I'm leaving out most of the niceties and focusing on where I think you could do better. I put in an encouraging number in there at some point.
Quote:
Originally Posted by savant111
I liked Brian's idea trade review, so I decided to do it also, hopefully others will follow suit. I don't think what the stock did after I sold is a very good measure of Correct vs Incorrect trade, so I'll be doing it differently.
Sells are trades too. A penny saved is a penny earned and a penny not gained is a penny lost. I'm far less results oriented than my persona here, but tracking positions that you are out of is a nice exercise.
Quote:
Also in case any one doesn't know, I don't report unrealized gains/losses when I report numbers to you guys.
My results are stock/dividend gains (realized and unrealized) divided by my total investible net worth. No big deal if people track their results differently. I do it my way because it keeps me from thinking I am more clever than I am and it keeps me from not realizing a loss that I should realize.
Quote:
Finished the month up a little better than 1.5%. Sadly, it was my best month of 2013, However, I consider it a very positive month with think a lot to build on for me.
That is over 19% annualized for the month. Very good.
Quote:
Technically, July behaved very similar to January. If you guys recall...back in January I was posting about waiting for "the big short opportunity", initiating a few shorts, and staying away from long trades. If you guys recall I said at the time the price action was something I did not have a lot of experience with and would do better the next time.
This time around I saw the same situation, post breakout, held some positions longer, and rather than look short when my first wave of long trades ended, I added a second wave of longs, which kept me on the right side of the market, and made me a few extra bucks. Also, I held more positions than I did in January and held them a bit longer. All of this is growth and progress as a trader to me.
You are learning. I'm not against shorting to hedge your long bets, as long as you understand that you are fighting inflation and companies that are trying (and usually successful in) be(ing) profitable. Market shorts are right eventually though.
It is cheaper (and less risky) in the long run to just have a decent sized cash position that you can employ after a significant drop. You won't have much to post about though.
Quote:
SH: Took a decent loss here. Most of it was incurred in June. I still think it was a smart hedge. I carried it a bit past the "soft stop" I had on it looking for a better exit. I don't regret the decision it just didn't work out.
I think you have been over-hedged here. Eventually the shorts will be right. Most of them will be poor before they are right, given history.
Quote:
KORS 1: I was holding half of a position from June into the month. I found my self in a spot during the month where I had to choose between selling this and CHK.
I think you have to let this run or give up on it. It will be driven by revenues and earnings. You are giving up too much of the upside by getting out.
Quote:
I decided to sell KORS over CHK (even though KORS was a better trade), because CHK looked like it had room to pop and KORS was approaching overbought status. This was my best move of the quarter imo. Took a nice profit here.
Hindsight, but overbought is not a problem in a directional market.
Quote:
CHK 1: My worst entry of the month. It was a panic buy as I wanted something post jobs report. Hot market bailed me out though, and I did nice job managing it post buy, selling KORS instead of it when I wanted to lighten up, dumping CHK for a nice gain, than getting a good spot to buy it back lower.
You did that one well, imo. Risky play, but well executed.
Quote:
FB: Bad entry, same panic buying as CHK, though this was closer to setting up for a pop. Again market bailed me out and I would of wound up buying it the following Monday.
Obviously missing the earnings report was the decision that could of made this a whole different review, but I thought about It a lot and it was the smart move for me given what I knew at the time.
What I learned from FB, is how hard it can be to find an entry post earnings. Part of my rationale for selling was if a good report brought it above 29.00, I can rebuy for an easy trade to $32.50. To my surprise the thing opened above $32.50 and never gave me a good entry before running well past a buy point. I'll factor in the possibility of getting priced out, when making earnings based decisions in the future.
I suggest that you just continue to trade into earnings. You are taking on most of the market risk in between earnings seasons and by sitting out earnings season you are not letting your view of the underlying companies benefit you.
Quote:
PRLB: I saw the market about to break out, saw PRLB basing, and took the entry. I'd take it 100% of the time in the same spot. Unfortunately it did not break out with the market. Instead it gave a false breakdown. I sold the false breakdown (knowing it was probably a head fake), because It was in my plan to sell on a close below xx.xx. So I just dumped it. At the end of the day it's very important for me to follow the game plan I lay out the night before, that where I ultimately think I'll have an edge.
This is one I wouldn't touch with a 10 foot pole between earnings seasons. Between earnings it is just going to be an effective triple times SPY bet.
Quote:
KORS 2: Still in progress. Did A nice job holding it through a downgrade (this is another thing I would of never done back in January).
I ignore up/down-grades except on momentum trades where the upgrades coincide with momentum or where there is a
new problem/risk that will slam things for a while and people who have been waiting for a dip to buy are delaying the correct sized drop (see news on potash and subsequent price action of POT - it is a piece of **** basic material stock now). If I got the upgrades before everyone else did, my answer would change.
Quote:
CHK 2: Bought it back lower, this time at a proper buy point and it hit my profit target. Well traded/Well executed.
Well done. Note that this would not have worked if we were in a down market.
Quote:
CAT short: Rare day trade, rare stock short (though I do want to experiment with individual stock shorts a bit in the coming months). Day trading is tough for me. I spend too much time watching the monitor and away from my day job. It's not worth it. I'm not putting in a rule against it, but will only do it in rare spots. The play broke even (I gave up some gains I probably didn't need too though...due to inexperience).
I'd avoid attempting day trading if I were you. You have a day job.
One thing I have noticed that I wanted to bring up is that you are rarely buying late in the day. A lot of the moves that could be countered recently have happened late and gaps have made any morning moves very difficult.
With your background in psych, you should have some ability to predict how people will react upon sleeping on the news prior to you sleeping on it.
Quote:
PETM: This was an experimental trade for me. I wasn't confident at the time, but I liked this trade a lot and now think it was a good entry. I bought it of a reversal following a false breakdown. This is a play I'm going to add to my arsenal. It like going to level 3 in poker vs the algos. The market didn't pop as I hoped or I would of definitely hit my profit target.
"would have" not "would of"
See above. Oh, and take into account how major players will be motivated in addition to the emotional traders. Markets start crashing and you think the Fed isn't above adding "we are now going to start buying corporate bonds" to their mix instead of tapering?
Quote:
WOR: Here I was looking for a breakout in the stock. The entry was bad though. I should buying this thing flat or up, I bought it on a down open below the 10 day..in a spot that I think effected it's EV. If the market would of popped, this would of worked, but it stayed flat and I was lucky to get out with a small gain.
I'd consider this a possible hold forever stock (I just don't like their basic materials side of the business, but that is a hedge!). It is also on an uptrend, so I think that there isn't much value in worrying about the 10 day unless you just want to own it for a week or two.