Quote:
Originally Posted by donkeykong2
i did buy the index with currency protection to the euro. if you call out an index with a value of 11000 and set out a goal of 20000 for two years and it comes out at 18800, that is a very good call imo regardless of what other indizes did. if you compare it to something you should at least be objective and take the msci world index or even a balanced portfolio or sth.
Yes it's a good call, but worthless from an investing perspective. And SPY is kind of the benchmark for any trader or hedge fund. If you're badly underperforming SPY (regardless of how good your predictions are), you're below average, not "brilliant". Predictions that don't result in portfolio outperformance are worthless. I predict that oil will hit $100 a barrel again in the next five years (current ~$50). Doesn't mean jack **** unless I can make money from it that beats an index.
Look, people who get predictions right are interesting. But sample size, global conditions, etc mean that you need a lot more than once to mean anything (unless you're taking low probability events).
Quote:
Originally Posted by donkeykong2
also you comment about substantial risk must be a joke right?
No, just a bit of fun.
Quote:
you claim the spy is a safer investment than the nikkei? you claim going 100% spy would be safer than 80% spy and 20% nikkei? i never recommended to anyone to go 100% long Japan. my approach is safer because it diversifies. the risk of buying the nikkei (or topix i did) at 11000 was extremely low.
I don't think an approach is safer because it diversified. And there was lots of risk. If the economy failed to kickstart, you were holding an absolute mess because of JPY. You even kind of agree that it depended:
Quote:
Originally Posted by donkeykong2
i m still very optimistic here but obviously the success is depending on the actual implementation of the policies which have been announced. i think the nikkei has the potential to reach 20000 within 2 years if the global climate for stocks stays good.
If there was a global recession or problems (necessary for SPY to go down) or they failed to execute, Japan was in strife. Everyone called what Abe was doing "risky". I don't think you gained anything her except underperformance of SPY, to be honest.
Anyway, congrats on the call. It seems you got it correct