Quote:
Originally Posted by JackInDaCrak
96 vs 80% has to be a pretty short payback period for only $400 different price.
A bit larger for the Maytag 80 vs. 96, but agree that the payback period should still be relatively short.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sjrosswog
I'd lean more towards the Trane equipment. Ive seen a few consumer reports that rated Maytag as the top brand, but have only seen a handful personally. The most important thing is that it's sized correctly. Did they do a load calculation on the house?
I'm not sure. I can ask the guy, but I think the 5 ton is pretty standard for most of the houses around here, and I don't have any reason to believe that the current machine is inappropriate. But again, it's worth asking.
Quote:
Originally Posted by REDeYeS88
you can google and find hvac efficiency payback calculators. you are correct that it is associated with energy use and not how well it cools. i don't know the gas prices in ohio (i'm assuming it's gas), but in oregon the difference between 96% and 80% is around $100/year. you should also search to see if their are federal and/or state energy savings incentives or tax credits. i believe there are still federal tax credits available for energy star furnaces and air conditioners but i don't think an AC with less than 15 seer will qualify.
regarding the warranty, do you know if it's transferable if you sell the house? similar to the efficiency payback, the longer maytag warranty won't matter if you don't plan on staying in the house that long and it's not transferable.
fyi maytag doesn't actually manufacture the equipment. they sold the naming rights to nordyne/nortek global several years ago.
In terms of rebates, all of the amounts I quoted are net of all federal/state/local rebates. Based on the conversation with HVAC company owner, the warranty is typically not transferable. Like, best case scenario, we can elect (upon installation) to purchase transferability and pay an extra ~$100 or so. I probably would not choose to pay that amount. So the extra warranty, for all practical purposes, is only useful to the extent that we expect to be here more than 3 years. No plans to move right now, but not averse to moving.
I've seen the link between Maytag and Nordyne/Nortek, but that doesn't really mean anything to me. (Because I'm completely ignorant about all things housing-related.) Is Nordyne/Nortek a good, neutral, or negative brand?