So a little update on solidteknics pan. I've cooked one meal a day in it since I got it. Bacon, steak, fried rice, and chicken thighs so far.
It's taking seasoning pretty well. Center is still only around ceramic nonstick nonstick but it's getting close to teflon on the outside (as good as it's gonna be realistically)
But I do have some complaints.
The sides are just too low. The splatter radius is way way way bigger than with my all clads and the matfer bourgeat I threw away months ago. This honestly is a deal breaker if I realized how bad it is.
You absolutely have to season the handle, at least once. I didn't at first but the seasoning started wearing off where I held the pan at the end.
I had to go out of my way to season it. I never had to do that with Matfer Bourgeat (probably different material) or Lodge (probably because it's not sharp edges). The cooking area of the pan is seasoning quite well just with regular cooking.
My overall review is... A-, maybe B+ given the price. It's good but a lot of its features turned out to be negatives.
Only two things stood to me as pure positives:
1. The satin finish seems to be the perfect balance between smoothness and ability to take on seasoning. As I said before, pan is still only around ceramic nonstick nonstick in the center but it's getting close to teflon on the outside (as good as it's gonna be realistically).
2. The factory seasoning is wayyyy better than anything I've seen. Maybe it's not the seasoning but the satin finish. I wouldn't be surprised if Lodge seasoning is actually thicker/stronger/more nonstick but the pebble surface is holding it back.
If I knew what I know now, I would have just gotten the Matfer Bourgeat again. It's a little harder to season but not dramatically so. I think if you don't care for the preseasoning and are comfortable with doing the first seasoning on your own, go for the Matfer.
PS: Does that US map look like Pikachu to anyone else?