Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
TSLA showing cracks? TSLA showing cracks?

05-02-2019 , 11:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
It's not circular, it's probabilistic.

P(Musk wouldn't raise when he can and not raising money does long term needless harm to the company) <80% imo at the most generous take. The assumption being that he's not insane and that M3 demand is as high as he claims (i.e. he can sell all cars he make up to 10/week).

Really? Name the other times? Name one other time? You just wholesale make **** up. Musk has always raised well in advance of need. And that's provable. This is 10 years of Tesla's working capital history:



Musk has been at the verge of bankruptcy as a very small company and couldn't get funding and had to go begging and lying to get funding, but that's not the same thing as deliberately "waiting until the last minute".

He's never let working capital even get negative before, let alone at a time when the stock price is so high AND he needs working capital more than ever for major expansion. Musk claimed that Tesla were "single digit weeks away from dying" last year...and they ended up building a makeshift line in a tent and not increasing SG&A just as they pushed out 2x more cars...to horrible consequences for customers. How does this make sense?

Musk is:

- Insane and incompetent as a CEO, harming Tesla's brand and long term future and risking "single digit weeks from dying" when he can easily raise OR
- Can't raise.

If you see a third way of explaining it, I'm all ears.
80% chance that Tesla can't raise money according to tooth sayer. Hate it when those 4-1 longshots come in.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 11:18 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SenorKeeed
80% chance that Tesla can't raise money according to tooth sayer. Hate it when those 4-1 longshots come in.
God this is funny. Go through the logic again. This is a claim that there is at least a 20% chance that they can't raise.

Quote:
P(Musk wouldn't raise when he can and not raising money does long term needless harm to the company) <80% imo at the most generous take
Let me put that into language.

The probability that Musk wouldn't raise when he desperately needs to is less than 80%.

In other words, the probability of the opposite (that Musk is blocked from raising) is >20%.

Thus an 80% outcome came in when it turned out they could raise. LOL @ you, this is a pretty hilarious logic fail. Thanks for quoting me and proving my point about how careful and probabilistic the bear thesis was.

In reality, even though I was careful in the post you so kindly quoted (thanks for making me look good? That was kind of you), I put the odds at around 50% they can't raise, exactly as I said.

Last edited by ToothSayer; 05-02-2019 at 11:24 AM.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 11:21 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SenorKeeed
80% chance that Tesla can't raise money according to tooth sayer. Hate it when those 4-1 longshots come in.
"The assumption being that he's not insane and that M3 demand is as high as he claims"

The assumptions turned out to be false. That's what you should be flaming him for.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 11:21 AM
It doesn't change the bear case, but it extends the time frame at least 6 months. And that is a lot of time for a guy like Musk to come up with a scheme that drags it out another 6 months...

That tweet about the prospectus is nice
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 11:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
God this is funny. Go through the logic again. This is a claim that there is at least a 20% chance that they can't raise.


Let me put that into language.

The probability that Musk wouldn't raise when he desperately needs to is less than 80%.

In other words, the probability of the opposite (that Musk is blocked from raising) is >20%.

Thus an 80% outcome came in when it turned out they could raise. LOL @ you, this is a pretty hilarious logic fail. Thanks for quoting me and proving my point about how careful and probabilistic the bear thesis was.

In reality, even though I was careful in the post you so kindly quoted (thanks for making me look good? That was kind of you), I put the odds at around 50% they can't raise, exactly as I said.
I'll certainly admit I didn't do more than skim this post this morning. You believed in your delusional conspiracy theory at a confidence of fifty percent, though? Still pretty bad man.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 11:46 AM
more about the raise from the WSJ:

https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB1005017850485007360

(credit @TheAdaptedMind on twitter)
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 12:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SenorKeeed
I'll certainly admit I didn't do more than skim this post this morning. You believed in your delusional conspiracy theory at a confidence of fifty percent, though? Still pretty bad man.
Delusional conspiracy theory? How do you figure a 50% probability of a somewhat common event as "delusional conspiracy theory"? Companies get blocked from raising all the time when the SEC investigates fraud or there's MNPI they don't want to disclose.

