Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
TSLA showing cracks? TSLA showing cracks?

03-29-2018 , 11:35 AM
Check out this report, apparently the owner of the Model X who died complained "7-10 times the car would swivel toward that same exact barrier during auto-pilot. Walter took it into dealership addressing the issue, but they couldn't duplicate it there."

I'm no genius by any stretch of the imagination, but if he knew the car was having this difficulty with this specific area shouldn't he have been driving the car himself? Sad story all the way around.

I for one can't understand this fascination with self driving vehicles. Driving my car is about the most free I feel in my life anymore!

http://abc7news.com/automotive/i-tea...pilot/3275600/
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 12:33 PM
About time this stock gets a reality check
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 05:37 PM
So Tesla in are in a frantic panic at the moment to artificially create a 2500/week run rate for a couple of days.
Quote:
An internal e-mailed leaked to Bloomberg indicates that Tesla (TSLA +1.2%) is placing a high priority in pushing up its production run rate on Model 3s this quarter.

Tesla VP of Production Peter Hochholdinger told employees on March 21 that the company was looking to squeeze out more Model 3 production by suspending the Model S and Model X lines for several days, and give some employees the option to pitch in with the Model 3 line.

Another e-mail dated March 23 from a different Tesla manager stated that it would be an "incredible victory" if the company could hit a production run rate of 2.5K per week by March 31.

The Bloomberg Tesla Model 3 Tracker currently shows an estimate of 1,026 vehicle per week and a total of 11,511 vehicles.
Let's just stop and consider how weird this is.

Firstly, they've clearly failed to reach anywhere near even their (twice badly delayed) prediction, and are now trying to cook the books by hand juicing the lines. They've probably stacked up inventory for the end of quarter run.

Secondly, how bizarre is this behavior for a billion dollar company? Rather than doing what makes sense - incrementally improving production, clearing bottlenecks, focusing on the long term and long run production - they are frantically trying to squeeze out a momentary production spike so they can lie to their investors and distract them from their actual, current, steady state run rate.

Thirdly, this is the second time they've done this. At the end of 2018 they frantically rushed to artificially create a 1000/week run rate for a few days that they could extrapolate out to a week and claim a round number milestone. Production then dropped well below that, which is kind of the opposite of the "exponential" the nutty bulls in this thread were repeating like cult utterances.

If you ever doubted that Musk is a carnival barker and a fraud rather than a serious or competent businessman, proof is in the above.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 05:59 PM
And by the way, do the bulls in this thread (who are invested in Tesla, not the unhinged fanboys) actually realize that Musk's talk of "exponential" and "machine that builds the machine" are deliberate lies he told you to get you to hold the stock at $380 and $350 rather than sell it and take your profit? They're the nerd-Trump version of "Mexico will pay", a nice little nugget of PR that fans take in and get conned by.

Do you realize that you being a gullible idiot and believing this (and repeating it - heltok I'm looking at you) is Musk directly ****ing with your mind to get what he wants? He knew for a fact at the time he was talking about exponential that exponentials were impossible for at least 6-9 months. He never told you this, instead lying to you so you would keep the stock inflated and lose your money when it eventually crashed.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Elon Musk, January 2018 conference call

And I think in part we were probably a little over-confident, a little complacent in thinking that this is something we know and understand. And put a lot of attention on other things and just got too comfortable with our ability to do battery modules because we've been doing that since the start of the company.

And of the four zones, two of them, of which are subcontracted to – the production systems are subcontracted to other companies, flat out didn't work, it turns out like, I mean, we promised they would work and it just didn't work. So, we had to do what would normally be maybe an 18-month development cycle for a production system of that scale and complexity, and try to do that in basically six months or maybe little, six to nine months.
The end of this process is just happening now according to reports (the new lines are being installed and will start producing soon). So Musk was deliberately lying to you, which has caused you to not sell (awaiting the exponential) and lose 30% of your money that you had in Tesla at $350.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 06:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
So Tesla in are in a frantic panic at the moment to artificially create a 2500/week run rate for a couple of days.

Let's just stop and consider how weird this is.

Firstly, they've clearly failed to reach anywhere near even their (twice badly delayed) prediction, and are now trying to cook the books by hand juicing the lines. They've probably stacked up inventory for the end of quarter run.

