Quote:
Originally Posted by cult_leader
I watched both dear zachary and touching the void last night. Dear Zachary is a great film. Touching the void bored the hell out of me though. Reenactments just don't do it for me.
I watched Touching the Void last night too after the recommendations in this thread (it was either that or the MNF game, so not much of a choice). I don't know that I was bored per se, but it didn't live up to the hype for me.
It didn't help that I had somewhat of a hard time grasping what exactly happened, and I went to the wiki page on the book afterward. So, after Jim falls and breaks his leg they take turns slowly descending the face, right? Then Jim falls off a ledge and is dangling there, so after much deliberation about what happened Simon decides to cut the rope because it's obvious Jim isn't going to be able to bolt in anywhere or he would have already done it. This is correct?
Both in the story and the wiki page it was mentioned that Simon caught a lot of heat for his decision, but I don't understand why. As was noted if he doesn't then they're both screwed. Unless I'm missing some other out that he had, or maybe they felt he didn't wait long enough before making that decision.