For one, we don't know whether they could raise back then and now had it lifted. The SEC had active investigations and in August he committed again massive securities fraud. Musk himself claimed they were "single digit weeks from dying" which is impossible if they could raise. So either Musk deliberately lied about his company about to die, and all the desperate actions he took for that - like building a tent line out of scap or letting servicing die and killing his brand - or the thesis was correct.

The thing which put the odds down below 50% for me was Clayton's incredible weakness in the face of securities fraud. I said as much at the time. If the SEC chair is willing to intervene to let that go, it seems unlikely he'd allow the SEC to prevent a raise.

Everything was highly rational in the thesis and the thing I gave the higher probability to came in. Looks like a whole lot of winning to me.

For my personal analysis I modeled the situation extensively with pages of formulas. I had 30% odds of "can't raise". This is a small section of a complicated mathematical model I did in March at $280 to price option probabilities at various strikes and times to find the best plays. I don't post this stuff here because there are too many undeserving cucks who go after me, but I'll throw back the curtain for a minute to show you how intelligent people analyze outcomes rationally:



We're currently in the highest probability segment of "demand death".
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 12:01 PM
Not updating guidance for Q2 and 2019 deliveries prior to this raise is going to be nuts, but you know they wont
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 12:09 PM
Probably worth pointing out Tesla Shanghai got 500m commitment from Chinese banks and can most likely get the other 1.5 billion from the same Chinese banks.

Tesla internally at least thinks it's still growing.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 12:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by syndr0me
Not updating guidance for Q2 and 2019 deliveries prior to this raise is going to be nuts, but you know they wont
from what i read on twitter, zach talked like one time on the call with underwriters and that was to reiterate q2 delivery guidance. otherwise it was elon selling autonomy
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 12:46 PM
The other part of the can't raise thesis was that if Elon actually can raise its on horrible terms. Lets see how this plays out.


Edit: Sounds like Elon is pushing Autonomy hard as the reason for needing money which is strange since Autonomy Day was a flop and its obvious they need to burn the cash to survive. Also reiterated guidance. Won't these lies be revealed in the next two months? What is the endgame here? I know Elon lied before to get money but it was always more forward looking. Is this his last shot?

Last edited by MrFeelNothin; 05-02-2019 at 12:52 PM.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 12:49 PM
Elon about to launch another rocket. Also, going to launch this stock as a metaphorical rocket.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 01:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BooLoo
more about the raise from the WSJ:

https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB1005017850485007360

(credit @TheAdaptedMind on twitter)
I chuckled
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 01:54 PM
I'm not going to cover. It's clear that the converts and equity will be issued at a strike lower than today's close, so the stock should go down. All this does is remove BK from the equation, but still, it's absurd when you consider that a stock price of 120 is still 21b+ in market cap in view of failing demand.

So they bring net working capital to zero. How do they address cash flow?

Luckily I decided not to go for crash puts until July and I already rolled my 2019 puts so patience paid out I guess.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 02:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mori****a System
I'm not going to cover. It's clear that the converts and equity will be issued at a strike lower than today's close, so the stock should go down. All this does is remove BK from the equation, but still, it's absurd when you consider that a stock price of 120 is still 21b+ in market cap in view of failing demand.

So they bring net working capital to zero. How do they address cash flow?

Luckily I decided not to go for crash puts until July and I already rolled my 2019 puts so patience paid out I guess.
Yes I also got a little lucky in that I sold my Jan 2020 crash puts earlier this week. June 2020s still down quite a bit.

July/August 200s down bigly but when Q2 comes in way below guidance I still feel like those are live.

Feels like should be adding more here but don't want to end up way overweight.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 02:04 PM
Also not covering. Adding at 250 if it ever sees it.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-02-2019 , 02:12 PM
Not covering shares but sold my aug 19 200s I got a ways back and were tracking nicely until now
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-03-2019 , 08:00 AM
Interesting developments:

1. They just increased the size of the raise. Obviously incredibly desperate for cash/near bankruptcy without it.

Quote:
Tesla said Friday it will boost the size of its stock and bond offering that electric car maker announced a day before and that CEO Elon Musk will now buy even more stock in the offering.

