Quote:
Originally Posted by Plus1Plus1
So I'm seeing the anger against fixed-index annuities in the other thread, and I am starting to wonder if my understanding of that investment vehicle is correct.
My understanding is that a fixed index annuity simply caps the return of the market. So if the cap is 5%, and the market returns 7%, then the underwriter reaps the reward of 2%. If the market returns 4%, it all goes to the investor.
Is my understanding wrong?
You get the index, nothing more.
If you invested $10,000 into the Vanguard 500 Index 10 years ago, it is worth $13,933.32 today.
If you put the $10k into an S&P 500 indexed annuity it is only worth $11,627.93.
Whats the difference? The dividend.
Extend that out to 20 years - $51,616.19 for VFINX and $35,109.62 for the index annuity. The stock market would have to lose 81% of its value for the index annuity to pay off - but then a crash like that likely means the insurance company ain't going to be able to pay up either...