Quote:
Originally Posted by GreenVert
Make sense but not fair cause the flush beats the straight and yes the straight beats the pair but when does the player win all the pot without sharing ? 🤔 in the other hands itÂ’s cool everyone can win.
It is fair because player C did not risk the same amount of chips as players A and B did, so he should not be allowed to win the same amount of chips. Think about a real money game where player A and B have $300 and player C has only $20. Is it fair for player C to be able to win $300 from each opponent when he wins, but only lose $20 when he loses? Obviously not. That would give player C a big advantage over A and B since C risks $20 to possibly win $600 while A or B risk $300 to possibly win $320.
In this case the right, and most fair procedure is to put $20 from each player into a main pot - $60 total. Each player is risking the same amount, $20 and each stands to win the same amount, $60. The remaining $280 from players A and B goes to a separate pot that player C cannot win. A and B each risk $280 in this pot to win $560.
If one player is to win both pots, it must be A or B having the best hand. In practice, the side pot gets decided first. The player who loses between A and B obviously cannot have the best hand among A,B and C for the main pot, so the side pot loser is eliminated, and the main pot will be decided between the winner and player C.
Suppose A has a flush, B has a straight, and C has a pair. Then the side pot goes to A and Bs hand is killed (he canÂ’t win the main since he canÂ’t beat A). Since A has a better hand than C, A wins the main as well. If C instead had a full house, A would still win the side pot, but C would now win the main.
If you have multiple players with different stack sizes all going all in (as is common at play money tables), it can get pretty complex. There will be multiple side pots. It still is fair though in the sense that no player risks less than any other involved in any of the pots. The smallest stack will only be in the main pot. The second smallest only in the main and the first side pot, the third smallest in the main and first two side pots, and so on. Within each side pot (and the main) each player eligible to win will have contributed the same amount.