Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** ***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread***

12-19-2016 , 05:30 PM
This is like a christmas calender that features chocolate with nuts you're allergic to.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 05:59 AM
This month just is the same ****. What a waste of a Christmas Calendar.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 06:42 AM
oh wow a 3/4th deposit bonus day? I could deposit another $270 to win $2? no way , what an exciting christmas calendar !
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 07:15 AM
Can't believe that 20% of the promotions have been deposit bonus'. I knew there would be one or two because they did last year but really... 4? Who's getting paid to make exciting and fun promo's that makes people want to play? I feel a redundancy letter is due...
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 07:25 AM
Running out of time for a decent promo, lol at a 4th MiniBonus.

They're running milestone hands on the American site - maybe we'll at least get one day of that?
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 07:40 AM
I allways thought it costs the site when player deposits. Guess this is a way to offer a deposit bonuses that nobody uses.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 07:50 AM
Yeah I'm not sure how much money they are really getting from this promo? All 4 times I've deposited, got my $1-$2 and withdrew that same amount within 5 minutes. Surely I'm not the only one?
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 08:55 AM
$30 * 4 deposits got me $2, $1, $1, $1

Last year I received $5, $10 bonuses
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 10:59 AM
I think the fact that I've only participated on 1 day out of the 20 days so far in the Christmas calendar promotion and actually lost money when I did participate says it all...

I personally find the whole promotion to be unimaginative and a waste of my time.

Last edited by Sonicdahedgehog; 12-20-2016 at 11:15 AM.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 11:06 AM
Unimaginative is 100% the word! It just looks lazy, like they have spent an hour thinking of 7-8 promo's that they have already used before and said yeah we'll repeat these, that will do! It's just so lazy... there are people out there who would actually enjoy making good promo's as a job!

I guess there's no point in moaning as it gets us nowhere... it's just a shame to see stars go so downhill in the 5 years of me playing poker!
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 12:44 PM
+1 Absolutely agree with you guys. I was expecting something similar to what we saw last year but this year the promos are getting way too repetitive, uninteresting and less exciting. I remember last year PokerStars Matthew who used to be active in this thread whom I have huge respect, asked for our feedback/ideas should they do this christmas calendar again. And this is what the feedback was provided:

Quote:
Originally Posted by PokerStars Matthew
As we evaluate the Christmas Calendar promotion, I'd be interested in your overall feedback and ideas if we do it again.
"Liked the Straight Flush, Mega Bonus and 180's promotions. Still struggle to see how all-in shootouts with 25c equity appeal to anyone."
"The straight flush was the one I liked the best"
"Yea it's definitely a great promo, probably the best they've done so far in the calendar! "
"This was great. More stuff like this please!"
"Keep promotions like this one coming!"
"180-man promo was one of the best promos PS had in a long time. Also loved the straight flush challenge"
"180 promo was great"
"Great promotion, well done stars!!"
"tell the promo guy at stars to keep giving real good promos like this one."
"Really like the promo. cheers."
"Finally not a horrible promo"
"Best challenge so far imo, wish I had seen it earlier."
"The promo was just sick."
"more EV+ challenges, less cheap shootouts."
"The best promotions are the ones that give away instant cash bonuses, such as the 180-man challenge, and the straight-flush challenge, golden SNGs, etc..."
"anything better than 20K shootout with 35K players registered. plz."

What's the point of asking for our feedback when you know you're gonna do what you think its the best? (unless you come up with these promos in next 4-5 days which I see highly unlikely)

Funny thing is that your non christmas month promo when you had card match month promo, cash game quest promo in january gave us better EVs than what we are getting in this month..

This guy was absolutely right
Quote:
Originally Posted by bhoylegend
This is code for 'Well done for catching us this time but rest assured this promo will never happen again in its current format'. In fairness to Matthew, I think he encouraged grinders to go for it, but once the numbers are crunched they will realise it favoured the scummy net withdrawers.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 12:46 PM
Maybe next time if they ever come up with a good promo we should better be criticizing it.. higher chance they will repeat that promo
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 01:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by saxby93
Yeah I'm not sure how much money they are really getting from this promo? All 4 times I've deposited, got my $1-$2 and withdrew that same amount within 5 minutes. Surely I'm not the only one?
I'm pretty sure you lost money by doing so.They have a 3% fee for every deposit you make and another exchange rate for withdrawal.
For example,if you deposit 100$ +3% fee(3$) and you get 1 or 2 $ bonus..you still lose(obviously).
And how lucky you must be to deposit 20$ to get extra 2$ when i received the same amount for depositing 400$
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 02:08 PM
I'm not a massive player on Stars anymore or indeed on any poker site. My issue with this calendar is that pretty much every promo in it has been to Stars' benefit, not the players.

A micro millions 'promo' = thanks for all the extra rake they took that day.

