Quote:
Originally Posted by imjosh
Another quick question. Would it be better to make min payments on all of our loans at the start of 2013, and max our Roth IRAs first? Would that be better from a time-value of money perspective?
Our loans:
7k @ 6.8%
24k @ 6.2%
12k @ 5.0%
5k @ 3%
17k @ 0.9% (car)
15.5k @ 0% until I graduate (late 2015ish hopefully)
It looks like the VFFVX fund has made well over 7% this YTD. Basically if the VFFVX makes over 7% next year it's better to have maxxed Roth IRA first, correct? But there's no way of knowing for sure so I would be rolling the dice?
you are correct that if VFFVX returned 7% every year then you would pay the minimum on your loans and invest as much as possible with a guaranteed 7% ROI. if it weren't for luck, you'd win every time!
we can talk about estimates of sustainable long-term ROI for a diversified portfolio and try to figure out whether it's higher than the vig on any of your loans, but there are plenty of good reasons to focus on getting rid of the debt:
- simplicity. a portfolio containing a bunch of loans and a bunch of investments is more work to maintain than a portfolio containing nothing.
- debt can be a cause of stress, especially for a couple just starting out. it's money coming out of your paycheck, even when you have other things you'd rather spend it on.
- too much debt can harm your credit score and make it harder or more expensive to get, say, a home loan.
- government student loans are especially good to eliminate since they can't be dispensed in bankruptcy.
so what is my advice? do both if you possibly can! you have until tax day 2014 to contribute the max to your roth for 2013. consider keeping a portion of your emergency savings in your roths[1], and make up the rest a little bit each month. hopefully you can do this while also directing a substantial amount towards the loans each month because i think that's a higher priority -- 24k @ 6.2% gets ugly in a hurry. i hope you and your spouse-to-be are parlaying your educations into lucrative careers!
[1]
http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Roth_...emergency_fund