Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Apple discussion thread Apple discussion thread

09-27-2019 , 12:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by grizy
Just assuming about 6.5% Rm * ~1.1 beta + ~3% rf (30 year government bond). That looks closer to 10 now I type it out so implied long term gr
30 year is about 2%
Apple discussion thread Quote
09-27-2019 , 01:48 PM
9% then. Last time I looked was a few months ago.
Apple discussion thread Quote
10-28-2019 , 01:24 PM
RSI is almost at 80 heading into earnings, look I get on a year over year basis it's not up that much but it traded down to the $140s in January. We already know about the buyback and flood of passive money, still the rush of upgrades is kind of nuts. Post earnings I'll be looking to get involved, still waiting for some kind of short term blow off and that seems like as good of a catalyst as any.
Apple discussion thread Quote
10-29-2019 , 11:05 PM
Air Pod Pro looks pretty sweet. I might have to hit up one of them Geniuses to hook me up.
Apple discussion thread Quote
12-05-2019 , 03:26 AM
Apple has been a horrible investment for me. Im only up 148%.
Apple discussion thread Quote
01-03-2020 , 02:02 AM
Apple hit $300 today. It has now outperformed Amazon and Microsoft for my timing anyway. Plus dividends....

What is the bear case now?
Apple discussion thread Quote
01-03-2020 , 10:38 AM
I think the bear case is Apple is overpriced for what it is (a solid cash cow) and is particularly vulnerable to disruptions to iPhone. At a PE of ~25, Apple is priced more like a growth stock and there isn't any indication that's justified given its failure to break into Indian market and stagnant unit sales growth of iPhones. That makes the stock a hold at best IMO. I am also concerned Apple is particularly vulnerable to a Samsung Note exploding battery fiasco/recall that causes Apple to basically lose an entire product cycle.

The bull case I think is Apple's user base continues to grow (a lot of stagnant unit sales is caused by product cycles lengthening from 1-2 years to 2-3 years) and Apple may still have a lot of room to monetize the user base.

I thought it was a good buy at ~12 P/E as one of the best cows in the world but now I am more like... meh.
Apple discussion thread Quote
01-05-2020 , 01:36 PM
Market P/E is at 25 so they're valued as if they will perform in line with the market. Although I admit I'm not a buyer /adder at these levels either.

Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Well, we haven't had a recession yet. On the long term performance? I've been spot on. On short/short-medium term trends? I've been close to dead wrong. I can't pick Apple at all.

Long term, my main argument that we talked about a lot was that Microsoft was better value than Apple and had more room to run. I got laughed at for that. Result (for 5 years):


hiya total returns (dividends reinvested) using your (objectively bad-timed) starting date for apple:

$AAPL: 28.6%
$MSFT: 26.8%
Apple discussion thread Quote
01-05-2020 , 02:43 PM
Apple gets crushed by Microsoft and the Nasdaq for 5+ years since the debate started
It briefly gets hyperinflated as a headline stock in a fed-inflated market and nudges just above
Bulls jump in to declare victory after years of silence.

If anything shows that the bulls were amazing wrong, that is it. Everything went right for Apple and did no better than follow the market. You had ZERO chance of meaningful performance with high downside risk should a recession happen (Apple is a luxury good priced on 40% margins that are completely unsustainable in a recession). That the definition of a dumb bet.

Congratulations though and if you take all your profit now, I highly doubt you'll regret it. If you had $1.3 trillion dollars there is zero chance you'd own Apple because there isn't the return to justify it, especially given the risk, so why would own a fraction of it?
Apple discussion thread Quote
01-05-2020 , 03:14 PM
hurr durr
Apple discussion thread Quote
01-05-2020 , 10:15 PM
lol tard
Apple discussion thread Quote
01-06-2020 , 01:51 PM
https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2019/...ple-investors/

I'm pretty sure the market has stopped caring about anything
Apple discussion thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 04:41 PM
Apple in beast mode.

Remember when people in the thread were predicting disaster in 2013? because lol "iOS7 is a disaster?"

Not bad for a hardware company.

Last edited by WorldBoFree; 07-31-2020 at 04:49 PM.
Apple discussion thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 11:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Apple gets crushed by Microsoft and the Nasdaq for 5+ years since the debate started
It briefly gets hyperinflated as a headline stock in a fed-inflated market and nudges just above
Bulls jump in to declare victory after years of silence.

If anything shows that the bulls were amazing wrong, that is it. Everything went right for Apple and did no better than follow the market. You had ZERO chance of meaningful performance with high downside risk should a recession happen (Apple is a luxury good priced on 40% margins that are completely unsustainable in a recession). That the definition of a dumb bet.

Congratulations though and if you take all your profit now, I highly doubt you'll regret it. If you had $1.3 trillion dollars there is zero chance you'd own Apple because there isn't the return to justify it, especially given the risk, so why would own a fraction of it?
This aged horribly
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-01-2020 , 04:25 PM
Even if Microsoft was up more than Apple if you go back exactly 5 years from today (which its not), that doesnt mean Apple bulls were lol horribly wrong. I hope all my investments that are up over %300 in five years are “amazingly wrong” lol.