Secondly, how bizarre is this behavior for a billion dollar company? Rather than doing what makes sense - incrementally improving production, clearing bottlenecks, focusing on the long term and long run production - they are frantically trying to squeeze out a momentary production spike so they can lie to their investors and distract them from their actual, current, steady state run rate.

Thirdly, this is the second time they've done this. At the end of 2018 they frantically rushed to artificially create a 1000/week run rate for a few days that they could extrapolate out to a week and claim a round number milestone. Production then dropped well below that, which is kind of the opposite of the "exponential" the nutty bulls in this thread were repeating like cult utterances.

If you ever doubted that Musk is a carnival barker and a fraud rather than a serious or competent businessman, proof is in the above.
Also likely intentionally leak it thinking it is somehow a good thing

Last edited by syndr0me; 03-29-2018 at 06:30 PM.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 06:28 PM
I'm going to go read some electrek now to see how they compliment tesla on their commitment to safety
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 06:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by syndr0me
Was just about to post that.
When it rains, it ****ing pours!
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 07:40 PM
This is looking more and more like fraud, especially the way Musk is hyping all of his other projects while the company faces these very significant issues. They will have to raise money soon, if the demand doesn't show up... watch the stock crater. The way this recall is coming out preceding a holiday weekend after the market closes is a pretty scummy move as well.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 07:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ASAP17
This is looking more and more like fraud, especially the way Musk is hyping all of his other projects while the company faces these very significant issues. They will have to raise money soon, if the demand doesn't show up... watch the stock crater. The way this recall is coming out preceding a holiday weekend after the market closes is a pretty scummy move as well.
Pwc needs to be super cautious on the q1 numbers, they gave Tesla favorable going concern language, that might be a big problem should reckoning day come before the end of the year
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 08:55 PM
atleast the timing is smart, long weekend and production numbers are due next week; which by all indication will be abysmal, again.
so better to get it all out at once.

then they spend the next few months shooting cars into space, presenting new products that might never be released or do whatever else they come up with before they raise capital, again.

after following this thread, i have no doubt (retail) investors will keep throwing their money at them.

Last edited by BooLoo; 03-29-2018 at 09:01 PM.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 10:33 PM
It kind of depends on what you mean by abysmal. Model 3 production has been growing at roughly 10-20% per week depending on what endpoints you use to calculate and all indications are Tesla is still on that track. If they're really at 1400+ a week already they are arguably slightly ahead of expectations growing at about 12% per week this year. That's really not bad at all.

Last edited by grizy; 03-29-2018 at 10:38 PM.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 11:18 PM
just look at their own (most recent) projections and by how much they miss, like you would do with... well... any company?
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-29-2018 , 11:24 PM
I actually think the production numbers are pretty irrelevant at this point, quality control is the true looming disaster. Every time they recall product, it destroys their "profitability." They are recalling more Model Ss than the entire company made in vehicles for last year, even a minor repair is hundreds of millions out the door. The model 3 better hold up well over time, reports suggest the build quality leaves a lot to be desired.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-30-2018 , 12:26 AM
Yeah service centers are already backlogged for weeks - even on the high triage of fixing major Model 3 issues for those just delivered - and that's with a 500/week delivery rate. Add in a recall - which I don't think is that big a deal since it's voluntary and takes an hour to fix and only affects cold weather cars and winter is ending - and you've got a disaster in the making. It seems that many and varied components are failing in M3s at high rates. How are they going to handle 2500/week going out if service centers are already backed right up with near zero M3 volume so far?

https://www.greencarreports.com/news...tter-to-buyers
Quote:
The build quality of the early Model 3 we tested in late February was, in a word, appalling.

Before we were even able to visit the owner, the car had to go back to the Tesla service center to have the central touchscreen replaced.

You know, the one required to control virtually any aspect of the car except for turn signals, headlights, and wipers?

During the test itself, two things became clear: The Model 3 works largely as intended, and the build quality was the worst we have seen on any new car from any maker over the last 10 years.

The flaws and defects broke down into two categories: those that affected the functioning of the car or the owner's driving experience, and those that didn't.

