Quote:
Originally Posted by SalmanRushdieFTW
Wait, wat? In the post I linked, I asked CQ what he thought about Old Fashioneds, and he said he preferred them with rye (the right way to order them) and it's a good drink.
L2R? (Not denying I'm usually condescending, pretty sure I am, but in this instance was actually trying to be helpful.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Clare Quilty
I'm not sure what you mean. I think it's a good, classic drink. If you mean, how do I make them, I've seen a lot of places that muddle fruit (cherries, oranges, etc.) in their Old Fashioneds. Which is not how I roll. I go with a little sugar, bitters in sugar with a bit of water. Stir thoroughly, fill glass with ice, pour rye in and garnish with a twist of orange or lemon peel, essential oils caramelize-flamed onto the drink if I'm feeling extra-saucy.
This is what I was looking for (Salman), because there are a lot of different interpretations of the old fashioned beyond the type of whiskey used. If you order an old fashioned in Chicago, NYC, Miami, Denver, and Green Bay, you'll get 5 similar yet distinctly different drinks. The muddled fruit version is one I tried for the first time recently and was not impressed with. The few times out east I've had old fashioned it's been more in line with what you make.
In Wisconsin where I'm from (particularly the Eastern half), and Old Fashioned is essentially a whiskey sour/sweet with the added bitters/simple syrup dimension. It's admittedly less sexy than a classic old fashioned that most people are used to, but it's also a step up from ordering a standard Jack & Coke or rail whiskey and 7 up.
One of my favorite moderations for making old fashioned as a bartender was subbing in blood orange syrup for simple syrup and garnishing with cherry.