Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife'

09-30-2017 , 11:32 AM
What the **** is going on in here?
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 11:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Black Peter
What criminal behavior? And why haven't you called the cops?

My advice would be to leave it alone. You will never know the full story, and guys like you who get involved in these situations never get what you want from it. It's not healthy for your mental state of mind.




This is only partly true. There are therapists who will advise people to leave dangerous relationships. Of course, whether this guy was told that is entirely unknown.
In my country it's a criminal offence under Domestic Abuse legislation to abuse someone psychologically by e.g. seeking to isolate them from friends and family. By saying 'I've been told to stay away from her by professionals (who should be believed and obeyed' it's not a big leap to 'and so should you also' as well as the blackening of her name). I'm involved through her choice mostly, plus I know all parties so have an interest in a self-absorbed liar not shattering the fabric of important relationships through deception and distortion. If psychs have a kind of a-priori ban on issuing relationship diktats with only unilateral info it kind of helps unmask him.
All I want from this situation is her well-being and her not isolated from those who are important to her, and they from her. The situation has been very unhealthy for my mind also for several months, but it's worth the outcome.
At a stretch I think they'd only advise leaving dangerous relationships when they have the full story.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 11:36 AM
oT - sick sick sick gif usage, A+++, fast shipping, would buy again

OP - lol



Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisshiherlis
The situation has been very unhealthy for my mind also for several months, but it's worth the outcome.
loooooooooooooooooooooooooooool
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 11:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DrChesspain
Why do you want your friend to reconcile with her allegedly violent, philandering husband?
I very much don't, I'm delighted they're apart. But his lies have torn a lot of other people apart.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 11:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chopstick
oT - sick sick sick gif usage, A+++, fast shipping, would buy again

OP - lol
It's unbelievably sick, I know all those scenes like the back of my hand but would not have pulled that one off.
I've seen the actor post pics of himself in remote places, pretending to be that character 'still in exile'. The legend lives on.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 11:46 AM
OP,

Are you currently sleeping with your friend? Have you ever? Do you want to?
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 11:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larry Legend
OP,

Are you currently sleeping with your friend? Have you ever? Do you want to?
Very much not. I know the other person very well though and I'm aware of the danger he represents.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 12:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisshiherlis
In my country it's a criminal offence under Domestic Abuse legislation to abuse someone psychologically by e.g. seeking to isolate them from friends and family. By saying 'I've been told to stay away from her by professionals (who should be believed and obeyed' it's not a big leap to 'and so should you also' as well as the blackening of her name).
Lol, that law has nothing to do with your friend's situation. If she's isolated from her friends because her husband, for example, is threatening to harm her if she contacts them, or won't allow her to have a cell phone or use the internet, that's domestic abuse. If she's isolated from her friends because they choose not to associate with her based on what someone told them, that's not domestic abuse

Quote:
If psychs have a kind of a-priori ban on issuing relationship diktats with only unilateral info it kind of helps unmask him.
Of course they don't. They have an a priori ban on having sex with their clients, but that's about it, and even that doesn't stop them all the time. There's a poster here who has seen multiple therapists whom she says have told her she needs to break up with her boyfriend.

Last edited by gregorio; 09-30-2017 at 12:13 PM.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 12:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisshiherlis
Very much not. I know the other person very well though and I'm aware of the danger he represents.
So what are the major mental issues this situation is presenting you?

You are helping a dear friend in need, who is getting out of a bad situation, away from a psychotic individual.

The whole shrink thing and this guy's communication about it is just so ****ed no one itt can possibly give a reasonable take. You are conveying massively incomplete information, as a 3rd party, with some first-hand evidence, which itself is 2nd hand, you and her have never even met the shrink, and your source is a violent, cheating, crazy dude.

You've gotten across something resembling:
"now he is talking **** to friends through social media, omg ohnoes, whatever shall we do"

Which is weird. It is your place to help and shelter your friend, not to be her spokesperson about her situation to all her friends. And the first thing both of you should do is stop giving a single **** about anything this dude says. If you aren't friends with massive idiots, then no one will trust this dude anyway, and know he's unhinged. If somehow he is ruining friendships, then you and her need better friends anyway.

It seems like based on the OP title that you wanted people to say, "the shrink should have never said that", do you want them back together or something?
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 12:51 PM
OP, how long have you known MLYLT and Code3?
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 01:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisshiherlis
Nice post thanks. Guessing you're probably a therapist?

I need to protect her from his criminal behaviour in isolating her, she has no one else.
And there we have it.