The first group included:

The defective touchscreen and all the follow-on effects (above)
Persistent creaks and groans from the console or dash
An intermittent loud buzz from the upper right-hand center door pillar at highway speeds on some road surfaces
A steering vibration (in a car with just 1,000 miles)

Different owners have suffered blown main fuses in their Model 3 battery packs, varying and unexplained error messages that power down the car, and numerous other issues.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-30-2018 , 01:57 AM
There is a reason Tesla has been a case study in MVP concept applied to manufacturing.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-30-2018 , 05:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by grizy
There is a reason Tesla has been a case study in MVP concept applied to manufacturing.
The question for me is, what are we finding out that we didn't already know? We have a lot car manufacturers on the planet who have sold a lot of vehicles. I have no position in TSLA. I find this thread pretty interesting though. TSLA bears are more convincing at this point to me.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-30-2018 , 12:36 PM
Those snapshots into the Tesla mindset from early on are very interesting to see MyrnaFTW - the vision (hype?) they paint here is so strong ...

Quote:
Originally Posted by MyrnaFTW
Due to our order backlog, it seems that owning a Roadster can be a good investment. Last September, as the financial and real estate markets began crashing, a Roadster was sold at the Sonoma Paradiso in California wine country for $160,000, well above the current list price of $109,000. Many Roadster owners who have taken delivery of their cars have already decided to purchase a second Roadster or Roadster Sport because they like the first one so much.

The continued strong demand is driven by the fact that the Tesla Roadster has no direct competitors in the marketplace. It is faster than almost any sports car on the market (our Roadster beat a Porsche GT3 on the Top Gear test track) and yet uses less energy and has a smaller carbon footprint than a Toyota Prius, even if you assume the worst possible case where all electricity comes from coal.

I expect sales demand to strengthen further as this awareness grows. After all, what’s the point of driving another exotic sports car when it is slower than a Tesla and damages the environment? Already, the Tesla Roadster is the car of choice among the technology, business and Hollywood A lists – this year’s Academy Awards will be a lineup of Teslas – and we have never had to give a discount to anyone.

Many customers also appreciate the fact that profit from their purchase goes towards helping Tesla develop more affordable, mass market electric cars. The same cannot be said for those who buy gas-guzzling sports cars from other automakers.

And then it was super interesting to see that they've been promising lower costs, higher production, and profitability ... for 9 years

Quote:
Originally Posted by MyrnaFTW

2/09

"Tesla to be Profitable by Mid Year

Although extraordinarily difficult to close, the $40M financing round completed in December was twice the amount Tesla needed to reach profitability.

Haven't really read too much about Tesla, but saw a 'Master Plan' that Elon drafted in 2006 (https://www.tesla.com/en_CA/blog/sec...me?redirect=no), and it didn't have anything in it about autonomous driving. He drafted an update with the autonomous driving added in 2016, and claimed that society needed it asap because they believed it to be "significantly safer" than human driving (https://www.tesla.com/en_CA/blog/master-plan-part-deux)

Tesla getting into autonomous driving before they've even become profitable reminds me of this term they use on the news channels sometimes ...

At the risk of sounding like Lisa Simpson, it makes me super nervous to see that the two companies who are racing to develop autonomous driving, Uber and Tesla, aren't profitable - and so they may not have the funds to develop these systems with the care they deserve. Like in an ideal world, wouldn't it be better to build a closed track with robots designed to do all the things that people out in the real world might do, like watch Harry Potter videos when they're supposed to be watching the road, or cross highways in the middle of the night and not watch out for oncoming traffic, etc - except they don't have the money to do that, because they're both deep in the red?

Can't help but compare Elon Musk with Jeff Bezos - Jeff Bezos isn't really seen as much of a visionary, but he's done many of the same things Elon Musk has ... he's dabbled in autonomous shopping, he's building rockets ... was he also the first one to really successfully market cloud services to big business? And Amazon also turns a profit most of the time, and isn't in debt. Guess the only big mistake Jeff Bezos has made was to talk smack about Donald Trump when he thought Hillary Clinton had the election in the bag - and now Amazon's in his cross-hairs


Am starting to ramble - will have to try to find a way to tie things back to the share price Really hope TSLA isn't putting concerns about share price above safety - but have a sinking feeling that they could very well be. Which is an accident waiting to happen - literally! Maybe if Tesla's greatest asset is Elon Musk hype, their greatest vulnerability may be bad publicity?

