Quote:
the final answer every lawyer I have read gives is "I don't know if online poker is illegal or not."
Why the confusion?
They're so confused because they're ignoring the subject of the UIGEA, which isn't "poker" or "gambling" but banking.
Internet poker's
legal status has not changed as a result of the UIGEA. For that matter, neither has the legal status of real gambling, like casino games.
The act prohibited banking institutions from conducting business with "gambling" sites. Unfortunately, the only unclear thing is whether or not poker is a game of skill or a game of chance. Presently, it's considered a game of chance, and hence even those sites offering only poker are the subject of the prohibition.
So, if before the UIGEA you weren't in jeopardy of breaking any law (and some folks were, due to state or local laws), you aren't now.
Check out
this cardplayer article for more details. Also, I'm fairly sure there's something in these forums, too, but you'll have to find it.