Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart
View Poll Results: Is this odd?
Yes
103 76.30%
No
32 23.70%

10-01-2018 , 09:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dominic
Putting ~$4k on cc when she has 1k in the bank is troubling, but if it's a one-off, ok.
The wish to spend a week in Paris with her daughter, odd, but not out of line.

What seems to be troubling OP the most is that the finance made plans for a trip to Europe without consulting him at all, pretty much letting him know where he stands in the relationship.

He picks up her daughter after school. They are getting married. They own a home together. They are a family.

And she has decided she's going to go to Paris for a week over Xmas, without him. She didn't bring it up as a possibility, she didn't suggest an alternative to include him at all - she basically planned this behind his back.

This is not how families act. What makes OP think this kind of behavior will stop once they're married?

If my GF of five years treated me so cavalierly, it would be over. And we don't even live together. Every decision I make that might affect her in any way, I discuss with her. And she does the same. We are careful with each others' feelings, because, really, what else is there?
Probably the best post about the feelings dimension so far.

And, as always, LOL MLYLT.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-01-2018 , 10:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dominic
Putting ~$4k on cc when she has 1k in the bank is troubling, but if it's a one-off, ok.
The wish to spend a week in Paris with her daughter, odd, but not out of line.

What seems to be troubling OP the most is that the finance made plans for a trip to Europe without consulting him at all, pretty much letting him know where he stands in the relationship.

He picks up her daughter after school. They are getting married. They own a home together. They are a family.

And she has decided she's going to go to Paris for a week over Xmas, without him. She didn't bring it up as a possibility, she didn't suggest an alternative to include him at all - she basically planned this behind his back.

This is not how families act. What makes OP think this kind of behavior will stop once they're married?

If my GF of five years treated me so cavalierly, it would be over. And we don't even live together. Every decision I make that might affect her in any way, I discuss with her. And she does the same. We are careful with each others' feelings, because, really, what else is there?
Now Dom...this is their last chance for mommy and daughter to have "me" time before they're stuck with Dale for the rest of their lives. What better way to spend it going to an expensive city across the pond during the most expensive time of the year to travel?
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-01-2018 , 10:36 PM
Moderately responsible adults with 8 year old children don't have $1,000. Yikes. The type of people who have an 8 year old kid and $1,000 in the bank, who further go to Paris without telling their SO...yeah. Not ending well here.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-01-2018 , 10:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dth123451
Moderately responsible adults with 8 year old children don't have $1,000. Yikes. The type of people who have an 8 year old kid and $1,000 in the bank, who further go to Paris without telling their SO...yeah. Not ending well here.
But she has an [unspoken] backup plan to cover her expenses. She just hasn't informed him yet.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-01-2018 , 11:09 PM
This is so odd, even without MeDerpYou...how old are the principals in this?
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-01-2018 , 11:12 PM
She's 8
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-01-2018 , 11:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dalerobk2
So we talked yesterday. It was just a normal conversation, not heated or anything. I suggested Disney World or something closer by for just the two of them. She said she had always wanted to do Christmas abroad and wants to do it a mommy daughter trip. She's pretty inflexible about it.

She also is being completely unrealistic about the money. I think she way underestimates how much the trip is going to cost. She thinks she'll have the trip paid off by the end of January. I'm assuming the trip will cost $4,000-$5,000 (probably the top of that). She has a $1,000 in the bank right now. She might be able to pay off half that, best case scenario. I cautioned her about cc debt and how awful it is. It turns out her card is a 24% apr. I think she thinks I'm being overly dire in order to talk her out of the trip.

Also, it turns out that she was simply announcing the trip to me, it seems. She told me that she had already got those dates cleared with her boss b/c she was taking this trip. Her job is such that someone from the office is always on call 24/7. She cleared those dates before she had mentioned the specifics of the trip to me. She had vaguely mentioned a mommy daughter trip over Christmas, but I imagined that to be a weekend trip over the break, not 8 days to Europe including Christmas Day.

I'm just at a loss. I've been up most of the night thinking everything over. I just don't see why she's so hell bent on this. It's financially horrible. And why are you wanting to drag an 8yo around Paris in middle of the winter? I wonder what they're going to do Christmas day. I assume everything will be shut down. Are they going to spend the day in a hotel room? And ffs, we were just there.

I just don't get it, and it's making me rethink the relationship.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-01-2018 , 11:46 PM
Dominic is on point here.

