Quote:
Aside from leverage, is there a reason everyone buys puts instead of just a straight short? If you have healthy enough margin to short the stock to your max risk tolerance, is there a benefit to puts I'm missing?
It's really tough to predict the timing on when this collapses, hence why not just straight short? I had some Jan2020 200 puts that I exited and I think I'm going to just increase my short position.
Payoff ratio. If Tesla bankrupts by April, you get paid 100:1 on $100 puts. You think there's a <1% chance they bankrupt by April? It's >5% by any analysis you choose.
Your Jan 2020 200 puts paid a >10 bagger on bankruptcy by 2020 before the recent drop and pay several times on a big capitulation by mid year (M3 demand sucks, they can't produce a profitable M3, both >20%).
Thus they allow to bet on good probability but not >50% probability bets. You can profitably, even highly profitably, bet on the underdog. You have room to be very wrong and maintain EV.
You also have less absolute loss risk. If Tesla goes to $450 here by mid year you're left holding your balls if you shorted at $290. A million dollar short is down $550K. $100K of 2020 puts, which pays 10x on bankruptcy hence the same, is down maybe $70K. That's a big, big difference.
Another consideration is the horrible EV mistake of getting scared. I saw quite a few guys get cucked out hard and cover their shorts at $360/$370/$380 for a nice loss due to the sheer amount of money they were down. That ain't gonna happen with puts.