repeal & replace

@ham, Louis --

I'm fine with any of those three options, so long as you pick one of them soon.

Escrow info sent to you, Louis.

@Bob,

There's no reason to not let these guys shift out Baghdadi. I don't think they're angling and there's a reasonable argument about the rules. Your contest, your rules, so that's just one man's opinion.

You're too chicken to play this for money, SA, so you get no voice in this debate. Yes, that's definitely voter suppression. I'll probably forgive you, though, just on Sarah Calixto grounds.

I'll pick a) if no one in the $25 objects. I did not get a PM with the escrow info though.

as a cash pool member, i lean toward option b but will defer to the majority

I'm trying to square this with your prop bet offer

I will do whichever of option A or B the majority prefers. I prefer A. Howard please PM me the escrow info, thx

Should exclude some names like Manson and QE2.

Imo if people with baghdadi are allowed to replace, everyone else should get 1 replacement of their choosing as well

B4L,

Yes, seems fair.

House,

In that case I think it's easier to just say we keep him. I haven't heard anyone but Bob say they really think he should be out.

Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk

I have no problem with either option. I would say I prefer A.

The only problem I see with B is what housenuts said above.

Louis Cyphre has escrowed.

The vote tally seems to be:

A: JDiamon364
B: Econophile
abstain: Howard Treesong

Did I miss anyone? Any other votes by cash pool players?

I am in cash pool and go with option B with Manson and QE2 not eligible to be added to your list. I didn't pick baghdadi because i wasn't sure if he was eligible.

Updated tally:

A: JDiamond364
B: Econophile, rubixxcube
abstain: Howard Treesong

Minor complication: al-Baghdadi is my joker (and first name on the list). I guess according to what was discussed earlier the next name on the list becomes my joker?

Can I please get a final decision on what hamandrye and I are supposed to do?

the more i think about it, it seems like you should just keep your list as is

avoids potential second-mover advantage problems

btw, could you post your list LC? i don't think i saw it upthread.

eta: one proposal that could make everyone happy is keep al-baghdadi on list, but no bonus for violent death. otherwise counts according to bob's rules. would still be a pretty good score since he is 45.

1.Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi (45) [JOKER]
2.Melvin Leon Stottlemyre, Sr. (75)
3. Michael Schumacher (47)
4. Tommy Chong (78)
5. Mary Tyler Morre (80)
6. Aretha Franklin (74)
7. Stephen Hawking (74)
8. Orenthial James Brigance (47)
9. Valerie Kathryn Harper (77)
10. Dwayne Michael Carter Jr. (Lil Wayne) (34)
11. Toni Braxton (49)
12. Stephen Michael Gleason (39)
13. Bryan Clarence Murray (74)
14. William Anthony Perry (54)
15. Scott Mitchell Putesky (48)
16. Barbara Barrie (85)
17. Chen Shui-bian (65)
18. James Reiher Snuka(Jimmy „Superfly“ Snuka) (73)
19. George H.W. Bush (92)
20. Glen Campbell (80)

Very well.

Feel free to send in Al-Baghdadi replacements ham n rye and louis

LC:

Now *that's* a list.

My initial submission contained a list of ranked alternates. If it's just me and Ham replacing I'll just stick to that. There was talk about everybody (in the cash pool) getting the chance to replace one. In that case I would like the option to reconsider my choice.
What was the final decision on that?

That's for the purposes of the cash pool. For the play money pool I am fine with my original alternate.

Not sure what that means.

It means you put together an outstanding list.

Thank you.

These are the final lists that I have for my death pool. If I missed your list or got a name wrong, let me know and I'll recheck my PMs. Gotta admit that some of these read more like wish lists than entries designed to win lol

Note that this is going to be a very long post. I'm ordering them from most recent official entry to first entry received. I also noticed that some of you forgot your jokers. Someone mentioned the idea of having the first name on your list be the joker if you didn't pick one. To me, that is reasonable. Either that or you don't go with a joker. I'm content with both options.

