Quote:
People have always apologized away Keanu’s performance in that movie and I’ve never understood it.
Still a great movie.
thing about the matrix is had a ton of studio interference and last minute rewrites so what was originally something deeply grounded in science and based on plausible situations got rewritten and dumbed down until it reached a point where the studios felt it was dumb enough for the audience to understand - this is why it's just a series of vignettes that don't make much sense, for example, they put the bug in him, but then don't use it to actually spy or track him but let him secretly rendevous and go about his plans, etc etc it's just one after another that was later reconned in sequels with "oh we planned all this"
for example, the battery thing was because studio executives didn't think the audience could understand using humans for processing power via a neural net
but we aren't left saying wtf to all the inconsistencies, contradictions, plot holes, and just dumb stuff because keanu luckboxed his way into being the perfect distraction from it all
keanu's neo was a clueless bumbler who never thought deeply and just went along with it at all times, never asking questions, when he needed something he'd just figure it out as he went along - that zen indifference helps make the audience indifferent to it all as well
someone who acted in that role would have shown intelligence, empathy or understanding, in which case the absurdity of the entire premise collapses within on itself - when the actor playing neo shows that he cares instead of just being there experiencing it, you begin to realize how absurd it is to care because none of it makes sense
with keanu, the film was simply a vehicle to explore some incredible concepts skin deep and splice in plenty of incredibly orchestrated action sequences
with another actor, you start asking too many questions, why would he do that? but this doesn't make sense? shouldn't they just have done this instead?
his acting style of being flotsam just floating about wherever the waves take him was absolutely perfect for the film and the only way it could work
with keanu, there is no spoon so there is nothing to critique