Quote:
Originally Posted by AlbertoKnox
Maybe you mean my "Selling in 1 second isn't smartest" isn't true. But the first part is, if you put in your order for the full half mil it is the next thing that gets executed. No one is sniffing your traffic and sending a message to remove their bids faster than your order can arrive. Maybe you are accusing Gox of showing fake bids or bids they can take down themselves, I doubt it, but I dunno.
So if what you buy ends up less valuable later it turns out you weren't actually investing?
I really don't understand the definition. If you buy a share of stock and later it is still a share of stock up or down was that investing? Maybe dividends make the deference?
Such a large order would totally shock the system. But you are right, your order, if you put a low enough price in, would be cleared as soon as it goes in, and you cash out.
Although as crappy as Gox has been, it wouldn't surprise me if there was some shadiness in removing bids or having fake bids up.
Investing doesn't require it to be more valuable, but represents intent in actually creating value.
Quote:
Originally Posted by AlbertoKnox
So Tom and I both think buying bitcoin is speculation by these definitions. But I also think it is investing by that definition. These definitions seems good as any to me and they definitely overlap.
I'm not a huge fan of dictionary definitions for things that are technical, and I use the distinction to describe a clear difference in how things work. Anyone who buys bitcoins does not add any value. Bitcoins by themselves don't produce any actual value. Businesses that use Bitcoins certainly have that possibility. If you purchased shares in a Bitcoin poker site, you would be creating value (or at least attempting to). Creating Bitcoin itself would be considered investing.
By those definitions, buying bitcoins could be considered investing, although I don't like such a broad definition that the distinction becomes meaningless. I think you can invest in Bitcoin technology (which you are doing), you can use Bitcoin as a store of value.
People buying bitcoins can be a signal for the market to pay more attention to Bitcoins and develop businesses that take advantage of it, but that's another issue. A market that is built hugely on speculation is one that is not going to be healthy long term. I agree with you that there can be some benefits in using Bitcoins, although there are a lot of challenges in the way of getting there. I don't want to get into a speculators game without the fundamentals being there. I was a bull at $2, but what we saw last year was complete mania (and it rightfully went down). The only stories I still see is amateurs getting completely pwned and until the fundamental issues I saw last year go away, which might not even be possible, I'm a bear. But with this low of a market cap, big swings are still really possible.