--------------------------------------------

chuckleslovakian

Tommy Lasorda JOKER
Keith Richards
Mick Jagger
Kirk Douglas
Michael Douglas
Martin Scorsese
Pete Rose
Lindsay Lohan
George HW Bush
Walter Mondale
Dan Quayle
Ringo Starr
Bob Dylan
Dick Cheney
Joe Biden
Donald Trump
Hillary Clinton
Kayne West
Charlie Sheen
Martin Sheen

ntanygd760

George Bush old one
Clint Eastwood
Betty White
Dorris Day
Mel Brooks
Jimmy Carter
Lindsay Lohan
Charlie Sheen
Christopher Plummer
Patrick Stewart
William Shatner
Justin Beiber (one time!)
Keisha
Jerry Jones
Hugh Hefner
Bob Barker
Bill Cosby
Steven Hawking
Courtbey

fuluck414

Kirk Douglas
Billy Graham
George H.W. Bush
Bob Barker
Bill Cosby
Jimmy Carter
Stephen Hawking
Courtney Love
Bob Dole
Bob Newhart
Yoko Ono
Barbara Bush
Dick Vandyke
Glen Campbell
Jake LaMotta
Don Rickles
Henry Kissinger
Stan Lee
Whitey Bulger
Joseph Wapner- joker

Morphismus

Justin Bieber
Taylor Swift
Abel Makkonen Tesfaye (aka The Weeknd)
Kristen Stewart
Donald Trump
Samuel L. Jackson
Tobey Maguire
Donald Sutherland
Stan Lee
Sophia Loren
Woody Allen
Queen Elizabeth II
Jack Nicholson
Helmut Kohl
Mick Jagger
Tom Cruise
Steven King
Buzz Aldrin
James Watson
Tenzin Gyatso, the 14th Dalai Lama

Umcle Diddler

William “the refrigerator” Perry
Hugh Hefner
Gene Hackman
Dabney Coleman
Angela Lansbury
Don Imus
Mary Tyler Moore
Roger Moore (007)
Barbara Eden
Lamar Odom
Little Richard
Ozzy Osbourne
Yoko Ono
Doc Gooden (Joker)
Corey Feldman
Glen Campbell
Buddy Guy
Aretha Franklin
Chevy Chase
Artie Lange

Louis Cyphre (Note: I'm subbing out your #1 alt for al-Bag)

1. Lindsay Lohan (30) [JOKER]
2.Melvin Leon Stottlemyre, Sr. (75)
3. Michael Schumacher (47)
4. Tommy Chong (78)
5. Mary Tyler Morre (80)
6. Aretha Franklin (74)
7. Stephen Hawking (74)
8. Orenthial James Brigance (47)
9. Valerie Kathryn Harper (77)
10. Dwayne Michael Carter Jr. (Lil Wayne) (34)
11. Toni Braxton (49)
12. Stephen Michael Gleason (39)
13. Bryan Clarence Murray (74)
14. William Anthony Perry (54)
15. Scott Mitchell Putesky (48)
16. Barbara Barrie (85)
17. Chen Shui-bian (65)
18. James Reiher Snuka(Jimmy „Superfly“ Snuka) (73)
19. George H.W. Bush (92)
20. Glen Campbell (80)

ham n rye (let me know your Al-Bag alt)

oost van der Westhuizen
Steve Gleason
Fernando Ricksen
Helen Fawkes
Valerie Harper
Gord Downie
Paul Gascoigne
Desmond Tutu
Fats Domino
William Perry
Abu Bakr al Baghdadi
Leon White (Vader)
Bryan Murray (NHL)
John Bain
Javier Perez de Cuellar
Val Kilmer
Robert Pirsig
Luke Halpin
Leah Bracknell
Emperor Akihito

econophile

Glen Campbell
Malcolm Young
King Michael of Romania (*joker)
Shannen Doherty
Jake Lamotta
Prince Philip
Monty Hall
Kenneth Arrow
Joseph Lowery
John Paul Stephens
Joseph Wapner
Lawrence Ferlinghetti
Norman Lear
Carl Reiner
Val Kilmer
Stan Lee
Hugh Downs
Jerry Maren
Pierre Cardin
Henry Kissinger

rubixxcube

1. Donald Trump
2. Lindsey Lohan
3. Charlie Sheen (Joker)
4. Ozzy Osborne
5. Michael Lee Aday AKA "Meat Loaf"
6. Joni Mitchell
7. Jamie-Lynn Sigler
8. Dustin Hoffman
9. Val Kilmer
10. Justin Bieber
11. Bob Dole
12. George Bush Sr
13. Miley Cyrus
14. Tommy Chong
15. Stan Lee
16. Betty White
17. Dennis Rodman
18. Bob Barker
19. Clint Eastwood
20. Keith Richards

Tokyo!!