Thanks for sharing those shareholder letters Myrna - they were cool to see!
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-30-2018 , 01:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Why did you buy Jan 2019 puts? And at what strike? That matters.

I don't really care about clucks who believe in technicals and trends, etc, and neither should you. If you followed that bull**** you would have bought Tesla at $380. What I do care about is your thesis. Did you buy the puts for a major reckoning? At what odds? There are two problems, really.

1. If you bet on a major reckoning and always cover at 100%, you lose a fortune if your success rate at picking these spots is high, because this is what the start of a major reckoning looks like. Everything that goes to zero drops a bit like this first. See: Enron, Valeant. If Tesla are going to fail this is always what failure looks like - horribly missed targets, Musk lying his ass off, credit running out, being downgraded, being sued. This whole Model 3 business has taken the path of greatest incompetence.

2. If you bet on a major reckoning and your success rate on picking these spots is low, but your payoff is high (i.e. you're 1 in 5 to get these right and your payoff is 10 to 1 if you do), you guarantee that you're making a losing trade the moment you enter it if you take profit below your required payoff. Everyone should think out their trades such that they're never making guaranteed losing trades. If you're going to make guaranteed losing trades you should instead invite some girls over and set some cash on fire in front of them; the monetary outcome will be the same. There are a surprising number of ways of being a guaranteed losing trader; early profit taking on low probability, high payout if let run spots is one of those ways.

So there's only a narrow window of possibility in which buying the puts and selling them here is a good idea. This assumes they were well out of the money. If they were well in, ignore the above. Anyway, generally you want your bets to be +EV across as wide a range of possibilities as possible, because while it's possible to get the shape of things right, you can suck badly at the details. And being +EV across a broader range means sometimes doing counter intuitive things.

*clucks - yes it's a word - it means "a foolish person"
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
The time to short with impunity was at $380, when I said it was a screaming sell and told people like ChipRick that you should sell it no matter what your thesis was and that anyone holding it up here was a stone cold moron. The stock market is up a lot since then even after the latest run down, and Tesla is down 30%. Oops.

A short at this point is not guaranteed. Apart from Tesla being high beta and the market reversing, if production picks up over the coming month while the market recovers a bit, this is easily back over $320. Also note that there are zero borrows available. That means shorts covering if it reverses.

All of Tesla's short term problems are solved if they start churning out a much higher production rate (3000/week next month). Long term they are still dead of course, this company has no future whatsoever other than bankruptcy as anyone with a functioning brain realizes, but bulls are true believers and will continue to be while there's a glimmer of hope. And the market is still king. I told people at $380 not to the drink the KoolAid because most of the price was a 5x beta in a massive low volatility bull, and not a validation of their thesis. Being moron KoolAid drinkers, they didn't listen. The same is true now to some extent, although some of this fall is production failing so badly. But the majority is still the market, incredibly.

So if you think production is going to continue to disappoint and fail, then by all means short with impunity. If you believe Musk that battery pack production issues are their key bottleneck to get over 3000/week, well, Grohlmann automated production lines for the battery pack should be arriving from Germany about now and being reassembled at the Gigafactory, which means production will ramp in the coming weeks.

Have been trying to stick with stocks like AMZN that can be bought and held into perpetuity (although maybe not anymore if they have anti-trust problems?) - and tried shorting SHLD for the first time this year, because it looks like an imminent bankruptcy may be unavoidable? And then have been trying to avoid stocks like TSLA, where things look quite bearish, although there's a chance things in the short-term could go the other way - at a time when the market looks quite bearish, although there's a chance and things seem like they could go either way, in a market that looks quite bearish although there's a chance things in the short-term could go the other way.

Still, sometimes still find myself having trouble with exits when stuff sometimes starts feel like they're maybe getting a bit more grey? Like with solidfirstpost's TSLA put - guess you would have held it and only covered upon actual news of improved production? What if it appears the market is moving up merely based on hype or other news - would it still be considered a hold? If it were a bull market, would you set a limit buy somewhere?
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-30-2018 , 01:47 PM
Pick the clear spots. I haven't traded Tesla for size in over a year, and it was my bread and butter for about 3 years with lots of trades on either side and more profit than any other stock. Circumstances determine when you should enter.

