of the article says, anyway.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 01:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheGreenMagi

That being said, I would never want to own a pit. You can basically never take them off leash in public. You can never leave them alone with another animals (at least you shouldn't if you care for that other animal). You should never leave a pit alone with children (and probably shouldn't even have children in the same house at a pit). As an owner, you have to be constantly on guard because a lot of these dogs are ticking time bombs and you have to constantly be aware that they can be set off at any time for seemingly no reason.
Agreed, but a lot pit owners are ******ed and choose to ignore these rules.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 01:41 PM
Lol me: fila brasileiro, dogo argentino.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote
09-18-2015 , 04:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JayTeeMe
I think the point of suzzer's story was that the type of person that tends to own a pit bull is exactly the type of person we don't want to own a pit bull.
This is pretty concise.
Should pit bull owners be allowed to breed? Quote

      
m