Quote:
Originally Posted by Howard Treesong
A single politics post strikes me as a bit of an overreach, but yes, I like the idea of some disqualifying ratio between politics posts and OOT posts. But I’m not running the contest and my opinion doesn’t matter.
If we're talking about the rules for next year, I'd go for pretty lax criteria - i.e. let lurkers vote too, with an anti-brigadering exception that if there is evidence of people recruiting votes in other subforums then voters thus far unseen that year are not counted in that vote. It's obviously up to whoever wants to run it next year though.
Quote:
Originally Posted by patron
LektorAJ is running the competition. He made a terrible decision and disenfranchised hundreds of OOT regs. However, he has indicated that he may return to sanity and restore the usual and historical eligibility rules from the beginning of the competition.
The oldest rule is organiser's discretion. The rules you state didn't do anything to stop brigadering so it's impossible to use them to run a historical-style Ms. OOT. Too many people jealous their subforums don't have Ms. competitions.
People who didn't make the cut as judges for the E8 onwards due to lack of involvement/commitment in Ms. OOT 2018 will be added to the list if they have 20 posts or more in OOT between 1 Jan 2018 and 29 Nov 2018 (i.e. sufficient commitment/involvement in OOT as a whole) and suddenly want to get involved at this late stage.
Just vote and I'll add you to the list.
Last edited by LektorAJ; 01-16-2019 at 04:11 AM.