It's not even a good post. It's completely wrong.
Legal opinion from multiple lawyers interviewed by mainstream news: This was a very strong case, almost open/shut, that Musk is liable. The decision by the jury is comically wrong.
Legal opinion from the gaggle of losers/Musk fanboys on 2p2: Musk did nothing wrong! Everyone who said he did is wrong!
I know who I'm siding with:
Quote:
Several other attorneys who specialize in defamation cases privately expressed surprise at the outcome of what they viewed as a strong case for the cave explorer, Vernon Unsworth. They attributed it to Musk’s fame and the perceived youthfulness of the jury.
Quote:
“While there is more leeway and more hyperbole online and in social media in general, courts never really accepted that argument that social media is a libel free-zone,” said Lyrissa Lidsky, a professor who specializes in defamation at the University of Missouri School of Law.
Several attorneys said Unsworth appeared to have a strong case, and noted that Musk failed to convince the judge to dismiss it at an early stage. But they cautioned that anything can happen in a courtroom where factors such as the credibility of witnesses and likeability of parties can become important factors.
“Based on the court’s pre-trial rulings on motions, Mr. Unsworth’s case going in had the potential to underpin a substantial verdict in his favor,” said John Walsh, who represents people bringing defamation cases.
Those quotes are the end of the argument for anyone sane. As usual, Musk fans completely fail to grasp reality, and after horribly idiotic analysis, see a 2 outer as validating their position.
The same failure of logic lost them a fortune in "funding secured", where the logic was clearly that Musk was committing securities fraud and that it was a clear short as a result, but their priors are so ****ed up that they couldn't see that.
Musk is clearly wrong here, both morally and legally, and money/great lawyers/a jury fluke got him off. It happens. Enjoy it (just like fish enjoy a 2 outer on the river), but don't try reaching into something it's not, you just end up looking even more ridiculous.