OAF,
Not sure what all you're talking about or arguing against for against(?), but I was replying to the notion of no more water cooler shows as defined here in whatthe's comment:
Quote:
The future is in developing a wider dispersion of shows, each with a more narrow audience scope. This is arguably easier and more profitable than attempting to create a behemoth, decade-spanning vehicle that tries to appeal to all audiences
"Behemoth that appeals to all audiences" is exactly what popularity is imo. It's not just about being a "super elite level" show as you put it, that may only appeal to a narrow audience.
And idk about the UK, but I get the feeling that around here BB wasn't even all that popular or appreciated the first few seasons. It was more of a cult following then, and didn't even gain huge popularity until much later. GoT on the other had a massive following right off the bat. In fact it already had a huge following
before a single episode ever aired because the books were already massively popular.
And since there will always be massively popular books to base new shows on, new massively popular hit shows will keep popping up every few years. And we may even discuss them while at the water cooler!