Quote:
Originally Posted by ElSapo
Tooth, sometimes you seem pretty savvy and straight, and then sometimes you take a crap on Musk in ways that make you seem like you have motives and an axe. It makes your solid analysis less believable. Did he run over your dog in an electric vehicle or something?
ETA: I'm not trying to be an ass. Just, sometimes it seems more vindictive and less investment analysis.
Musk has been built up as a hero and genius. He's very obviously a liar and a fraud, and apart from strong skills in that area, not very bright and downright horrible with necessary "boring" detail. That analysis is the most important investment analysis there is, as nearly everything we know about Tesla depends on trust in Musk's accounting and projections. Take the self driving nonsense from 2016. Musk = liar and fraud led you to the correct analysis. Credulous heltok, who believed Musk rather than look at the rock solid analysis laid for him in detail on how bad autopilot was and how unlikely to improve given that, made an ass of himself despite the advantage of working in the industry. The same for many things.
A more recent example is the $420 tweet. If you put P(Musk is a liar and fraud) as > 90%, you come out with the right probabilities, as I did, that this is a very easy short at $370. If you put P(Musk is a liar and fraud) at <10%, you come out with very very wrong probabilities and lose a lot of money, as heltok, ChipRick, and the whole gaggle of bullish clowns in this thread did. That miscalculation cost them more money than any other single analysis on Tesla.
There are a few questions as to whether Tesla survives, and they all revolve around Musk's psychology.
- Is he a competent or incompetent leader and manager? Does his personality allow Tesla to recover from his extreme incompetence as a leader, or will he double and triple and pedo-dog-dare-burn-the-shorts-with-fraud-tweets right to the bottom?
- To what extent would he sanction fraud and creative accounting? Are his gross margins to be believed? How accurate is the picture created by the numbers in this upcoming quarter?
- Does the fraud run deep enough for the eventual downfall of Tesla via criminal and civil charges and liability?
All of these things depend on Musk's psychology as he basically runs this thing as a micromanaged fiefdom, with a powerless lackey board. I consider his psychology a settled question at this point given the mountains of evidence we have now, but others don't, because they're stupid.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ElSapo
I've worked for companies that developed their own internal systems, when every employee was wondering why they didn't buy something off the rack. ... seems like a common, simple mistake to make.
Hey, if you think my thesis is wrong, then say so. They're all just theses. I'm not an accountant.
Last edited by ToothSayer; 10-21-2018 at 06:18 PM.