The company will now sell 3.1 million shares, up from 2.7 million previously and boost its convertible notes offering to $1.6 billion, according to filings. Musk will now purchase up to 102,880 shares in stock worth $25 million, more than double his previous indication to buy 41,896 shares.
2. Musk remains one of the greatest conmen of our generation, treating Wall Street like the donkey as he puts a carrot-painted turd in front of Wall Street bankers:

Quote:
Musk confidently told investors on the call that autonomous driving will transform Tesla into a company with a $500 billion market cap, these people said. Its current market cap stands around $42 billion. He also said that existing Teslas will increase in value as self-driving capabilities are added via software, and will be worth up to $250,000 within three years....A Tesla will be worth $150,000 to $250,000 in 3 years, he claimed. He also said that a full self-driving upgrade will increase the value of any Tesla by a half order of magnitude, or five times.
Current Tesla will be worth $250K in three years. Love the "order of magnitude" mention again - previous "order of magnitude" mentions include robotic speed (outcome: 1980s hand line in tent), service speed (outcome: can't get Teslas fixed for months). And it continues: I love the balls on this guy as he goes even deeper in to pure fraud (his balls are almost as big as Elizabeth Holme's):
Quote:
He said that even though Tesla drivers need to keep hands on the wheel today, that will become less necessary over time. Musk said that competitors such as GM’s Cruise and Alphabet’s Waymo can’t catch up because Tesla has a fleet of connected cars on the road today, and a proprietary chip.
People that are 5+ years ahead "can't catch up". This is great stuff. Also love the selling of the "proprietary chip" as an advantage.

More:

Quote:
On Thursday’s investor call, according to the people who heard it, Musk and other Tesla execs declined to give details when it came to more pragmatic issues like where the company’s order book stands today, what they are doing to ameliorate problems with Tesla service and repairs, how much income Tesla expects to generate from regulatory credits for the rest of this year, and who will supply battery cells to Tesla in Asia as it begins manufacturing Model 3s in Shanghai.

One person asked what Tesla could do to improve its gross margins from the approximately 20% reported in the first quarter of 2019. The company previously promised it could achieve 25% margins.

Musk told investors Tesla would try to improve efficiency in its supply chain, but would feel good about 20% gross margins moving forward.

But he also tried to drive the conversation back to autonomy, calling it the fundamental driver of value for Tesla, and urged investors to stop nit-picking over vehicle margins.
He's up there with Madoff, Holmes and Skilling in the amount of bull**** he can spew and have people with money believe it. He's not quite Ron Hubbard level but he's getting close.

A recap from this last massive fraud to see where we are on the massive fraud timeline:

Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Beautiful stuff.

With no cash left and desperately cutting capex which means no M3 ramp and no Model Y in sight, he couldn't hype the M3 ramp or Model Y any more, so he did the old donkey carrot trick again:



Your average Tesla investor


Classic confidence man. Open big with a lie ("funding secured") and a shiny fake target ($420). Play people's FOMO ("I don't want miss out on $420!"). Assuage all their concerns with lies ("Anyone who wants to keep their stock, can!", "funding secured!"). Attack the evil shorts for trying to tear down his noble company (every good con needs a devil trying to harm their noble selfless goal).

Then, leverage those lies (fake "funding secured") - into an offering to join this "funding secured" investment at $420, because he wants to get a "wide investors pool" to "avoid concentration of ownership".

This is stock fraud on such an epic scale, and so blatant, he now has a big SEC target on his back. They can't ignore it. This is certainly their top priority case now.

Previous Musk donkey carrot FOMOs (look at the shiny object! If you sell now you'll miss out!):

- Permanently profitable claimed in 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018
- "Fully Self Driving" features coming in "3 months possibly, 6 months definitely" - January 2017
- 5000 M3s/week by the end of 2017 [knowingly false statement]
- Machine that builds the machines/air friction limited robot factory that outdoes the majors
- Beautiful solar roofs (they were mocked up frauds that didn't even exist).
- 2 years for full autonomy in 2015
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-03-2019 , 10:16 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
He's up there with Madoff, Holmes and Skilling in the amount of bull**** he can spew and have people with money believe it. He's not quite Ron Hubbard level but he's getting close.
Musk was just investigated by the SEC. The SEC is pretty inept but I doubt they are so inept they missed a fraud that large.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-03-2019 , 10:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by turtletom
Musk was just investigated by the SEC. The SEC is pretty inept but I doubt they are so inept they missed a fraud that large.
I don't think this is a reasonable take. They missed Madoff - a $50 billion ponzi - over decades despite whistleblowers, impossible returns, and several actual investigations.

