Quote:
Originally Posted by fsoyars
I've only ever been to Rudy's, Live Oak and The Salt Lick. Really want to hit Franklin's next time I go. But of the three I've been to I'd rank them Rudy's, Live Oak and then Salt Lick. Rudy's and Live Oak I thought were pretty close with Salt Lick being a clear third, although it definitely gets points for having a fun atmosphere.
You really think Live Oak is that much better than Rudy's? I thought they were both really solid. The brisket and ribs and Live Oak were amazing but the pork steak was kind of meh.
edit: Also I'm not sure what you mean by "I don't have time to wait" or "It's too late to hit anything that's really good." There was no wait at either Rudy's or Live Oak when I went and Live Oak is only open two hours later than Rudy's - 8pm and 10pm respectively.
I can't speak for Live Oak, just heard good things about it. Rudy's isn't anything to write home about, but it's consistent, decent, and well priced. They have hours longer and are just more convenient. I eat there at least twice a month.
For me, Live Oak is too far to be a convenience trip (Louie Mueller is equally close to my home as the nearest Rudy's, and Salt Lick is the closest, but Louie Mueller has more limited hours and selection and a longer wait). Salt Lick's one advantage is Family Style, which if you are eating a ton, can give it great value. I wouldn't say it's fantastic, but it's a solid choice. But there are better choices for people who want to make a special experience.