1. Jimmy Snuka (WWF Wrestler)
2. Malcolm Young (AC/DC)
3. Hillary Clinton (****)
4. Glen Campbell (Singer)
5. Bill Clinton (Bimbo Dicker)
6. Steve Gleason (Retired Football Player)
7. Mário Soares (Portuguese Politician)
8. Anna Holmlund (Skiier)
9. Lamar Odom (Retired NBA player/Bimbo Dicker)
10. Jamal Anderson (Retired NFL RB)
11. Eduard Gutknecht (German Boxer)
12. Valerie Harper (Actress)
13. Jason Snelling (Retired NFL RB)
14. Maria Venuti (Australian actress)
15. Leah Bracknell (English actress)
16. Gord Downie (Musician) - JOKER
17. Shannen Doherty (Actress)
18. Eddie Long (Pastor)
19. Kurt Eichenwald (Hack Journalist)
20. Keith Olbermann (Piece of ****/hack TV host)

Loden Pants

Paula Abdul
Wayne LaPierre
Bill Clinton
Donald Trump
Donald Trump, Jr. (joker)
Stevie Wonder
Neil Young
Dionne Warwick
Lance Armstrong
Bobby Doerr
Mary Tyler Moore
Dennis Hastert
Paula Deen
Eva Marie Saint
Michael Douglas
Kirk Douglas
Verne Troyer
Queen Elizabeth II
George H. W. Bush
Bob Newhart

golfnutt

Lamar Odom
Bill Cosby (joker)
Don Rickles
Regis Philbin
Dick Cheney
Pamela Anderson
John Madden
Sepp Blatter
Corey Feldman
Robert Blake
Axl Rose
Ned Beatty
Andy Dick
Hugh Hefner
The Pope
Phil Spector
Ozzy Osbourne
Whitey Bulgar
Bob Barker
Jimmy Carter

PyramidScheme

Bob Barker
Wilford Brimley
George H.W. Bush
Bill Clinton
Glen Campbell (joker)
Irwin Corey
Kirk Douglas
Queen Elizabeth
Matt Harvey
Dub Jones
Stan Lee
Norman Lloyd
Jack Osbourne
Mike Pence
David Rockefeller
Jackie Stallone
Donald Trump
Otto Warmbier
Herman Wouk
Malcolm Young

Howard Treesong

Glen Campbell (joker)
Betty White
George HW Bush
Mel Stottlemyre
Kirk Douglas
Henry Kissinger
Hugh Hefner
Bashar al-Assad
Sean Connery
Jimmy Carter
Clint Eastwood
Angela Lansbury
Bob Barker
Mel Brooks
Adam West
Jerry Lewis
Monty Hall
Don Rickles
Nicolas Maduro
Summer Redstone
Bill Russell

425kid

Queen Elizabeth
Jon Jones
Ronda Rousey
Bob Dole
Jimmy Carter
Donald Trump
Stephen Hawking
Bashar Al Assad
Recep Erdogan
Kim Jong Un
Michael Schumacher - Joker
Pope Benedict XVI
Hosni Mubarak
King Michael of Romania
Mugabe
Sean Connery
Mikhail Gorbachev
Kirk Douglas
Prince Philip
Ursula Le Guin

wesrwood

Bill Cosby
Bill Clinton
Donald trump
Queen Elizabeth
Charlie sheen
Lamar Odom
Rhonda rousey
Kurt angle
Paige (wrestler )
Betty white
Dennis Rodman
Jon jones
Tony Stewart
Dmx - joker
Hulk hogan
Ric flair
Mick jagger
Steven Tyler
Kanye west
Tommy Chong

