Quote:
Originally Posted by ASAP17
You should be selling options or be in spreads in this name since all of you keep going on about puts, straight directional vol is a terrible r/r.
This is hilariously wrong. If you bought mid year (June) $200 puts on say January or February after Q1 on the thesis that Musk would **** up M3 production, you made a 6 to 9 bagger depending on when you bought them. You need odds of >16% that one of the following would happen:
- Musk would mess up M3 badly (>50%)
- Several bad news items would come out and tank the stock (15% or so)
- The stock market will have a decent correction (10%?)
- Institutional investors start dumping their holdings as disclosures came out (for example, Musk's amazing admission of stock fraud on the January 31 call) - 10%.
On the other side, if you bought weekly calls when the delivery numbers came out and I said Musk's spin was sufficient to make the stock bullish and it could run off lows, you made a 10-30 bagger depending on the strike.
Morish made a double bagger and a 5 bagger I think on puts.
Straight directional vol is
by far the best way to play this. Selling vol is the worst way to play this except in rare situations.
Quote:
Not cheap to short the stock either... There is too much polarized opinion (my own personal thoughts included).
This is wrong on several levels. It's very cheap to short the stock. For most of the year is was 1.9%/year to borrow on IB. It's spiked to 9% now (which is still cheap) but it rarely stays elevated. And polarized opinion doesn't matter when there's an outcome approaching that will settle questions in most minds (whether Musk can get viable mass manufacturing working before a cash/credit crunch).