Unfortunately OP, the relationship is not where you thought it was. I can relate....
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-01-2018 , 11:57 PM
Plot twist:

She's pregnant with some guy in Paris
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-01-2018 , 11:59 PM
And it's their second child together.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 12:10 AM
1. I feel like one of the best parts of this thread is Dale discovering the magic of Mbabs.

2. Dominic is right.

3. Out of curiosity, why are you marrying this woman anyway? I'm not saying to dump her, but is there any reason you can't just live in your current situation indefinitely. I'm not even saying you're wrong to get married. Just curious more than anything.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 12:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dominic
Putting ~$4k on cc when she has 1k in the bank is troubling, but if it's a one-off, ok.
The wish to spend a week in Paris with her daughter, odd, but not out of line.

What seems to be troubling OP the most is that the finance made plans for a trip to Europe without consulting him at all, pretty much letting him know where he stands in the relationship.

He picks up her daughter after school. They are getting married. They own a home together. They are a family.

And she has decided she's going to go to Paris for a week over Xmas, without him. She didn't bring it up as a possibility, she didn't suggest an alternative to include him at all - she basically planned this behind his back.

This is not how families act. What makes OP think this kind of behavior will stop once they're married?

If my GF of five years treated me so cavalierly, it would be over. And we don't even live together. Every decision I make that might affect her in any way, I discuss with her. And she does the same. We are careful with each others' feelings, because, really, what else is there?
Yeah Dom nailed it in this post. Her actions are hugely indicative that she's going to always consider her and the daughter as the main family and you, her, and the daughter as a lesser one. I think you have to decide if you are going to be okay with that or not. Be prepared for the phrase "She's not YOUR daughter" to come up eventually if you stay together.

Credit card stuff is also worrying, you and her should sit down and have a frank discussion about what you both expect finance wise once you get married. There are a couple credit cards out there that offer 0% APR for the first year, maybe try to convince her to get one of those before she goes on the trip.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 04:05 AM
The lack of self-awareness in MLY's posts ITT is a complete shock to me.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 04:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bighurt52235
That is hilarious.

How was the room?
It was nice if you're Woody from Toy Story. Terrace was nice.

Quote:
Originally Posted by dalerobk2
She's never used the card before. Certainly never had a balance. We have seen each other's credit reports. Her score is something like 770. No blemishes.
770 is decent. How the hell does she have a credit card with an APR a college kid with little credit history would have?

Quote:
Originally Posted by gregorio
Or $1,700/night hotel suites at Disney World
She wasn't always this way.

Quote:
Originally Posted by dalerobk2
Lol. Like I said, I don't mind spending Christmas alone. I'll make myself a big dinner and drink some Oban in front of the fire. It will be nice. I just don't understand her excluding me from Christmas. I suspect she would go ape **** if the roles were reversed.

Still have no idea what to make of it and will continue to try to process it and evaluate our relationship.
Is her vibe like it's no big deal because Christmas is no big deal, or what?

Quote:
Originally Posted by MeLoveYouLongTime
You don't really feel like spending Christmas with her when the "supposed" reason you are mad in the first place is because you weren't spending Christmas with her. Lolol
You sound like a big baby that didn't get his way and really immature. How old are you by the way?

Be upset about the finances or whatever, but happy that she gets to spend this time with her daughter- the person that was there before you, whose heart beat she felt and listened to in her stomach. Her daughter only has so many years of childhood and special memories to gather from it.
Wtf is this mother/daughter memories bull****? She's 8-years-old. Literally next to worthless to take her to Europe for a week. Have OP dress up like Santa and give her 20 presents is what she really wants. Take her to Europe when she can appreciate it more.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 04:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Land O Lakes
Wtf is this mother/daughter memories bull****? She's 8-years-old. Literally next to worthless to take her to Europe for a week.Take her to Europe when she can appreciate it more.

ofc it's nuts to take an 8yo to Paris, we all know that.

The memories aren't for the little girl, they are for the mom. DYE woman, bro?

mom is going to do her thing and OP is going to pay for it. c'est comme ça.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 05:26 AM
I think the issue is how she is doing it. For me it would be REDDEST flag that SO has nothing to say for her Christmas plans. It is like really really really off. And 24% credit card debt is plain dumb. I mean... it is plain asking for troubles.