I bought both. Both have crushed.

Microsoft rumored to be in talks of taking over the US side of tik tok. Win win.
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 11:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by WorldBoFree
Even if Microsoft was up more than Apple if you go back exactly 5 years from today (which its not)
Um, what?



Microsoft still kicking the living **** out of Apple on the 5 year, even after Apple got a massive boost from being a corona haven (thanks, giant stimulus checks and people stuck at home).

Quote:
that doesnt mean Apple bulls were lol horribly wrong. I hope all my investments that are up over %300 in five years are “amazingly wrong” lol.
It's certainly turned out better than I expected, but it's really just been part of a tech bubble run. Apple fundamentals (and growth) are horrible for its valuation. They were horrible 100% lower, but bubbles are bubbles and they have a mind of their own.

Quote:
I bought both. Both have crushed.
And yet you're only a buttboy for Apple. You never cheerlead about the one that crushed Apple and that I suggested to buy instead of Apple.

Quote:
Microsoft rumored to be in talks of taking over the US side of tik tok. Win win.
The Microsoft grand tradition of horrible acquisitions continues, sadly. Maybe this one will actually work for them. Not hopeful.
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 04:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BigPoppa
I have a confession to make:

I talked someone out of buying a ****load of Apple stock 1997.


Girl I was dating said her parents were interested in buying a lot (probably high 5 figures, maybe low 6 figures) of Apple stock and asked my opinion. I told her it was a bad idea to put so much of their money (they weren't rich) into one company and suggested an index fund instead.


How was I to ****ing know? This was before iTunes, the iPod, the iPhone, and even the goddamned iMac hadn't been introduced yet. Macbooks with lithium ion batteries were randomly bursting into flames. Apple was a ****ty company with no market share. This was like someone telling me in 1990 they wanted to bet everything on the Braves to win the pennant next year and me telling them not to. They suck, they've sucked for years, and there's no indication they'll ever stop sucking; then suddenly Steve Jobs is Tom Glavine and I look like an *******.


Good thing we never married, because I'd be catching **** every single time Apple was in the news.
You only cost them about $310 million dollars not including dividends. If all dividends were reinvested probably closer to a billion dollars.
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 05:16 PM
MSFT going into a casual social media business is a sign of desperation.
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 05:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chytry
MSFT going into a casual social media business is a sign of desperation.
I don't have an opinion, personally, but I'm curious why you think that.
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 06:34 PM
Tooth going on here about how he was right because MSFT outperformed AAPL seems like super dishonest revisionist history. I don't see him in this thread arguing for MSFT as an investment - his references to Microsoft were almost entirely about how Microsoft with their tablet offerings and maybe Windows Phone, present a major existential risk for Apple. Which is not quite how things played out. MSFT's resurgence is mostly about Azure and Office and has little to do with Tooth's thesis here. It seems like a few years ago, after all the things he predicted never came to pass, Tooth pivoted to "MSFT vs AAPL" stock performance, which wasn't why he went on about Microsoft here. The point was Microsoft as a competitor and an existential risk, not as as a stock comp.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Truthsayer
The trouble for Apple now is that we're approaching 1995. Phones are reaching a state where Apple's initial design advantages are declining, and competing software is becoming compelling. See Android - from 0 to 70% in three years - and Windows Phone 8, which will integrate perfectly with Windows 8/9, its apps and ecosystem as it slowly gets installed onto a billion PCs.

