Quote:
Originally Posted by nickjehz
So lets say the govt. does this, how on earth are they going to enforce this?
to provide an outline let's say there are 4 stages of bitcoinization.
phase 1 (today) - extremely small segment of the population using bitcoin regularly
phase 2 - transition phase where regular people acquire bitcoin and adopt it's use for everyday life
phase 3 - you check out at walmart and the kiosk has two payment options, USD or BTC
phase 4 - you check out at walmart and the kiosk only accepts BTC
what phase 2 would actually look like is a complete mystery. this is the phase where the "hodlers" think they become billionares.
i have no idea why regular people would participate in phase 2. the zealots are counting on a future use or quality for BTC that hasn't been discovered yet which will make it a better option.
but lets pretend this use for BTC is discovered and housewives across america can't wait to pay for their morning starbucks with BTC. how do they acquire it? they must patronize some kind of currency exchange. this is where the government inserts themselves and levies the 10% tax.
i have a very hard time imagining what currently undiscovered reason a random soccer mom will use to pay in bitcoin, but it will need to be a very very good reason to justify paying an extra 10% and waste a bunch of time to ultimately purchase the exact same product.
will soccer mom patronize a shady, off-shore exchange in order to acquire BTC for 10% less to then pay for her starbucks? seems difficult and far fetched.
there's still OTC trades. the equivalent of your local bookie except he's selling BTC instead of taking wagers. well he wants his cut too. and again, i'm still wondering why soccer mom is going through all this trouble to pay for starbucks.
Quote:
The beautiful thing is that its hard to regulate and one of the core reasons for crypto is to get rid of 3rd parties like banks and govt.
it's not hard to regulate at all. they just aren't doing it right now. it is hard to completely decimate, though, but they don't need to do that. if they keep it small and underground enough that they can easily monitor the entire network, that will be good enough for them.