Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight
View Poll Results: Which sandwiches advance?
Reuben OR
69 51.11%
Pulled Pork
58 42.96%
Banh Mi OR
46 34.07%
Cheesesteak
81 60.00%
Breakfast OR
68 50.37%
Brisket
57 42.22%
BLT OR
54 40.00%
Pastrami
69 51.11%

03-20-2018 , 07:26 PM
Greg,

Quote:
Originally Posted by gregorio
MLY, did El D let you vote this round?

Ugh, not sure if I remembered to ban her from voting this round.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by btc
Pizza is technically an open face sandwich: piece of bread with stuff on it

If you fold the pizza slice does it become an actual sandwich?
It becomes a calzone, and no, that's not a sandwich.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:31 PM
Banh mi is also amazing value. $3.50 for a large.

Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:40 PM
Greg,

Even in sf, the home of mediocre overpriced $10 sandwiches, you can get a great banh mi for under $5.

Edit: of course we do also have plenty of hipster banh mi places with $10 sandwiches...
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:44 PM
I am surprised there hasn't been more of an anti-cilantro outcry re: banh mi.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:44 PM
Nuggetz, your pics look incredibly delicious! Even though half of your breakfast sandwich pics are ineligible, I don't even mind since they look so good!

El D, the banh mi pics in nuggetz' post and your last pic look pretty photogenic to me!
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:49 PM
LOL @ pastrami and Reuben both being on here. Someone from the corned beef lobby rigged the hell out of this contest.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:53 PM
Cranberry,

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cranberry Tea
LOL @ pastrami and Reuben both being on here. Someone from the corned beef lobby rigged the hell out of this contest.

Weird of them to put pastrami through instead of corned beef...
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:55 PM
I had been wanting to get a bahn mi after seeing them on TV but always end up getting somehing else when going to a vietnamese restaurant. I got one today at a place that has pretty good pho but it was underwhelming even though I really want to love it. The ratio of meat to the veggies seemed off.

It was better when I put a bunch of sriracha on it. I even tried dipping it in the pho.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:56 PM
I've seen an awful lot of crazy conspiracy theories on this site, but this one may top them all!

Big Corned Beef rigging the competition on behalf of its biggest competitor, Big Pastrami?!
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 07:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MeLoveYouLongTime
Yes, I've had both.

BBQ Brisket>>>>>>>>any kind of pork

You obviously haven't had a Texas Brisket sanwhich, son

Bless your heart, sweetie.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:00 PM
Action,

Depending on the place and their particular meat ratio, sometimes I ask for extra meat on my banh mi order. They're so cheap that it's not much more, and it can make the resulting sandwich even better!
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:05 PM
Pho is often meatballs and tendons with a metric ton of veggies and noodle. It goes best with Vietnamese iced coffee because I don't like sleeping.

I propose a new title for this thread "Elite 7 and McGriddle," although I dispute the thought that syrup-infused bread is actually bread under the current definitions.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:09 PM
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gregorio
MLY, did El D let you vote this round?
For only one sandwhich though.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Saklad
Bless your heart, sweetie.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:37 PM
Wet, Dry, Squishy.....mmmmmm
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:46 PM
Still looking for nyc banh mi recs as I think they are slightly overrated in this competition.

Num pang + some deli's are what Ive had. Want to set the bar a little higher and maybe see things your guys way.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by El Diablo
Sapo,

It’s just a slippery slope, brother. What next, pitas? Croissants? Arepas? Pupusas? Burritos? Pizzas?

You gotta draw the line somewhere. And bread seems like a good place to draw it!
Anything with 2 slices of grain that has been baked with stuff in between is basically a sandwich. At the same time I think it makes sense in these polls except you'd have to subtract the breakfast sandwich from the polls imo. A breakfast sandwich is nothing on normal bread next to it being on a muffin, biscuit or croissant. I'm thinking that breakfast sandwich should be taken out if we don't include the croissant, biscuit and muffin. If not then a breakfast sandwich just can't compete to be honest.

As a sandwich lover I am loving these threads tho.

Quote:
Originally Posted by MeLoveYouLongTime
Wet, Dry, Squishy.....mmmmmm
After looking at that I have a feeling I've never actually had a really good pulled pork sandwich. Any I've bought were not even on the level of the ones that I've made and I don't know how to make a good pulled pork sandwich specifically, I just know how to make good sandwiches. In that vein I've never had a good pulled pork sandwich cuz an expert would show me up easily after looking at those pics.


Quote:
Originally Posted by OmgGlutten!
My dear lord!! That looks like art wrapped in a sammich!!! I need to find a place that makes that, my sandwich game needs an upgrade. Thanks for the post bud.

Last edited by Sir Huntington; 03-20-2018 at 08:52 PM.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:52 PM
That's chopped Brisket, NOT pulled pork!
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:54 PM
Ok gotcha lol, I've never had a brisket sammich. Only had straight brisket... I think. Either way that looks on point.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:55 PM
Jesus, cheesesteak is going to win the whole thing, isn't it? OOT has the collective palate of a teenage boy.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 08:57 PM
Cheese steak is awesome and more mainstream then most in the poll and it's hard to make a bad one. I'd still take an Italian sub over it tho. Unless you get it from a place that makes it like wawa. # lamesauce
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 09:08 PM
Quote:
it's hard to make a bad one
The carnies at my local St. Patrick's Day street fair and art show would disagree with you.

I love cheesesteak, but that may have been the worst sandwich I ever ate.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote
03-20-2018 , 09:08 PM
There are a lot of ****ty cheesesteaks. The one at Subway might be the worst (I guess it's called Steak and Cheese). But the really good ones are great. They aren't that hard to make but you can end up with **** ones--dry, not enough meat, etc. The bar is pretty high for cheesesteaks here in Philly and I've yet to have a bad one here.
Best sandwich bracket Elite Eight Quote

      
m