I like to think of myself as a moron at trading who's only capable of being +EV when picking up absolutely free money requiring no thought. You should think of yourself that way as well. It's not a bad approximation. Amazing opportunities come that even a real idiot could make money from; you wait for them. That's profitable trading in a nutshell. If you're umming and ahhing, let it go.

Selling is a trickier beast, although it a piece of cake if you're doing the above. Best advice there is to have a thesis and stick to it. Why did you buy it? Has new information substantially changed your thesis for the worse? If not, then stick with it.

Last edited by ToothSayer; 03-30-2018 at 01:53 PM.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-30-2018 , 01:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Pick the clear spots. I haven't traded Tesla for size in over a year, and it was my bread and butter for about 3 years with lots of trades on either side and more profit than any other stock. Circumstances determine when you should enter.

I like to think of myself as a moron at trading who's only capable of being +EV when picking up absolutely free money requiring no thought. You should think of yourself that way as well. Amazing opportunities come that even a real idiot could make money from; you wait for them. That's profitable trading in a nutshell. If you're umming and ahhing, let it go.

That's good stuff - it helps a lot, thanks TS
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-30-2018 , 02:02 PM
I think there is one thing we can all agree, the market EVENTUALLY figures it out. Price is all that matters, they will either be able to raise money or they won't. When the overall market turns, who will want to own this balance sheet? SolarCity is still a thing right? I said pages back Musk in untouchable & maybe I should have added he's untouchable for those that believe in him (which is still a very large contingent). The model 3 has a mixed reception so far, that's sort of odd when you'd expect the first models to be flawless and hype to be astronomical from its most dedicated employees and buyers.
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-30-2018 , 02:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Selling is a trickier beast, although it a piece of cake if you're doing the above. Best advice there is to have a thesis and stick to it. Why did you buy it? Has new information substantially changed your thesis for the worse? If not, then stick with it.

Yes - will have to give this a try. Thanks TS!

PS. Hi ASAP! Am seeing a lot of people from the contest thread in this thread as well Will have to put together a little summary for March over the weekend ...
TSLA showing cracks? Quote
03-31-2018 , 09:17 PM
The scumbag pieces of a **** at Tesla had their autopilot fail badly (confirmed today), and are trying to blame the driver:

Quote:
“In the moments before the collision, which occurred at 9:27 a.m. on Friday, March 23rd, Autopilot was engaged with the adaptive cruise control follow-distance set to minimum. The driver had received several visual and one audible hands-on warning earlier in the drive and the driver’s hands were not detected on the wheel for six seconds prior to the collision. The driver had about five seconds and 150 meters of unobstructed view of the concrete divider with the crushed crash attenuator, but the vehicle logs show that no action was taken.”
Someone, please defend this. Their autopilot was engaged for an extended period before crashing into the concrete divider. It failed to avoid a gigantic concrete barrier with lots of warning/lead time in good conditions. Tesla spends the majority of their PR blaming the driver, throwing out red herrings ("warnings earlier in the drive") to avoid taking responsibility for the basic fact that their "autopilot" cannot reliably avoid slamming into giant concrete dividers in good conditions.

Let's not forget that 15 months ago, Musk promised "Fully Self Driving" coming online in "3 to 6 months". 15 months later their software is so incompetent it crashes into static concrete dividers in good conditions with long visibility. And this is not an isolated incident. I posted a year ago about "truck lust" and "concrete divider affinity", from multiple posts by Tesla drivers, who call this tendency scary. Like I said, Tesla has been lucky that its customer base is full of wealthy, intelligent early adopters - doctors and lawyers and business owners - rather than the general public it will soon be targeting with its Model 3.

Multiple lead engineers have actually left Tesla because of Musk's reckless incompetence, warning that autopilot isn't ready for prime time and Musk is being extremely reckless and putting customer lives at risk by releasing it.

When are people going to realize that Musk is a fraud and cowboy, who is far behind on autonomous driving?
TSLA showing cracks? Quote

      
m