Quote:
Originally Posted by Dudd
Failed pretty hard at my first attempt at sous code. Picked up a $99 Gourmia from Amazon, according to my thermometer it was the right temperature, set it at 132. Got it out, patted it dry as best I could, then seated it. Flipped it a few times until the crust looked decent, maybe two, three minutes per side total, and it was just gone, way over cooked. Fairly thin steak, maybe an inch, so I guess it just couldn't handle that much searing. Good news is it was a .8 pound steak that I cut in half since in theory I'm trying to diet, so I have the other half to sear and try tomorrow sitting in the fridge, will go for less of a seat and see if the interior doesn't way over cook.
Kinda sad Dudd didn't get much constructive feedback. Yes, as El D said, for a thinner steak like that, you can skip the reverse sear and just go directly to the sear and it should come out OK. But no one commented that the main sin was that 132 F for your sous vide step is way too high. 132 F is a much higher temperature than the usual medium rare ITT. 131 F is on the high end of what most people consider OK here. Most aim for more around a uniform 125 F edge to edge, with the exception of the crust. When I sous vide steaks, even pretty thick ones, I set the bath for 117 or 118 F (at temps this low, don't go more than an hour or so). Then the additional heat from the sear isn't going to overcook your steak.
I only use 131-132 F for things like a leg of lamb that I want to cook overnight, and as such, it's vital to have over the pasteurization temperature of 131 F. For steak with a short sous vide time, you should be well under 131.