Abysmal

Stephen hawking - joker
Doug Stanhope
Johnny Manziel
David Rockefeller
Donald trump
Betty White
Marilyn Manson
Dolly Parton
Justin Bieber
Grace slick
Bill Clinton
Chris Brown
Rihanna
George w bush
Amanda Bynes
DMX
Joe Montana
Kanye west
Ronnie wood
Mick Jagger

True North

Donald Trump
Ivanka Trump
Bill Clinton
Jimmy Carter
George H. W. Bush
Bill Cosby
Hugh Hefner
Betty White
Tommy Chong
Shannon Doherty
Brett Favre
Bobby Brown
Cher
Paul Gascoigne
Randall McDaniel
Kevin Mawae
Scott Hall
Selena Gomez
Lena Dunham
Gord Downie - JOKER

krunic

Katt Williams
Donald Trump
Bill Clinton
Dick Cheney
Jacques Chirac - joker
Flava Flav
Lamar Odom
Lenny Dykstra
Keith Richards
Donatella Versace
Jake "The Snake" Roberts
Kirstie Alley
Charlie Sheen
Zac Efron
Lindsay Lohan
Glen Campbell
Mary Tyler Moore
Jenna Jameson
Tommy Chong
Jerry Lewis

JDiamond364

Lamar Odom
Justin Beiber
Ian McKellen
Charlie Sheen
Mick Jagger
Bill Cosby
Little Richard
Lil Wayne (Joker)
Stan Lee
Tommy Chong
Mary Tyler Moore
Stevie Wonder
Hillary Clinton
Joe Jackson
Jerry Lawler
Hugh Hefner
Stephen Hawking
Jimmy Snuka
Don Rickles
Doyle Brunson

toedder

Betty White
Bob Barker
Monty Hall
Billy Graham
Hugh Hefner
Doris Day
Olivia de Havilland
Michèle Morgan
Carol Channing
Nanette Fabray
Irwin Corey
Kirk Douglas
Marty Allen
Roy Dotrice
Carl Reiner
Pierre Cardin
Stan Lee
Jimmy Carter
Prince Philipp
Henry Kissinger

kdub72

Richard Petty
Nazr Mohammed
Donald Trump
Dan Aykroyd
Shannen Doherty
Leon White (Wrestler Big Van Vader)
Jared Leto
Angela Lansbury
Verne Troyer
Emmanuel Lewis
Willie Nelson
Ric Flair
Lamar Odom
Val Kilmer
Andy Dick
Louie Anderson
Kurt Angle
Bob Sager
Dick Cheney
Kathy Bates

housenuts

George RR Martin
Jared Fogle
Hugh Hefner
Bob Barker
Izzy Stradlin
Sepp Blatter
Snooki
Jodie Sweetin
Doyle Brunson
Michael Caine
Sporty Spice
Scooter Braun
Fay Vincent (JOKER)
Katey Sagal
Ann Coulter
Mel Brooks
Jeffrey Ross
Roseanne
John Goodman
William Hung

ScreaminAsian

Henry Kissinger
Don Rickles
Donald Trump
Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II
Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
Jimmy Carter
George Herbert Walker Bush
Aretha Franklin
Macaulay Culkin
Elizabeth Warren
Bernie Sanders
Barney Frank
Mario Andretti
Jackie Martling
Hugh Hefner
Sheldon Adelson
Betty White
James Watson
Bernard Madoff
Artie Lange (joker)

SuperUberBob

Mel Stottlemyre
George H.W. Bush
Jimmy Carter
Olivia de Havilland
Kirk Douglas
Queen Elizabeth II
Carl Reiner
Don Rickles
Jake La Motta
Stephen Hawking
Henry Kissinger
Willie Mays
Billy Graham
Bob Dole
Mary Tyler Moore
Jenna Jameson*
Donald Trump
Stan Lee
Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
Jack Nicholson

*joker

My main fear is that if the rules change too much that it can become a bit confusing to read everything going on. Your rule won't confuse things that much but imo if more things get changed, the cash pool should probably have a separate thread.

This should be Bob Barker. I verified that my PM requested to replace Craig Sager with Bob Barker after Sager passed. Thanks!