For those who want to follow Tooth's pivot, caveat, backpedal in real time here it is below.
Tooth starts out with an absolute position that 'utilizing a lockdown when you have a more virulent strain competing with a lesser one is wrong'...
Quote:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shuffle
Why are you dog whistling with the Denmark strain? It died out because of strict controls.
The U.K. strain which is the dangerous one has proliferated because it was allowed to spread and become the new dominant strain.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Actually, you have it backwards. Lockdowns and restrictions help select the more prolific strains, the ones with high enough R that they can keep spreading despite lockdowns. ...
.
I then lay out for him in clear, easy to follow logic (as if I am talking to a child) why he is wrong...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cuepee
This is a profound misunderstanding of the science. No surprise.
There is no reason, zero, to believe the "more prolific strains" would not keep spreading at the same or greater rate in a 'let it rip' scenario. The 'let it rip' scenario DOES NOT see the "more prolific strain" out competed and its nonsense if you application of the science makes you think that.
What you are mistaking is predominantly seeing the "more prolific strain" in a lockdown absent the diminished 'weaker strains' for meaning the more "prolific strains" are doing better at spreading under those conditions and that is not the case.
For those who actually want to understand science and not just Tooth bro science, as misguided and ignorant as he is, here is what matters...
'Generations' for mutations are what matters the most. The more proliferation, the more generations, the more "prolific strains" that will hae time to emerge.
Tooth immediately begins his pivot, caveat, backpedal to say what he always meant was yes, locking down a more virulent strain is not only correct but might be REQUIRED now.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
And just to give an idea of what 0.7 extra R means, in 10 weeks starting from 10,000 cases:
Old strain = ~1.3^10 = 13x = 130,000 cases (the last week is 30K cases at once)
New strain = 2^10 = 1024x = 10,000,000 cases (the last week is 5 million cases at once)
One is manageable, the other is a disaster requiring shelter in place lockdowns.
Full mandatory and enforced lockdowns are now his position if he says that math holds and he says that is the same as what he said before.
FLOL