On the tablet side, hardware is for the first time getting fast enough that it can run full Windows with a good experience. If you've used a Surface Pro you'll realize how vastly superior the experience is to an iPad. Battery life, ecosystem, inertia and lack of sales channels and supply of parts (there's a severe lack of touch screen components) are the only reason Windows tablets aren't destroying the iPad yet, but they will. It'll be Mac vs PC all over again and Apple will get killed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Truthsayer
There is no evidence of the market wanting anything except Windows when they purchase a full operating system. And full operating systems have, just this year, become viable on tablets, something which vastly improves the experience and usability over iOS/Android once the kinks are ironed out. Within a few years they'll be viable on phones - Windows Blue already shares much of its code with Windows Phone, and makes it trivial to developer for both simultaneously.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Truthsayer
They nearly went bankrupt on the Mac when their sole natural advantage disappeared over time. They'll go bankrupt again when far superior software makers - Microsoft then and Microsoft and Google now - can leverage a superior system that works over all hardware. Tablet and phone hardware is now finally getting to that point where this happening. Competitor software, complexity and range is also overtaking Apple, and Apple's response so far with iOS7 has been to copy everyone else and reduce their existing advantages. Ecosystem is not enough - Microsoft have a bigger one with their installed base on PCs and in businesses and they will leverage that onto phones and tablets. Google's Android is finally becoming polished and already has an Apple equivalent and in some cases superior ecosystem. You can't maintain 35% industry killing profits when you're like everyone else in the industry and have no software or hardware or aesthetic advantage left. You need to be heavily differentiated, which they no longer are with this latest update (see my Windows Phone comparison video above).
Quote:
Originally Posted by Truthsayer
The luxury aesthetic, consistency, and feel of high end perfection feel is gone with this update - they've made themselves much closer to Android, which is an enormous mistake given that they need the high end look to sell at a premium vs their competitors. Feature wise, they are inferior to Android and Windows Phone. Looks, polish and ecosystem are all they have, and they just ceded their edge on the first two to their competitors.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Truthsayer
You guys simply don't understand consumer sentiment. Microsoft are a lock to destroy the iPad and Android in tablets. I'm going to make a prediction: By the end of 2014, Windows will have over 50% of the global tablet market. I'm more wary about predicting the end of this year, but I'm going to throw out 20% of global share.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Truthsayer
So yes, I think they're a total lock to be the dominant player in the tablet market within two years. Which is very bad news for the iPad and Apple. Flow on effects with shared apps, settings and ecosystems on PCs, tablets and Windows Phone will further drive down Apple products as the installed base gets larger and larger. Phones are a different kettle of fish and Apple have a fighting chance here with a tech breakthrough, but they're fighting uphill in a Microsoft world. PC or tablet -> phone ecosystem adoption will be a big driving force; Phone -> tablet, and phone -> PC adoption are non existent as Apple have proven (Mac shipments actually went down slightly from last year).

So I think Apple are finished as a market leading mega cap company baring a major unlikely technical breakthrough like a transparent wraparound phone. Total profit is going to decline further and further, and the $50 billion share buyback and increased dividend means their cash is going to decline too. No one should be buying Apple for a long term investment.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Truthsayer
And despite this Apple saturation, they have 12% Mac market share, and declining since Windows 8 came out. Macs are irrelevant and will never be an important part of Apple valuation or their future growth. Because of the small installed base, they also have no crossover or ecosystem benefits for selling profitable high volume items (phones and tablets). The opposite is the case with Windows 8/9, which is huge in terms of pushing sales into phones and tablets via a highly unified ecosystem, which will be on a billion PCs within a few years.

Let me ask you though: What does Apple have now that Blackberry didn't in 2008? Blackberry had lock in, massive cult following ("Crackberry"), ubiquitous in business, and highly functional.
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 09:24 PM
Fading Tooth has been an absolutely incredible run

Apple, Netflix, Bitcoin, Tesla

oof
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 09:50 PM
He's perpetually lost, feel bad for him
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 10:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by candybar
Tooth going on here about how he was right because MSFT outperformed AAPL seems like super dishonest revisionist history.
Not at all; it was broad months-long discussion when Apple was $700 (pre-split) and Microsoft $25. I was harping on Microsoft being undervalued and Apple being a bad buy.

The truth is I called you out as a fraud in another thread, and now despite a supposed busy wall street job you're spending time trawling (dishonestly) my post history?

Quote:
I don't see him in this thread arguing for MSFT as an investment - his references to Microsoft were almost entirely about how Microsoft with their tablet offerings and maybe Windows Phone, present a major existential risk for Apple. Which is not quite how things played out. MSFT's resurgence is mostly about Azure and Office and has little to do with Tooth's thesis here. It seems like a few years ago, after all the things he predicted never came to pass, Tooth pivoted to "MSFT vs AAPL" stock performance, which wasn't why he went on about Microsoft here. The point was Microsoft as a competitor and an existential risk, not as as a stock comp.
That was what was discussed in the Apple thread. I was banging on Microsoft like crazy in other threads and mocking Apple. So nice try bro, but I posted about it so much when it was $25 and Wall Street was convinced it was "dead money" that I was actually pissing everyone off at the time with how much I liked it.

The iPad certainly died a bad death. The iPhone however has continued to do very well.
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 10:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheMVP
Fading Tooth has been an absolutely incredible run

Apple, Netflix
Netflix and Apple have definitely run longer than I thought they would. My posted positions in the Netflix thread crushed overall (hundreds of percent cumulatively).

Apple has performed terribly relative to alternatives despite everything going right for it.

Quote:
Bitcoin, Tesla

oof
I've crushed both bitcoin and Tesla. If you faded me on bitcoin (I said it was a "strong buy" at $250 and twice called tops), you'd be broke. If you faded me on Tesla you'd be about -1000% given my options performance. Do you not realize that fading means "taking the opposite side of"?
Apple discussion thread Quote
08-09-2020 , 10:16 PM
hahaha

to be fair he's not 'lost' he's a troll

the trolls playbook is to never back down and forever take the contrarian view no matter how badly and how long they get owned

you shouldn't feel bad for because of his losing positions but for the fact that trolling 2+2 is the most important thing in his life

sad!
Apple discussion thread Quote

      
m