Quote:
Originally Posted by GeoffRas22
The problem isn't the criticism, the problem is this is what people do when they're predisposed to criticize some form of art. If they go into it wanting to like it, and they are made aware of similarities to something else, then it isn't a lame rip-off, it's a NOD, or something that makes them clever. If they want to hate it then it's just "oh how unoriginal." It's completely impossible to continue a story in the Star Wars universe with a new generation (some of whom happen to be the offspring of the old generation) and not re-use some themes/storylines
How does someone float this take after seeing Episode 7? A lot of people enjoyed that for what it was, but "unoriginal" was a very generous (and fair) criticism. Some people are naturally concerned about future episodes taking the same approach.
You can try to frame it as "similarities" or "reusing some themes" if you want to badly downplay what we're talking about, but we've seen movies. The problem isn't people being critical of a lack of originality or wanting more than a reworked version of a previous film.