Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Coronavirus Coronavirus

09-29-2020 , 09:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jsb235
You are misrepresenting how T cells offer protection for individuals and how it would ultimately impact herd immunity. T cells don't prevent infections, so when you keep bringing up infections as evidence that there is no T cell immunity, it is confusing.

Your lack of knowledge of the basic function of T cells is why I can't discuss this with you. It's like we are talking about poker and you keep claiming the pot because you have blackjack, and wondering why I didn't split my pocket sevens.
This is one of many you quoted for T Cell theory:
Quote:
Indeed, Gomes suggested, herd immunity could happen with as little as one quarter of the population of a community exposed — or perhaps just 20 percent. “We just keep running the models, and it keeps coming back at less than 20 percent,” she told Hamblin. “It’s very striking.” Such findings, if they held up, would be very instructive, as Hamblin writes: “It would mean, for instance, that at 25 percent antibody prevalence, New York City could continue its careful reopening without fear of another major surge in cases.”
Your theory for Texas was that cases were dropping because they were herd immune at 20% (T Cells providing the rest of the immunity).

You yourself have stated multiple times that the T cells provide immunity at 20% enough to stop a second wave:
Quote:
Originally Posted by jsb235
New York will be interesting to watch. If there is any truth to the notion of T cells immunity, it should avoid a second wave. Obviously it will be hard to tell until things open up completely, but it seems like we are heading in that direction, so there will be an answer soon.
Now you're lying about what you said because the theory has been destroyed by facts. And I think you actually realize that now by your last response. No one lies about their previous position like you are unless you know it's been disproven.
09-29-2020 , 10:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shuffle
jsb, your T cell theory seems like Dr. Oz quackery. Tooth explained it well to you with all the data in that Menaus post.
Fine. You don't ever have to think about T cells again. Obviously data from Manaus, a city in the middle of the Amazon, can be extrapolated to the world at large. Obviously it disproves t cell immunity. Obviously what happens in Manaus is going to be the same everywhere.

But outside of this thread, no one is making the points TS is making to disprove T cell immunity. And if TS tried to make these points outside of this thread, he would be laughed out of any conversation.

The reality is that no one knows whether T cells offer any immunity or, even if they do, they lower the threshold for herd immunity. And certainly you can't believe that TS is smarter than some of the world's leading scientists. But if you do, fine.
09-29-2020 , 10:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shuffle
The MIT covid projections guy will not update his model beyond November 1, and he will publish his final update next week. I wonder why.
What is the obvious 'why'?
09-30-2020 , 01:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shuffle
jsb, your T cell theory seems like Dr. Oz quackery. Tooth explained it well to you with all the data in that Menaus post.
Here is an opinion piece in Bloomberg about herd immunity possibly being much lower than previously thought. This isn't some theory being shared by me on this message board and nowhere else. It's a pretty mainstream idea that is gaining more attention by the day.

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/ar...?sref=uN6cur8D
10-01-2020 , 05:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shuffle
Meanwhile, in the U.K.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-54362900



OMG it's so critical they closed the restaurants and pubs one hour earlier.



Uhh... they are needed dude.
It's partly about softening us up. As per the conversation back in March/April, the UK government cannot do very much without the consent of the people and sadly they have messed up too much to go straight for what is needed.

The rest is because of so much pressure from the 'we must open the economy brigade'. Rightly or wrongly (very wrongly in my view) there are far too many of them for Boris to just ignore even though I think he is strongly inclined to.

Quote:
There are absolutely zero proven treatments for Covid-19. Nothing but anecdotes and quackery, hospital staff fooled by randomness and seasonality, and people believing whatever optimism they want to believe.
That's not quite true.

Quote:
Dexamethasone, an anti-inflammatory drug, has been immediately approved to treat all UK hospitalised COVID-19 patients requiring oxygen, including those on ventilators, from today.

The drug has been proven to reduce the risk of death significantly in COVID-19 patients on ventilation by as much as 35% and patients on oxygen by 20%, reducing the total 28-day mortality rate by 17%.

