Quote:
Originally Posted by NoSoup4U
I'm not arguing for the accuracy of the new/old language, I get where you are coming from as far as that goes. None of your terms have a yin/yang relationship like new/old, if you call one the stolen hemisphere, the other would have to be whatever the opposite is to make sense.
The logic of the division is that Europe/Africa/Asia species are generally biologically distinct from American species. ...
There are other distinctions in other fields too.
For example in new world countries "nativism" is the about the minorities who were in the place before the majority (for whom the place is "new") came there, and the majority sees the country as built on immigration and/or particular sets of political values.
In old world countries nativism is about the majority (for whom the place is "old") and is an expression of scepticism about diversity and change - the country is built on its native population which in any case are mostly all related if you go back a dozen generations and often speak a language not spoken outside their narrow cultural bubble.
At least in the UK we'd typically include Aus/NZ as new world countries. We think of ourselves as a old-world country but there are various reasons why we're a bit in between (immigration, strong cultural links to new world countries, speaking one of the three major international languages, the presence of more-native-than-thou people speaking Celtic languages etc.)
I'm not an expert but there are apparently differences between old and new world winemaking approaches - old world being far more reliant on the native microflora that's always been there in past compared to new world which is far more controlled. I get that it's loaded and would be fine using different terminology if there is a non-loaded alternative.
Getting back on topic - views on why it might the old/new world distinction might make a difference with Covid? Maybe countries established longer with a more homogenous population are easier to get working together as a society?
Last edited by LektorAJ; 10-29-2020 at 07:02 PM.