Welcome back, Tylertwo!
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 02:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisshiherlis
In my country it's a criminal offence under Domestic Abuse legislation to abuse someone psychologically by e.g. seeking to isolate them from friends and family. By saying 'I've been told to stay away from her by professionals (who should be believed and obeyed' it's not a big leap to 'and so should you also' as well as the blackening of her name). I'm involved through her choice mostly, plus I know all parties so have an interest in a self-absorbed liar not shattering the fabric of important relationships through deception and distortion. If psychs have a kind of a-priori ban on issuing relationship diktats with only unilateral info it kind of helps unmask him.
All I want from this situation is her well-being and her not isolated from those who are important to her, and they from her. The situation has been very unhealthy for my mind also for several months, but it's worth the outcome.
At a stretch I think they'd only advise leaving dangerous relationships when they have the full story.
I don't see how she is isolated. He left her. She can do what she wants.

You say this is worth the outcome. What outcome? What is your end goal here? To get with her?
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 02:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larry Legend
So what are the major mental issues this situation is presenting you?

You are helping a dear friend in need, who is getting out of a bad situation, away from a psychotic individual.

The whole shrink thing and this guy's communication about it is just so ****ed no one itt can possibly give a reasonable take. You are conveying massively incomplete information, as a 3rd party, with some first-hand evidence, which itself is 2nd hand, you and her have never even met the shrink, and your source is a violent, cheating, crazy dude.

You've gotten across something resembling:
"now he is talking **** to friends through social media, omg ohnoes, whatever shall we do"

Which is weird. It is your place to help and shelter your friend, not to be her spokesperson about her situation to all her friends. And the first thing both of you should do is stop giving a single **** about anything this dude says. If you aren't friends with massive idiots, then no one will trust this dude anyway, and know he's unhinged. If somehow he is ruining friendships, then you and her need better friends anyway.

It seems like based on the OP title that you wanted people to say, "the shrink should have never said that", do you want them back together or something?
Thanks, that's very helpful.
I was really trying to get a handle on whether shrinks are normally directed away from getting involved in issuing personal-relationship-directives. It kind of spiralled from there, helpfully at some points.
Heh, funny you should say that about others working him out. I think that's kind of what happened, I only have vague info about that but it seems things did not go to plan for him.
I don't want them to get back, I don't think they ever will. It's likely that the others put a lot of credit on his suggestion that he was told by professionals to stay away from her. I'd like very much for her to get back involved in the circles she was previously involved in.
Actually now you mention it, a lot of them are massive idiots.
Thanks.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 02:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Black Peter
I don't see how she is isolated. He left her. She can do what she wants.

You say this is worth the outcome. What outcome? What is your end goal here? To get with her?
His circles were her circles. He badmouthed her, they've all gone. She's just...isolated. A few casual acquaintances here and there, and me basically.
The outcome would be the restoration of some of the most important relationships she had before.
No intention at all to be with her, just to see the mess undone a bit for her.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 02:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larry Legend
So what are the major mental issues this situation is presenting you?
The villain represented a serious threat to me over a large number of years, the situation draws me back into his environment with a generally hostile overtone.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 04:34 PM
chris,

Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisshiherlis
No intention at all to be with her, just to see the mess undone a bit for her.
She's very lucky to have someone as caring and understanding as you in her life. If she expressed interest in getting together with you, would you consider it?
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 05:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisshiherlis
His circles were her circles. He badmouthed her, they've all gone. She's just...isolated. A few casual acquaintances here and there, and me basically.
The outcome would be the restoration of some of the most important relationships she had before.
No intention at all to be with her, just to see the mess undone a bit for her.
It's a sucky situation, and i feel bad for her. But i don't think this is criminal behavior. But maybe in your country, it is. If you believe that, then why haven't you called the cops?
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 06:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by El Diablo
chris,



She's very lucky to have someone as caring and understanding as you in her life. If she expressed interest in getting together with you, would you consider it?
Nothing regular. For me, the sun rises and sets with her.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 06:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Black Peter
It's a sucky situation, and i feel bad for her. But i don't think this is criminal behavior. But maybe in your country, it is. If you believe that, then why haven't you called the cops?
He did make other more direct steps to isolate her, which are probably criminal. Cops are a bit of a blunt instrument in this kind of situation maybe.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 07:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by amead
Here's an idea: mind your own business.
This.

OP, your involvement in this thing seems... strange.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 07:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cs3
This.

OP, your involvement in this thing seems... strange.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 08:24 PM
OP is most likely being manipulated by girl right?

Let me ask you this OP, why would a girl marry someone so alledgedly ****ed up? Could it be because she is really ****ed up as well?

Either way you yourself should eject IMO
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 09:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisshiherlis
He did make other more direct steps to isolate her, which are probably criminal. Cops are a bit of a blunt instrument in this kind of situation maybe.
Why are you not listing those criminal actions? You seem to want to have the whole story peeled back layer by layer instead of telling it all up front.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
09-30-2017 , 11:36 PM
A message for the OP:

Spoiler:
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote
10-01-2017 , 03:12 AM
Chris,

Quote:
Originally Posted by chrisshiherlis
Nothing regular. For me, the sun rises and sets with her.

What are you afraid of? It seems obvious to everyone that you two are meant to be together.
Psychologist: 'You should stay away from your wife' Quote

      
m