Funded by the UK government, via the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) and UK Research and Innovation (UKRI), the Oxford University UK RECOVERY trial is the first clinical trial anywhere in the world to show a treatment provides significant impact in reducing patient mortality.
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/w...-by-government

Last edited by chezlaw; 10-01-2020 at 05:30 AM.
10-01-2020 , 05:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by smartDFS
it's actually not easy, which is why we don't have these stats
This. it's very hard for all sorts of reasons. One, among many, is that so many people who died caught the disease in hospital and so will be correlated with the conditions that put you in hospital.

Dont be an a neadanthal may be good advice.
Quote:
Scientists have claimed that a strand of DNA that triples the risk of developing severe Covid-19 was passed on from Neanderthals to modern humans. The genetic endowment, a legacy from more than 50,000 years ago, has left about 16% of Europeans and half of south Asians today carrying these genes.
https://www.theguardian.com/science/...9-study-claims
10-01-2020 , 07:59 PM
Sweden averaging about 1 death a day for about 2 weeks now.

Headline for click bait, but much ado about nothing.
10-01-2020 , 11:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Sweden averaging about 1 death a day for about 2 weeks now.

Headline for click bait, but much ado about nothing.
C'mon. The rise in deaths lag the cases.

If we wait for the deaths to rise to worrying levels then we know it's too late to stop the avalanche.
10-02-2020 , 01:40 AM
Trump and Melania just announced they tested positive. This is a big moment. If they end up being fine and shake it off like it's nothing, things will go in one direction. If one of them dies, shutdown for life!

Last edited by onemoretimes; 10-02-2020 at 01:55 AM.
10-02-2020 , 05:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shuffle
I don't know what the temperature was in Duluth the other night, 40-something degrees? Not good for him, his prognosis probably worse than average for his age and obesity so far in the pandemic.
He will have the best medical care money can buy so I think his prognosis will be much better than average for his [x].
10-02-2020 , 07:32 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shuffle
Then when deaths spike, these types of posters say "but the cases are going down!"
You tried to scare your friends by saying millions in the US will die over the next 6 months. That means you need the death rate to go from 700 a day to about over 7000 a day or 10 000 a day. I can understand if headlines can easily make you scared.

7 months ago when we were clueless you could have scared me with a link like that.

Today when we have actual numbers and data.

Last edited by Tien; 10-02-2020 at 07:42 AM.
10-02-2020 , 07:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chezlaw
C'mon. The rise in deaths lag the cases.

If we wait for the deaths to rise to worrying levels then we know it's too late to stop the avalanche.
Yeah of course I've heard the "deaths will explode in 14 days" statement of fact / fear mongering months ago when it spiked in the US. Death rates didn't sky rocket and daily death rates (as high as they are) remain in the US statistically insignificant. Also amongst a carefree IDGAF population still not wearing masks. Swedish olds are much more responsible.

The death rates will be even less statistically significant in Sweden.

The olds in Sweden don't act like the olds in the USA.
10-02-2020 , 08:26 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by onemoretimes
Trump and Melania just announced they tested positive. This is a big moment. If they end up being fine and shake it off like it's nothing, things will go in one direction. If one of them dies, shutdown for life!
It wont matter if they are fine or not. The stories of how they recklessly refused to wear masks and exposed other healthy people to the virus after knowing about Hope Hicks's positive result will haunt them.

Trump attended a fundraiser after knowing about Hicks, and others in his group interacted with press, etc, all without masks and all while knowing they had exposure to a positive person.
10-02-2020 , 08:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Yeah of course I've heard the "deaths will explode in 14 days" statement of fact / fear mongering months ago when it spiked in the US. Death rates didn't sky rocket and daily death rates (as high as they are) remain in the US statistically insignificant. Also amongst a carefree IDGAF population still not wearing masks. Swedish olds are much more responsible.

The death rates will be even less statistically significant in Sweden.

The olds in Sweden don't act like the olds in the USA.
In 2018 2.8M people died in the USA.