As for Musk, the staff wanted to remove him as director but Jay Clayton personally intervened. Musk must have him in his pocket. Such is life when you're a billionaire.

Congratulations on your sweet bottom pick long. A bit of luck too but it seems it was nice timing.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-03-2019 , 10:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by turtletom
The SEC is pretty inept but I doubt they are so inept they missed a fraud that large.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-03-2019 , 10:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
I don't think this is a reasonable take. They missed Madoff - a $50 billion ponzi - over decades despite whistleblowers, impossible returns, and several actual investigations.

As for Musk, the staff wanted to remove him as director but Jay Clayton personally intervened. Musk must have him in his pocket. Such is life when you're a billionaire.

Congratulations on your sweet bottom pick long. A bit of luck too but it seems it was nice timing.
TY. Luck always helps even if the odds are in your favor.

Also, I would argue that Madoff carried far more credibility than Musk which is why the investigations were so fruitless. Lots of people think Musk is a fraud (I mean look at this thread).

I know zero about the fundamentals here. Trade was based solely off me seeing tons about TSLA going broke on twitter and then I saw tons on it here. Prompted me to look at it more. Don't plan on holding this trade for more than 3 months so all of you could still be right. At this point we need to squeeze some shorts though I think.

Edit: Also, everything in my body wants me to take some profit off the table here bc up 7 or 8%. Usually that intutition is wrong so I'm holding. Maybe get a good Monday and take some off or something. Think we can at least fill that gap at 285 if we can get back inside its range. Also, likely trend followers shorting on breakout so adds fuel to fire if we get more of a squeeze.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-03-2019 , 01:13 PM
https://old.reddit.com/r/teslamotors..._for_my_close/
I'm going full in on drinking the Kool-Aid. I just placed an order for three Model 3 SR+ cars for my close family members with the hope that they appreciate in value and that I can put them on the Tesla Network.

My plan is to let them use the cars for free until I can put them on the network and then they can still use them as their daily transport after then.

If the cars truly appreciate in value, I may just sell the cars and not worry about ride sharing.
at least a lot of ppl commenting are saying this maybe isn't that great of an idea, but still... there are people like this who really exist and are real people
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-03-2019 , 01:22 PM
Of course there are. Tens of thousands of people believe a mentally ill 1960s science fiction writer when he says that personal issues are caused by the residual souls of people blown by up hydrogen bombs a trillion years ago by an evil galactic warlord.

Why wouldn't people believe that a guy with a cool rocket company who's delivered on lots of stuff that people thought impossible, is telling the truth when he says he'll do something amazing with autonomous cars next year?

It's really that simple when it comes to retail baggies and Tesla fans. People are dumb and trusting and in love with Elon, some of whom see him as their personal Jesus/nerd ambassador.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
05-03-2019 , 01:29 PM
For me Musk continuing to back down on his crazy robotaxi claims & that Teslas will be worth 200-300k in the future is what made me 100% convinced he is either completely crazy or a conman.

Everything he claimed before that, you could argue it was somewhere between being highly optimistic, being a slightly crazy visionary, or needing to learn to stfu when you are under influence of whatever.

But imo there is a 0% probability that he isn't either (1) completely crazy or (2) fully realizes that his robotaxi claims are completely bull ****.



And I also thinks he deserves to be challenged on it by the SEC or whoever. While it is quite easy to say it's bull **** with a financial background, there are a lot of people who believe Elon Musk is the Einstein of our time, and people who believe that Tesla self-driving is the best in the industry (I saw a poll recently of people looking to buy a car, and Tesla crushed the competition wrt self-driving reputation). Them being led to believe that Teslas are a great investment, is not too far from being the victim of a scam.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote

      
m