OP, the answer to this rides on just exactly how likely Drunky is to actually do anything about your refusal to surrender your paper. Not having been there, my guess is that the vast majority of the time, he's pissed off that he got kicked out and his ego is starved for a victory of any kind, even if that means stealing your newspaper. He's not willing to spill life's blood all over Fremont Street for a 75-cent
Sports Weekly. So if you bend, you will feel even more like a bitch than you would if it were, say, 50/50 that refusing him would result in a fight.
For example, a couple weeks ago I needed to drop something off at an apartment complex. Since all I needed to do was run up to the door and come back, I just left my car in the easiest spot. As I was getting out of my car, I was accosted by an Angry Black Woman in an SUV (that probably wasn't hers) screaming at me that she was in a hurry and I need to move my car:
Now, this may seem reasonable, but in the time it would have taken me to move, she could have easily found a much quicker way around me:
And what was she going to do about it besides yell at me some more? Ram my car with her (not really) SUV? I held all the leverage: I was there first, she could have gone where she needed to be faster without making me move, and she was being a belligerent beeotch and there wasn't a goddamn thing she could do to stop me.
I moved my car.
I hated myself all day for being such a sackless weenie about it.