Quote:
Originally Posted by ToothSayer
Short term, yes. Long term, no. Why do you think US growth has been so sluggish, and wages flat to going backward, since China started needlessly duplicating US factories? There are square miles of factories making everything from computer chips to steel that was once made perfectly well in the US, with enormous capital and debt costs (to the US) in losing the output of those productive factories and having to retool and reskill rather than reaping the profits of that knowhow for a good period of time.
There is no reason, except for China's theft and anti-free-trade practices, that the US couldn't grow at 90s levels or better and have much lower debt today, given its huge lead in knowhow and capital. That's real economic damage that's happened in real time. A bit of short term pain to cut out that cancer is worth it. It should have been done in 2005 or 2010.
The idea that Trump is protectionist, that he's anti free trade, that a trade war will be bad for everyone (long term), is a bull**** narrative. The opposite is true. We're already in a huge trade war where we're bending over and letting others plunder our wealth. Trump is wanting to increase free trade and stop trade wars. When US companies are hit with large tariffs and targeted laws to stop them selling in China or Europe, but European and Chinese goods can just be dumped here with no restrictions, that is the US being killed in a trade war. Much of US debt has been the papering over of that loss of wealth.
I disagree with this. The US has not been struggling because of the actions of China. The US has been struggling because of the actions of the US.
The post 90s economic picture in the US is characterized by a cyclical balance sheet recession (not an income statement recession). A balance sheet recession takes much longer to work off.
To be clear, I am referring to the balance sheets of individual citizens. Basically private debt was too high (marked poignantly by sub-prime). Since then we have seen a rather rapid decline of the middle class in the US.
The middle class is the engine of growth.
Current policy favors those with established capital and preserves wealth while it hinders those without it.
When you combine this with costly efforts to save the petro dollar, much of American capital has been wasted on frivolous consumption (the citizen's credit card) and destructive foreign policy (the government's credit card).
Sound money, interest rates, tax policy, etc., would have prevented this largesse in the first place (think Vietnam).
The only answer is a return sound practices on both the individual and national level.