C19 has not done a full year yet, 212K deaths so only 70K to go to be 10% of that number.

Something that achieves 7-10% of total mortality is a long way from being statistically insignificant.

Its killed ~6.7% of Swedens 2019 total mortality which was 88K.

Last edited by O.A.F.K.1.1; 10-02-2020 at 09:08 AM.
10-02-2020 , 08:54 AM
Like 99% they don't show any symptoms right?
10-02-2020 , 09:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tien
Sweden averaging about 1 death a day for about 2 weeks now.

Headline for click bait, but much ado about nothing.
World o Meters reporting 5 deaths in latest update.
10-02-2020 , 09:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ratslla
Like 99% they don't show any symptoms right?
Already being reported he has cold like symptoms. So he is not a symptomatic, and he is also a high risk candidate given age and obesity.
10-02-2020 , 09:25 AM
^ Wow okay, thx. Yeah, he def falls in the high risk category. Imagine if Biden has it too...
10-02-2020 , 09:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by O.A.F.K.1.1
World o Meters reporting 5 deaths in latest update.
I've noticed that Worldometers reports 5 deaths for Sweden most days, but then when you check the graph the next day, it's revised to one or two deaths. I don't know if it's a glitch or what.
10-02-2020 , 10:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by O.A.F.K.1.1
World o Meters reporting 5 deaths in latest update.
Oh my God.
10-02-2020 , 10:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by O.A.F.K.1.1
In 2018 2.8M people died in the USA.

C19 has not done a full year yet, 212K deaths so only 70K to go to be 10% of that number.

Something that achieves 7-10% of total mortality is a long way from being statistically insignificant.

Its killed ~6.7% of Swedens 2019 total mortality which was 88K.
Daily death rates in the first 2 months have no comparison significance on death rates today and the future.

The entire 1st world population of olds is not interacting socially the same way anymore post summer 2020 compared to March 2020.
This disease is predominantly an old person killer in aggregate.

So Sweden has nothing to panic over. Sweden needs to continue doing what its been doing the last 4 months, and continue doing it another 6-8 months until a vaccine comes.

And all 1st world countries are doing this now. Opened the economies back up as they should, keep it opened, manage life with corona, and stop panicking.
10-02-2020 , 10:58 AM
People should stop obsessing over Sweden. It's a quite small country, pretty different from central/southern Europe, and even more different from North America. No shutdowns is less restrictive than shutdowns, but it's a concensus culture with high trust in government and media, so when government leaders and experts ask people to take measures to decrease spread of the disease, it will have a bigger effect than in many other countries.

With that said, the Swedish population is susceptible to the same fallacies as other European populations right now, the spread has been low for a while and people are tired of restrained social contact, so behaviour changes in ways that lead to a resurgence in cases. Given the lag from spread of the disease to death numbers ticking up, I think we are looking at a decent sized second wave in Sweden in the coming months.
10-02-2020 , 11:09 AM
I also read the other day that Sweden has a very high percentage of 1 person households, which makes the virus spread a lot less because so much transmission is done within the home.
10-02-2020 , 12:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gorvnice
It wont matter if they are fine or not. The stories of how they recklessly refused to wear masks and exposed other healthy people to the virus after knowing about Hope Hicks's positive result will haunt them.

Trump attended a fundraiser after knowing about Hicks, and others in his group interacted with press, etc, all without masks and all while knowing they had exposure to a positive person.
That secondary story is not yet penetrating but should be the headline story. He knew he was with her, unmasked, indoors for days doing debate prep. He knew he she tested positive before going to the fundraiser. He knew he wasn't feeling well and went anyway and had up close interactions with many people, unmasked- which of course are primarily older men.

I truly hope he and anyone else involved who tests + makes a complete recovery. But this is the very definition of recklessly playing with others' lives and he deserves the condemnation coming his way, just like anyone else would.
10-02-2020 , 12:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mat Cauthon
People should stop obsessing over Sweden.
So many people's entire amateur hour theories hinge solely on Sweden so they aren't going to give it up.

      
m