That said, they answer to shareholders now, they are a different company. The answer is simply to play elsewhere. If you continue to play there and simply whine about ever increasing rake and poor promos then you are simply giving them evidence to support their view that poker players will remain as customers even with a price hike.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 02:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by suzyana
I'm pretty sure you lost money by doing so.They have a 3% fee for every deposit you make and another exchange rate for withdrawal.
For example,if you deposit 100$ +3% fee(3$) and you get 1 or 2 $ bonus..you still lose(obviously).
And how lucky you must be to deposit 20$ to get extra 2$ when i received the same amount for depositing 400$
I'm from the UK and have a GBP account on stars that I transfer to as there are no charges. Had to put £24 in, which gave me £24 and same with withdrawing, no charges... it would have charged me if I had put it straight into my USD account and vise versa.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 05:07 PM
A simple thing for this promotion and for promotions in general: Nothing comes for free!Even it's for free,it's probably the worse deal!
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 05:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Perfection
I'm not a massive player on Stars anymore or indeed on any poker site. My issue with this calendar is that pretty much every promo in it has been to Stars' benefit, not the players.
Bingo. This month hasn't been full of promotions, as advertised, it's been full of gimmicks designed to generate rake. I've got no problem with PS trying to generate more money, but don't insult the players by calling this a promotion.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-20-2016 , 08:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VelvetGreen
Bingo. This month hasn't been full of promotions, as advertised, it's been full of gimmicks designed to generate rake. I've got no problem with PS trying to generate more money, but don't insult the players by calling this a promotion.
I hate to break the bad news but all promotions are nothing other than gimmicks to make money for the site. In some cases you may be tricked into feeling good by the fact that you personally somehow came out ahead but the real purpose is to drive revenue and profit for the site. What has shifted is more of a focus on an immediate or short term payoff rather than long term payoffs. No business just gives away money. Whatever they may say they are giving away they are really expecting to make several times more in additional profit. It is like a store running a sale. They give up a portion of their per unit profit with the goal of increasing the number of sales which brings in more revenue overall.

Not saying the quality of these promotions don't suck because they do. But even "good" promotions are run for the ultimate benefit of the site. The difference between a good promo and a bad promo for the player is how it makes you feel to take part. For the site the difference is how successful the promo is at driving additional traffic. A great promo is one that makes the players feel good and makes lots of additional money for the site. A disaster promo pisses off the players and loses money for the site. We can speculate where this series of promos falls on that spectrum.

What has also changed is Stars promos are no longer aimed at anyone that reads or post on 2+2. They see us as a group that will for the most part either give them our business or not and will not be strongly swayed one way or another by promos. Just look at how long it has been since a Stars rep participated in this thread?
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-21-2016 , 06:56 PM
New promotion to gamble 7-70 starscoins for your chance to win a jackpot (prob like 1 in 5 0million times or something fun like that) You have 7 cards remove two and get rewards based on the 5 cards you have.
https://gyazo.com/7bbf28e11f47d7d704f5b6dbf8d96794

Payouts:
https://gyazo.com/e97aed596467328358c32b015e159eb2


fk off amaya


edit/

New promotion to gamble 7-70 starscoins for your chance to win a jackpot (prob like 1 in 5 0million times or something fun like that) You have 7 cards remove two and get rewards based on the 5 cards you have.
https://gyazo.com/7bbf28e11f47d7d704f5b6dbf8d96794

Payouts:
https://gyazo.com/e97aed596467328358c32b015e159eb2


fk off amaya


edit/

oh this just happened https://gyazo.com/06d24758296c6a73f9084fc5de500c1a
maybe it's not truly that terrible, 50% goes to winner if he gets jackpot and 50% goes to whoever has played in last 12 hrs , so it might be +ev to play this daily hoping someone wins jackpot and u get 50% share split ?
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-21-2016 , 07:25 PM
Can you somehow get rid of this deal thing in your lobby?
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-21-2016 , 08:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TreadLightly
New promotion to gamble 7-70 starscoins for your chance to win a jackpot (prob like 1 in 5 0million times or something fun like that) You have 7 cards remove two and get rewards based on the 5 cards you have.
https://gyazo.com/7bbf28e11f47d7d704f5b6dbf8d96794

Payouts:
https://gyazo.com/e97aed596467328358c32b015e159eb2


fk off amaya


edit/

New promotion to gamble 7-70 starscoins for your chance to win a jackpot (prob like 1 in 5 0million times or something fun like that) You have 7 cards remove two and get rewards based on the 5 cards you have.
https://gyazo.com/7bbf28e11f47d7d704f5b6dbf8d96794

Payouts:
https://gyazo.com/e97aed596467328358c32b015e159eb2


fk off amaya


edit/

oh this just happened https://gyazo.com/06d24758296c6a73f9084fc5de500c1a
maybe it's not truly that terrible, 50% goes to winner if he gets jackpot and 50% goes to whoever has played in last 12 hrs , so it might be +ev to play this daily hoping someone wins jackpot and u get 50% share split ?
Wow! Thats a really ****ty thing, a new way to make people lose the little reward they got at the tables.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-21-2016 , 09:22 PM
lol just noticed my doubled up comments in my post, disregard idk what happened
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-22-2016 , 01:44 AM
3 cent shootouts again today...
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-22-2016 , 02:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by saxby93
Yeah I'm not sure how much money they are really getting from this promo? All 4 times I've deposited, got my $1-$2 and withdrew that same amount within 5 minutes. Surely I'm not the only one?
how do you managed to insta withdraw? isnt the 48 hours applicable to you?
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote
12-22-2016 , 05:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PumaPerez
how do you managed to insta withdraw? isnt the 48 hours applicable to you?
Ewallets don't have the 48 hour rule. Although I'm also UK, perhaps different elsewhere.
***PokerStars Promotions Ideas/Suggestions/Opinions Thread*** Quote

      
m