I would totally rethink the relationship and absolutely 100% use some kind of premarital counselling
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 05:52 AM
Just cheat while she's gone. You will feel better.

Spoiler:
I'm bad at advice
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 06:37 AM
What Dom said. LOL at everyone saying Dale's overreacting, he's a man, blah blah. This is the real world.

Also, what Dids said re: Josie being single.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 06:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by offTopic
This is so odd, even without MeDerpYou...how old are the principals in this?
I'm 41 and she's 31.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 06:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Melkerson
1. I feel like one of the best parts of this thread is Dale discovering the magic of Mbabs.

2. Dominic is right.

3. Out of curiosity, why are you marrying this woman anyway? I'm not saying to dump her, but is there any reason you can't just live in your current situation indefinitely. I'm not even saying you're wrong to get married. Just curious more than anything.
I think it's safe to say the wedding is on hold for now.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 06:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Land O Lakes
It was nice if you're Woody from Toy Story. Terrace was nice.



770 is decent. How the hell does she have a credit card with an APR a college kid with little credit history would have?



She wasn't always this way.



Is her vibe like it's no big deal because Christmas is no big deal, or what?



Wtf is this mother/daughter memories bull****? She's 8-years-old. Literally next to worthless to take her to Europe for a week. Have OP dress up like Santa and give her 20 presents is what she really wants. Take her to Europe when she can appreciate it more.
IDK about the card. Like I said, she's never carried any debt except for a car loan and student loan. Maybe she got the card in college and the rate never adjusted? Really have no idea.

I honestly am not sure what her "vibe" was. Have been in a bit of a fog, which is why I think I just need some time to calm down and reflect. As I said, Christmas is a big deal for her. I think she told me via texts that she didn't see why this was so big. "There will be other vacations and Christmases." I think that was a response to asking if this was a one off are are we now doing separate vacations.

I mean, I used to go to Biloxi every 2-3 weekends. It was nice to get out of the **** hole town I live in and the extra money was nice. I haven't gone in three years. I've completely redone my work schedule to spend the afternoons running around with the little girl. I don't mind any of the sacrifices I've made because that's what you do for the people you love. It just hurts to feel like I'm somehow being pushed aside. Like I said, I need some time to calm down and reflect.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 06:58 AM
Dominic,

Thanks for your posts. They have been heard. I just need some time to cool down, reflect, reread this thread in a few weeks, and figure some things out. I do appreciate everyone's input.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 08:19 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dalerobk2
What is wrong with you? How could it be fun if I felt like I was coercing her to be there?


This!

Biloxi sounds cool and I know Vegas is cool. Treat yourself.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 08:27 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Alobar
I think your reaction is normal, but I don't think their plans are odd. Not everyone sees Christmas as this super important family time. To me this seems more like they want a mom daughter trip and given school and vacation schedule it makes the most sense to do it on the holidays.

My mom many years ago got me and my dad a trip to chicago. All the people at her work said that she should be going as well and that it should be a family trip. A few years after my dad died I actually thanked my mom for not going on that trip with us, because it's the single most cherished memory I have with my dad. Not that I don't love my mom, or it wouldnt be a cherished memory had she gone, but it would have been different, and I wouldn't be left with the same feelings about it that I have now, and I'm sooo grateful I had the oppportunity to do that with my just my dad.

Since holidays and christmas is important to you, why not just have christmas early, and still make it a special, or try and make thankgsgiving even more about the three of you sharing time together as a family.
I agree with the bolded.
I think most people would be hurt but I'm weird so personally I wouldn't remotely give a ****.I really don't care about holidays or when I'm supposed to do things. If I was dating a woman who had a kid I'd be fine with them taking a trip together when school is out even if it happened to be over Christmas.

I would however never get in a relationship with someone who sucked with money.

Last edited by borg23; 10-02-2018 at 08:41 AM.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote
10-02-2018 , 08:59 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dalerobk2
I think it's safe to say the wedding is on hold for now.
Was reading a portion of that old thread and I was laughing and thinking of how big a deal I made of things and now couldn't care less and it was all a waste of mental energy.

The trip is only 8 days. You have been together 3 years. It's not the end of yall's future together or shouldn't be. Don't dwell on it for months and just accept it's happening and be happy they get some time together and you get some good alone time. You have every other day of the year to be together and be a family.
Is this odd?  Spending Christmas Vacation Apart Quote

      
m