Quote:
Originally Posted by BrianTheMick2
I can guarantee that 1% of coin-flippers will be in the top 1% of a coin-flipping contest.
Unless you have the skill to differentiate the lucky from the skilled, you aren't on to anything by picking past winners.
So you think Dan Loeb, Steve Mandel, David Shaw, Jim Simons, Lee Ainslie, David Tepper, Bob Koenigsberger, James Dinan, Ray Dalio, Seth Klarman, WEB are all lucky coinflippers*?
Or are you saying a 20, 25, etc track record isn't long enough to tell?
Or some special talent to have spotted them - I mean, the media never talks about them do they...
LOL GMAFB & GTFO. It takes only
One manager to disprove your already disproven theory.
Regardless, Roger Ibbotson already showed that Winners Repeat, and Winners Repeat with Style.
The reason you
don't listen to salesguys with 25 funds and x that have outperformed is that you don't know about the ones that were closed and opened along the way. they could have had 250 funds over that time frame. But if you had 25 mgrs running 25 funds at one shop at 4 of them consistently outperformed for 15-20 years, that's all the evidence you need. After fees and expenses of course.
* Yeah ~half of them are closed now but half or more are not. And some of the closed ones were open very recently.
And there are multiple mutual funds that qualify as well. You probably think Will Danoff is lucky too. 26 years at the helm, at a no-name firm like Fidelity, running almost no assets except for $100Bn, 3.18% average annual outperformance after fees.
Yeah, just lucky I bet.
Last edited by NajdorfDefense; 08-17-2016 at 05:50 PM.