Quote:
Originally Posted by Schwallie
Lost so much money by selling this stock by listening to the dissenters in this thread :/
Why I listen to random people on the internet that have no idea what they are talking about, I have no idea.
Who on Earth are you talking about? I'm the main dissenter in this thread I think, vs the hoardes of nutty Musk fanboys who don't even trade the stock.
The record of the dissenters is exceptional. My first posts are recommending not going short. More recently, I hammered the stock in the $230s in November and December when the Model X presentation was a disaster and delays were piling up, and $220s in January, said it was done (and it was). Turtletom (a "dissenter") said this in December:
Quote:
Originally Posted by turtletom
Tsla is a great sell right now imo.
All these companies are extremely overvalued and imo we are close to the end of the bull run.
You would have made a lot of money shorting or even more with puts. Then at $150, I said this:
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Down 43% off highs from a few months ago, partly from reality/the upcoming EV competition that everyone downplayed and ridiculed, and partly from Musk's very (very) idiotic design decisions holding up the Model X.
Good time to buy TSLA here at $151 (or cover the short if you had one). It's hard to predict what will happen at this point, especially with the market being volatile, but upside is substantially higher than downside going into earnings and the period after. There are too many things for one of the world's greatest PR talents to pump coming into March.
If earnings turn out bad (reasonable chance), then buying after when it goes to the $120s or so is a no brainer. The upcoming pump cycle through March/April should be impressive and worth 30+% to the long side. I don't recommend it unless you're very comfortable with volatility though.
Long term of course TSLA remains one of the worst buy and holds in the market.
This is basically the ****ing bottom and I recommended buying!! Yet you blame me for you losing money?? WTF is wrong with you? What more do you want?
Immediately after earnings (which were horrible), I recommended getting out in the immediate aftermath of earnings to anyone who following me into a pre-earnings long at $151:
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Anyone who followed me into the trade above at $151, close this ****er now for 6% at $161. It could run/short squeeze or it could sell down hard. Impossible to tell, but the numbers are horrible and a profit is a profit. You don't know what tomorrow will bring.
Musk is even more of a PR genius than I gave him credit for. I think Wall Street and Musk will pump this hard on the conference call/short squeeze, but the bottom is a long way down if the market sees these numbers for the disaster they are.
And it did indeed sell down from $161 - back down to $144 - a full 10% drop. Once it stabilized down there, it was again a buy. You had a week to get back in at $150 once it stabilized.
The "dissenter's" take on trading this stock have been very clear (and very correct). If you're too much of a ****wit to parse written text and understand the difference between medium term (the first) and short term (the second) advice, that's not my problem. Perhaps I need to spell it out for the morons by specifying time frame? Do I need to hold your hand through the trades?
When someone shorted at $206, I said this:
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
I don't know what your thesis/time frame is, but I will say: bad time to short IMO. Model 3 and all the hype is happening this month. Who knows what BS they can spin. Model X is ramping up now, which is great for the bull case/an excuse for upgrades/positive press. There's also a very high short%/hard to borrow which is great for squeezes should they have a good showing and then have analysts blow it up. "Short squeeze fundamentals" are strong right now.
If you can't parse simple text, or understand the difference between short, medium, and long term view, it's not my problem, Schwallie. Maybe invest in an index instead? If you can't make money selling when I strongly recommended in the mid 200s and buying when I recommended at $150 (and staying long through the Model 3 event), then you're too much of a drooler to ever beat an index.
Anyone who followed my trading view on TSLA has done very, very well. Meanwhile, the Musk fanboys don't propose a single trade. Like teenage boys in love, they're here to defend their beau, not make money.
For the long term, nothing has changed. The Model 3 is a nice looking concept car, and preorder demand is as strong as the article I posted said was likely (and got mocked for). It's a positive for sure and will be worth buoyancy for a little bit until big money dumps for the next down cycle.
But the fundamentals are terrible, they will never improve, and Tesla will collapse. Musk can't sell the Model 3 for $35K without losing vast sums of money. BMW could get 200K pre orders as well by promising to sell a lovely $50K cost car for under $30K (after credits). They'd go broke doing it, and everyone would think they are nuts, but that's what Musk is promising.
Musk cannot and never will compete with the majors. He lacks the capital, the supplier networks, and he lacks the skill/intelligence. It is a cutthroat commercial business and pretty much the opposite of the space industry.
I'll post again when I think it's time to short/sell. Try not to buy when I recommend that. I cannot for the life of me fathom how you could have lost money listening to my trading advice.